TL;DR
This study uses computer simulations to investigate how "amplitude cancellation" in surface EMG signals affects the accuracy of spike-triggered averaging (STA) for estimating motor unit properties. The findings reveal that amplitude cancellation significantly reduces the measured size of motor unit potentials, particularly when the EMG is rectified, potentially leading to misinterpretations of motor unit characteristics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Spike-triggered averaging (STA) is a common technique used to extract the electrical signal of individual motor units from surface electromyogram (EMG) recordings. This method relies on triggering the average based on the discharge times of a specific motor unit and then averaging the concurrently recorded EMG signal. The size of these averaged potentials is often used to infer properties of motor units, such as their size and synchronization. However, STA is based on several assumptions, including the absence of correlated activity between the motor unit of interest and other signals, and an adequate number of trigger events.
A key challenge arises because surface EMG signals are a composite of many motor unit potentials. When these potentials overlap in time, their positive and negative phases can cancel each other out, a phenomenon known as "amplitude cancellation." This cancellation can distort the shape and amplitude of the averaged signal, potentially leading to inaccurate estimations of motor unit properties. Furthermore, a common practice of rectifying the EMG signal before averaging introduces its own set of issues, including a nonlinear relationship with the original signal and a loss of information due to cancellation. This paper aims to systematically investigate how physiological factors like excitation level, motor unit conduction velocity, and motor unit synchronization influence amplitude cancellation and, consequently, the accuracy of STA.
Methods
The researchers employed a sophisticated computer simulation model of the first dorsal interosseus muscle. This model incorporated detailed physiological parameters, including:
- Motor Unit Properties: Distributions of recruitment thresholds, motor unit territories, and conduction velocities were based on established physiological data.
- Volume Conductor Model: A multi-layered model (skin, subcutaneous tissue, muscle) was used to simulate how electrical potentials propagate to the skin surface.
- EMG Simulation: Motor unit action potentials were generated and summed to create a simulated surface EMG signal.
- Spike-Triggered Averaging (STA): The simulation mimicked the STA procedure by triggering on the discharge times of individual motor units and averaging the simulated EMG. Three types of averages were computed:
- Interference EMG: Averaging the raw, simulated EMG.
- Rectified EMG: Averaging the rectified simulated EMG.
- No-Cancellation EMG: A simulated average where motor unit potentials were rectified before summing, thus preventing cancellation between opposite phases. This served as a ground truth for the motor unit's potential.
The study systematically varied three key physiological parameters:
- Excitation Level: Simulated at 5%, 10%, and 15% of maximal excitation.
- Motor Unit Conduction Velocity: Varied from 2.5 to 5 m/s.
- Motor Unit Synchronization: Imposed at different levels (quantified by common input strength, CIS).
The primary outcome measured was the area of the averaged motor unit potentials, which was compared across the different averaging methods and simulated conditions. An "amplitude cancellation index" was also calculated to quantify the degree of cancellation.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies entirely on computer simulations based on established physiological models and parameters.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Amplitude Cancellation is a Major Distortion: The core finding is that amplitude cancellation significantly reduces the measured size (area) of motor unit potentials when averaged from the surface EMG, especially when the EMG is rectified. This is a critical limitation for techniques relying on STA to estimate motor unit properties.
- Rectification Exacerbates the Problem: Rectifying the EMG signal before averaging leads to an even greater underestimation of motor unit potential size compared to averaging the raw interference EMG. This is because rectification amplifies negative phases, making them more susceptible to cancellation with positive phases.
- Excitation Level Matters: As excitation level increases, the underestimation of motor unit potential size in rectified EMG averages becomes more pronounced. This suggests that studies conducted at higher contraction intensities might be more prone to inaccurate motor unit size estimations.
- Conduction Velocity Plays a Role: Slower motor unit conduction velocities lead to longer motor unit potentials, increasing the likelihood of overlap and cancellation. This, in turn, results in a greater reduction in the measured potential size from rectified EMG averages.
- Synchronization Increases Potential Size, But Cancellation Limits It: While motor unit synchronization generally increases the measured potential size in both interference and rectified EMG averages (as expected), amplitude cancellation acts as a counteracting force, limiting the extent of this increase. This means the effect of synchronization on STA is not as straightforward as might be assumed.
- "No-Cancellation" EMG as a Gold Standard: The "no-cancellation" EMG simulation is crucial. By rectifying potentials before summing, it effectively removes cancellation, providing a more accurate representation of the underlying motor unit potential. Comparing STA from interference and rectified EMG to this "no-cancellation" signal highlights the impact of cancellation.
Key Results
- Linear Relationship: The percent decrease in the area of potentials from the rectified EMG was linearly related to the amount of amplitude cancellation in the interference EMG signal.
- Underestimation: Potentials averaged from the rectified EMG were consistently smaller than those from the no-cancellation EMG. For example, at 15% maximal excitation, the rectified EMG average was 75% smaller than the original potential for a small motor unit.
- Conduction Velocity Impact: At 5% maximal excitation, a decrease in mean motor unit conduction velocity from 5 m/s to 2.5 m/s led to a greater reduction in the rectified EMG potential area.
- Synchronization Effect: Motor unit synchronization increased the area of potentials derived from both interference and rectified EMGs, but cancellation limited this increase. For instance, with an average CIS of 2.0, the interference EMG potential area increased significantly, but was still substantially less than the no-cancellation EMG potential area.
- Experimental Validation: Preliminary analysis of experimental data from a subject with high motor unit synchronization showed that STA potentials increased with force level, consistent with simulation findings.
Limitations and Future Work
- Simulation Scope: The study acknowledges that its simulations were limited to low levels of excitation and specific EMG recordings.
- Experimental Data: While experimental data was used for preliminary validation, the primary findings are based on simulations.
- Motor Unit Properties: The paper notes that multiple motor unit properties (fiber length, recruitment limits, discharge rates, etc.) can influence cancellation, making it difficult to predict the exact impact on STA.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that these findings highlight limitations in using STA to quantify motor unit properties like number and size. They imply that alternative methods, such as motor nerve stimulation, might be more appropriate for accurate motor unit characterization. Further research could explore the impact of these cancellation effects across a wider range of physiological conditions and muscle types.
Summary updated