An Adaptive Control Method with Disturbance Estimation for Underwater Manipulation

Yiqun Wang, Shuo Li, Qiyan Tian, Yiping Li, Honglin Sun, Yuexing ZhangJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel adaptive control strategy for underwater vehicle-manipulator systems (UVMS) that effectively estimates and compensates for disturbances like ocean currents and manipulator movements. This approach improves station keeping and trajectory tracking by enhancing robustness without sacrificing performance, even in dynamic and uncertain underwater environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater operations, especially those involving manipulation, are inherently challenging due to the harsh and unpredictable marine environment. Underwater Vehicle-Manipulator Systems (UVMS) are crucial for tasks like scientific exploration, maintenance, and rescue. However, controlling these systems precisely is difficult because they are subject to various disturbances. These include:

  • External Disturbances: Ocean currents, which can be time-varying and unpredictable, exert forces and moments on the vehicle.
  • Internal Disturbances: The motion of the manipulator itself introduces dynamic couplings and forces that affect the vehicle's stability and control.
  • Model Uncertainties: Imperfect knowledge of the UVMS's dynamics, such as variations in hydrodynamic coefficients, further complicates control.

Existing control methods often struggle to handle these combined disturbances effectively. Some methods are overly conservative, sacrificing performance for robustness, while others require extensive tuning or additional sensors, which are often impractical in underwater settings. This paper aims to develop a control scheme that can accurately estimate and mitigate these disturbances in real-time, leading to improved precision and stability for UVMS operations.

Methods

The proposed solution is an adaptive control scheme that integrates a disturbance observer with an adaptive feedback controller. The core components are:

  • Disturbance Observer: This is a key innovation. Instead of relying on additional sensors to measure disturbances, the observer estimates them using feedback from the system's state errors and control inputs. This approach is designed to be less sensitive to sensor noise and more robust to the complexities of underwater environments. It lumps various internal and external disturbances into a single estimated term.
  • Adaptive Feedback Control: This part of the controller uses the estimated disturbance to adjust control gains dynamically. This allows the system to adapt to changing conditions and maintain stability.
  • Feedforward Term: The control law also includes a feedforward component that utilizes a prior dynamic model of the UVMS. This helps to proactively compensate for known forces and moments, further enhancing performance.

The control law is formulated in the task space, aiming to precisely navigate the end effector of the manipulator. The stability of the proposed control scheme is analyzed using a Lyapunov-like candidate function, demonstrating that the tracking error asymptotically converges to zero.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a custom-built variable structure robot (VSR) platform in a controlled pool environment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Disturbance Estimation without Extra Sensors: The most significant insight is the development of a disturbance observer that doesn't require additional specialized sensors. This is crucial for practical underwater applications where sensor deployment and maintenance are challenging.
  • Robustness Without Performance Sacrifice: The proposed method achieves robustness to disturbances without compromising nominal performance. This means that when disturbances are absent, the system's performance returns to its optimal level, unlike some conservative control strategies.
  • Quick Response to Disturbances: The disturbance observer allows for rapid identification and compensation of unexpected disturbances, leading to quick responses and improved closed-loop stability.
  • Unified Disturbance Handling: By lumping various internal and external disturbances into a single estimated term, the observer simplifies the control problem and makes it more manageable.
  • Task Space Control for UVMS: The paper emphasizes the suitability of task space control for UVMS, as it directly addresses the goal of precise end-effector positioning, which is critical for manipulation tasks.

Key Results

The effectiveness of the proposed control scheme was demonstrated through experiments on a variable structure robot (VSR) platform in a 3.5m depth-rated pool.

  • Attitude Control: In station keeping mode, the proposed scheme showed better stability and more prompt attenuation of time-varying disturbances (manipulator motion and simulated currents) compared to Sliding Mode Control (SMC). While SMC had a slightly quicker initial response, the proposed method maintained superior stability and recovered performance when disturbances lessened.
  • Trajectory Tracking: For end-effector trajectory tracking, the proposed scheme produced smoother trajectories than SMC, especially when approaching the target position. The position error curves asymptotically converged to zero, even under time-varying disturbances, indicating effective compensation.
  • Simulated Current: A simulated current (first-order Gauss-Markov process with a mean of 10 cm/s) was used to test the system's response to external disturbances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specialization for UVMS: The authors acknowledge that the proposed control scheme is specialized for underwater vehicle-manipulator systems.
  • Future Work: While not explicitly detailed, the success of this approach suggests potential for application to other complex robotic systems operating in dynamic environments. Further research could explore its scalability to different UVMS configurations and more complex operational scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, an adaptive control scheme with disturbance estimation is proposed for the station keeping and trajectory tracking of an underwater vehicle-manipulator system (UVMS) in a task space. The control of UVMSs encounters time-varying and lumped disturbances introduced by the motion of the manipulator and currents. The proposed control scheme includes an observer to identify disturbances without introducing additional sensors. Using state-of-the-art UVMS control technologies, it alleviates the restriction of the feedforward control applied to the UVMS. In addition, the proposed control scheme is not designed based on the worst case. In other words, the robustness of the controller is not achieved at the price of performance, and the performance of the controller can be recovered in the absence of disturbance. Meanwhile, the controller can also realize quick responses to attenuating disturbance and closed-loop stability when encountering an unexpected disturbance. The effectiveness of the proposed control scheme was demonstrated by a series of spatial trajectory tracking experiments under various disturbances. A limitation of this study is that the proposed control scheme is specialized for the underwater manipulation of UVMSs.
BibTeX
@article{wang2023adaptive,
  author = {Yiqun Wang and Shuo Li and Qiyan Tian and Yiping Li and Honglin Sun and Yuexing Zhang},
  title = {{An Adaptive Control Method with Disturbance Estimation for Underwater Manipulation}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11061113},
}
Figure