TL;DR
This paper presents a novel multiscale computational model of the mouse heart that links cellular-level electromechanical processes to whole-organ function. By simulating cardiac mechanics at physiological temperatures and heart rates, the model successfully reproduces experimental pressure-volume data and highlights the critical role of length- and velocity-dependent feedback in explaining the discrepancies between single-cell and whole-organ cardiac behavior.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding how individual cardiac cells generate force and how these cellular mechanisms translate to the complex pumping action of the entire heart is a fundamental challenge in cardiovascular physiology. While models exist for individual components (electrophysiology, contraction), integrating them into a comprehensive, biophysically realistic model of a whole organ, especially one that operates under physiological conditions (body temperature, high heart rates), has been difficult. Specifically, the paper addresses the significant differences observed between the tension generated by isolated cardiac cells and the pressure measured in a beating heart. These discrepancies are thought to arise from the complex interplay of cellular deformation (length and stretch rate) with excitation-contraction coupling, but the precise mechanisms and their quantitative contribution remain debated. Furthermore, existing models often rely on data from different species or non-physiological conditions, limiting their direct applicability to specific experimental models like the mouse, which is widely used in research.
Methods
The authors developed a novel, biophysically based, multiscale electromechanical model of the murine heart. The model integrates two key components:
- Cellular Electrophysiology and Contraction Model: This component is built upon existing models but adapted for mouse physiology. It incorporates a data-driven calcium transient model and a four-state Markov model for sarcomere dynamics, including troponin binding, tropomyosin, and crossbridge kinetics. Crucially, it explicitly models length- and velocity-dependent feedback mechanisms, which are known to influence force generation.
- Whole-Organ Model: The cellular model is embedded within a larger framework representing the entire mouse ventricle. This includes:
- Finite Element Method (FEM): A detailed 112-element cubic Hermite mesh derived from MRI data is used to represent the heart's geometry.
- Constitutive Law: The Guccione constitutive law is employed to describe the passive material properties of cardiac tissue, with parameters adjusted to match experimental passive inflation data.
- Electrophysiology: A dense grid with ~0.1 mm spacing is used for detailed electrical activation modeling.
- Hemodynamics: A three-element Windkessel model is used to simulate blood flow and pressure dynamics during ejection.
- Coupling: The model integrates these components to simulate a full cardiac cycle, from diastole to ejection and relaxation.
A key methodological aspect is the extensive parameter sensitivity analysis performed at both the cellular and whole-organ levels. This analysis helps identify which parameters are well-constrained by experimental data and where new data would be most beneficial for refining the model.
Datasets
The study utilized several datasets for model development and validation:
- Electrophysiology Data: Data from Li et al. (2011) based on comprehensive experimental data from Andersson et al. (2009) for the calcium transient.
- Cellular Mechanics Data: Various experimental data from the literature for isometric twitch tension, relaxation times (RT50, RT90), and strain-rate response using sinusoidal analysis. These were used to parameterize the cellular model.
- Whole-Organ Data:
- In vivo MRI data: Used for mesh generation and volume estimation.
- Pressure-Volume (PV) measurements: Obtained from in vivo catheterization to capture end-diastolic pressure (EDP), aortic pressure, and pressure-volume transients.
- Passive inflation data: From ex vivo hearts to estimate material properties.
The authors also mention using data from other species and lower temperatures for initial parameterization, but emphasize the importance of using mouse-specific data at physiological conditions for validation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Velocity Dependence is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that a significant velocity dependence of tension is essential for bridging the gap between single-cell tension transients and whole-organ pressure transients. This implies that how quickly the cardiac muscle is stretched or shortened plays a more critical role than previously appreciated in determining the overall pumping function.
- Length-Dependent Activation Matters: While filament overlap contributes to length-dependent tension, the model highlights the importance of length-dependent activation (LDA) in shaping the pressure transients, particularly in influencing ejection duration and relaxation.
- Multiscale Modeling Unlocks Insights: By integrating cellular mechanisms into a whole-organ model, the study reveals emergent behaviors that are not apparent at the cellular level alone. This approach allows for a more comprehensive understanding of how cellular properties translate to organ-level function.
- Parameter Identifiability is Key: The detailed sensitivity analysis provides a roadmap for future experimental work, pinpointing which cellular parameters are well-constrained and which require more precise measurements (e.g., Ca2+-TnC binding rates at physiological temperatures) to improve model accuracy.
- Physiological Conditions are Essential: Simulating at body temperature and physiological heart rates (6-10 Hz) is critical for accurate comparison with experimental data and for revealing limitations in existing models that might be masked under less physiological conditions.
Key Results
- The developed multiscale electromechanical model shows good agreement with in vivo experimental pressure and volume measurements at physiological temperatures and pacing frequencies.
- The model successfully reproduces the differences between single-cell tension transients and whole-organ pressure transients, primarily by incorporating strong velocity-dependent tension.
- Parameter sensitivity analysis revealed that while some parameters are well-constrained by available data, others (e.g., Ca2+-TnC binding rates) would benefit from more precise experimental measurements at physiological conditions.
- The model demonstrated that electrical activation patterns can significantly influence calcium transients in tissue, impacting ejection fraction.
- The study showed that fibre distribution within the ventricular wall plays a role in preventing excessive apex-base distance changes during contraction.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Limitations: Despite efforts to use physiological data, some parameters were still based on data obtained at lower temperatures or from different species. The authors acknowledge that more experimental data at body temperature for specific cellular mechanisms (e.g., Ca2+-TnC binding) would further constrain the model.
- Homogeneous Properties: The model assumes homogeneous length-dependence properties throughout the tissue, which is likely an oversimplification. Future work could investigate regional variations in these properties.
- Diastolic Model Simplification: The model uses a simplified representation of diastole, as the focus was on earlier cardiac phases. More detailed diastolic modeling could be explored.
- Mechanical Boundary Conditions: The determination of optimal mechanical boundary conditions remains a challenge.
- Future Directions: The authors propose using this framework for future research, including investigating genetic knockout mice to link gene changes to whole-heart function and extending the electrophysiology modeling to whole-organ electromechanics. They also suggest that explicit mention of isometric tension during sinusoidal analysis experiments would be beneficial for cell model parameterization.
Summary updated