An Adaptive Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control Method for a Two-Joint Manipulator

Jianliang Xu, Zhen Sui, Wannning Wang, Feng XuProcesses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Adaptive Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control (ADITSMC) method for robotic arms, designed to improve trajectory tracking accuracy and reduce chattering, even in the presence of disturbances. By combining adaptive control with a discrete integral terminal sliding mode approach and incorporating a one-step delay estimation for disturbances, the ADITSMC scheme significantly outperforms existing methods in simulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robotic arms are increasingly used in high-precision industrial applications. However, real-world operation involves factors like changing load conditions, external disturbances, and system friction, which can lead to deviations in their motion trajectories. This makes achieving precise trajectory control challenging, especially in complex and unpredictable environments. Existing control methods often struggle with model uncertainties and can suffer from "chattering" – rapid oscillations in control signals that degrade performance and can even damage the system. This paper aims to address these issues by developing a more robust and accurate control strategy for robotic arms.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an Adaptive Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control (ADITSMC) scheme. Here's a breakdown of the key components:

  • Dynamic Modeling: The authors first establish a dynamic model for a two-joint robotic arm using the Lagrangian dynamics method.
  • Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control (DITSMC): This forms the foundation of their approach. It's a type of sliding mode control that aims to drive the system's state to a desired sliding surface and keep it there. The "integral terminal" aspect suggests it incorporates both integral and terminal (fast convergence) properties to improve accuracy and speed.
  • Adaptive Switching Term: To combat chattering and further enhance disturbance rejection, an adaptive switching term is introduced. This term's gain is adjusted dynamically based on the system's state, allowing it to respond to varying conditions.
  • One-Step Delay Estimation: To handle unknown disturbances and discretization errors, a one-step delay estimation method is employed. This helps the controller anticipate and compensate for these uncertainties.
  • Stability Proof: The paper includes a theoretical proof demonstrating the stability of the proposed ADITSMC approach.

The ADITSMC scheme is presented as an improvement over classical Discrete Sliding Mode Control (DSMC) and Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control (DITSMC) by integrating adaptive elements and disturbance estimation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulation experiments using a defined two-joint manipulator model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptive Control for Robustness: The adaptive nature of the switching gain is crucial. It allows the controller to dynamically adjust its response to disturbances, leading to smoother control signals and better tracking than fixed-gain methods.
  • Disturbance Estimation is Key: The one-step delay estimation of disturbances, combined with the adaptive approach, significantly improves the system's ability to reject external influences and internal uncertainties.
  • Chattering Mitigation: The paper highlights that while DITSMC improves upon DSMC, it can still exhibit oscillations. ADITSMC's adaptive switching term is specifically designed to further suppress these chattering effects, leading to more stable and precise control.
  • Simplicity and Effectiveness: The authors emphasize that their ADITSMC scheme is relatively simpler to implement compared to some other advanced control techniques (like those involving neural networks) while achieving superior performance.

Key Results

The simulation results demonstrate the effectiveness of the ADITSMC scheme:

  • Trajectory Tracking Error: ADITSMC maintained trajectory tracking errors within 0.004 radians for each joint, significantly outperforming DITSMC and DSMC.
  • Control Torque Variation: The absolute integral of control torque variations (IAFV) was calculated at 5.85 × 10³, which was lower than DITSMC (1.37 × 10⁴) and DSMC (1.73 × 10⁴), indicating smoother control actions.
  • Mean Square Error (MSE): ADITSMC achieved the lowest MSE (2.19 × 10⁻⁶) compared to DITSMC (4.37 × 10⁻⁵) and DSMC (7.12 × 10⁻⁴), signifying better overall tracking accuracy.
  • Robustness to Noise: Even under white noise disturbances, ADITSMC effectively reduced tracking errors and exhibited minimal oscillations in control torque.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Complexity: The current study focuses on a two-joint manipulator. The authors suggest future work to investigate the ADITSMC scheme for multi-degree-of-freedom robotic arm models to assess its effectiveness in more complex scenarios.
  • Disturbance Estimation: While the one-step delay estimation is effective, the authors acknowledge that it may not fully estimate all disturbances. They propose exploring the use of state observers or disturbance observers for more comprehensive disturbance estimation in future research. This could further enhance the algorithm's disturbance rejection capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

In response to the trajectory tracking control problem of manipulators under measurement disturbances, a novel multi-input multi-output discrete integral terminal sliding mode control scheme is proposed. Initially, this scheme establishes a dynamic model of a two-joint manipulator based on the Lagrangian dynamics analysis method. Subsequently, a discrete integral terminal sliding mode control law based on the dynamic model of the two joints is designed, incorporating delayed estimation of unknown disturbances and discretization errors in the manipulator system. To enhance the trajectory tracking accuracy of the control scheme and suppress the impact of sliding mode chattering on the manipulator system, an adaptive switching term is introduced into the discrete integral terminal sliding mode control law. The paper derives an adaptive discrete integral terminal sliding mode control scheme and provides stability proof for the proposed approach. Simulation experiments are conducted to compare the proposed adaptive discrete integral terminal sliding mode control scheme with classical discrete sliding mode control schemes and discrete integral terminal sliding mode control schemes. The simulation results demonstrate that the designed adaptive discrete integral terminal sliding mode control scheme maintains trajectory tracking errors within 0.004 radians for each joint of the manipulator, with minimal changes in control torque for each joint. The absolute integral of the control torque variations is calculated at 5.85×103, which is lower than other control schemes, thereby validating the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2024adaptive,
  author = {Jianliang Xu and Zhen Sui and Wannning Wang and Feng Xu},
  title = {{An Adaptive Discrete Integral Terminal Sliding Mode Control Method for a Two-Joint Manipulator}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12061106},
}
Figure