Amplified warming in tropical and subtropical cities at 2 °C climate change

Sarah Berk, Manoj Joshi, C. M. Goodess, Peer NowackResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Standard climate models often overlook the unique microclimates of medium-sized cities due to low spatial resolution. By combining Earth System Models (ESMs) with a novel machine-learning approach, this study reveals that 81% of tropical and subtropical medium-sized cities will experience warming that outpaces their rural surroundings, with some cities in India and China seeing temperature spikes more than double the regional projections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the Urban Heat Island (UHI) effect—where cities are significantly warmer than their rural counterparts—is well-documented, projecting how it will evolve under global climate change is notoriously difficult.

Current Earth System Models (ESMs) operate at scales far too coarse to "see" individual cities, often leading researchers to focus only on a few megacities. This leaves a massive data gap for medium-sized cities (populations between 300,000 and 1 million), which house a significant portion of the global urban population. Furthermore, these cities may not have reached "UHI saturation," meaning their local warming could respond more drastically to climate shifts than established megacities. The authors aim to bridge this gap by providing high-resolution surface temperature projections for 104 medium-sized cities in the tropics and subtropics.

Methods

The authors employ a "process-based machine learning" approach to downscale global climate projections to the city level.

  • The Model: They used a Regression Enhanced Random Forest (RERF). This hybrid model combines Ridge Regression (to capture robust linear relationships between climate variables) with a Random Forest (to handle complex, non-parametric residuals).
  • The "Delta Change" Technique: Instead of using absolute ESM values, which can be biased, the researchers calculated the change in key drivers (like humidity, precipitation, and vegetation) between pre-industrial levels and a 2 °C warming scenario. These "deltas" were then added to high-resolution historical observations to feed the ML model.
  • Predictors: The model was trained on variables known to influence UHI intensity, including the Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI), albedo, relative humidity, and city area.

Datasets

The study integrates several high-profile datasets:

  • Satellite Data: Terra MODIS for Land Surface Temperature (LST), vegetation indices, and albedo; ESA Land Cover maps for city boundaries.
  • Reanalysis: ERA5-Land for historical monthly humidity and precipitation.
  • Climate Projections: Outputs from five CMIP6 Earth System Models (including CanESM5 and UKESM1-1-LL) under the SSP3-7.0 emissions pathway.
  • City Selection: A curated list of 104 cities with populations of 300k–1M, located at latitudes < 40°, and filtered to exclude coastal or mountainous regions to isolate climatic drivers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Vegetation Gap: A primary driver of amplified urban warming is the projected change in rural vegetation. As regional areas "green" or gain moisture, they benefit from evaporative cooling. Cities, dominated by impervious surfaces and drainage systems, do not share this benefit, causing the temperature gap between city and country to widen.
  • Erosion of "Cool Islands": In arid regions like the Middle East, cities are sometimes "Urban Cool Islands" because of urban irrigation. The study finds these cool islands are likely to erode, with city temperatures rising faster than the surrounding desert.
  • Regional Hotspots: India and China are identified as particularly vulnerable. In these regions, the influence of vegetation on the SUHI is strong, and the projected changes suggest that urban dwellers will face heat stress far beyond what regional climate maps currently predict.

Key Results

  • Widespread Amplification: In 81% of the studied cities, the annual mean Surface UHI (SUHI) is projected to increase.
  • Quantified Warming: On average, the SUHI magnitude increases by 0.4 °C. This means while the surrounding region might warm by 2.2 °C, the city itself warms by 2.6 °C.
  • Extreme Cases: In 16% of cities (mostly in India and China), the mean LST is projected to increase by an additional 50–112% above the ESM projections for the surrounding area. For example, in Patiala, India, the city-specific warming is nearly double the regional background warming.
  • Model Accuracy: The RERF model performed exceptionally well on test data, achieving an $R^2$ of 0.87 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 0.86 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Static City Footprints: The study does not account for future urban expansion. Since larger cities generally have stronger UHIs, the reported warming is likely a conservative estimate.
  • Geographic Constraints: To keep the model manageable, the authors excluded coastal cities (where sea breezes complicate temperature) and mountainous cities. Future iterations could incorporate these complex topographies.
  • Daytime Focus: The primary results focus on daytime temperatures (13:30). While night-time data is included in the supplement, the authors note that daytime changes are generally more pronounced under these specific climate drivers.
  • Humidity and Health: While the study focuses on temperature (LST), the authors acknowledge that the interplay between rising temperatures and humidity is the next critical step for assessing true human survivability and "wet-bulb" risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Cities are often warmer than rural surroundings due to a phenomenon known as the urban heat island, which can be influenced by various factors, such as regional climate. Under climate change, cities face not only the challenge of increasing temperatures in their surrounding hinterland, but also the challenge of potential changes in their heat islands. Making projections of future climate at the city scale is difficult given limitations of Earth System Model (ESMs), which has limited studies to a small number of urban areas – mostly megacities. Here, we address these limitations by applying a novel process-based machine learning model to ESM outputs, to provide projections of changes in land surface temperature (LST) for 104 medium-sized cities (population 300K to 1M) in the subtropics and tropics. Under a 2°C global warming scenario, annual mean LST in 81% of these cities is projected to increase faster than the surrounding area. In 16% of these cities, mostly in India and China, mean LST is projected to increase by an additional 50–112% above ESM projections of the surrounding area. These findings suggest that the potential impacts of climate change are underestimated at present for millions of people in cities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berk2024amplified,
  author = {Sarah Berk and Manoj Joshi and C. M. Goodess and Peer Nowack},
  title = {{Amplified warming in tropical and subtropical cities at 2 °C climate change}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4623186/v1},
}
Figure