Ammonia-oxidizing archaea adapted better to the dark, alkaline oligotrophic karst cave than their bacterial counterparts

Qing Li, Xiaoyu Cheng, Xiaoyan Liu, Pengfei Gao, Hongmei Wang, Chuntian Su, Qibo HuangFrontiers in Microbiology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Subsurface karst caves provide unique opportunities to study the deep biosphere and microbial contributions to elemental cycling. While ammonia oxidation by ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and archaea (AOA) is well-documented in soil and marine environments, knowledge of these processes in the subsurface remains limited. This study investigated weathered rock and sediment samples from Xincuntun Cave, an alkaline karst cave in Guilin, China. Using high-throughput sequencing, qPCR of amoA genes, and potential nitrification rate (PNR) measurements, we found that AOA significantly dominated the ammonia-oxidizing community. AOA amoA gene copies outnumbered AOB by two to six orders of magnitude and contributed 48–100% of the PNR. Ecological modeling revealed that AOA community development was primarily driven by deterministic processes, whereas AOB communities were influenced by stochasticity. These findings confirm that AOA are better adapted to alkaline, oligotrophic karst environments, playing a fundamental role in subsurface nitrogen cycling.

Introduction

Nitrification is a critical two-step process in the global nitrogen cycle, with the aerobic oxidation of ammonia to nitrite serving as the rate-limiting step. In many environments, this process is mediated by ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB). However, the relative contributions and ecological strategies of these groups in extreme, nutrient-poor subsurface environments like karst caves are not well understood. Karst caves are characterized by darkness, high alkalinity, and oligotrophic conditions, making them ideal natural laboratories for studying the limits of the deep biosphere. This study aims to clarify which group dominates these environments and the environmental factors that shape their community assembly.

Methodology

Samples of weathered rock and loose sediments were collected from the Xincuntun (XCT) Cave, categorized into Entrance Nearby Zones (ENZ) and Dark Inner Zones (IZ). The research team employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Molecular Quantification: qPCR was used to quantify the amoA gene copies for both AOA and AOB.
  • High-Throughput Sequencing: Illumina MiSeq sequencing identified the taxonomic composition of the communities.
  • Activity Assays: Potential Nitrification Rates (PNR) were measured using selective inhibitors to differentiate between archaeal and bacterial contributions.
  • Ecological Modeling: The iCAMP (Infer Community Assembly Mechanisms by Phylogenetic-binning) framework was used to quantify the relative importance of deterministic versus stochastic assembly processes.
  • Network Analysis: Co-occurrence networks were constructed to explore interactions between AOA and AOB across different cave zones.

Results and Discussion

Community Diversity and Assembly

The study revealed a stark contrast between AOA and AOB communities. AOA amoA gene copies were found to be 100 to 1,000,000 times more abundant than those of AOB. Diversity indices showed that AOA maintained robust populations across both entrance and inner zones, whereas AOB populations were often sparse or near detection limits in the more extreme inner zones.

Alpha and beta diversity of AOA and AOB communities across different cave zones.

As shown in Figure 6, alpha diversity metrics (Chao1, Shannon, and Simpson) and PCoA clustering highlight the distinct ecological signatures of these groups. AOA communities were primarily shaped by deterministic processes (50.71%), indicating strong environmental selection. In contrast, AOB communities were dominated by stochastic processes (92.09%), suggesting that their presence in the cave is largely due to random dispersal or drift rather than specific adaptation to the alkaline, oligotrophic conditions.

Functional Contribution and Environmental Drivers

AOA were the primary drivers of nitrification, contributing between 48% and 100% of the measured PNR. In weathered rock samples near the cave entrance, AOA were the sole contributors to ammonia oxidation. Taxonomic analysis identified Nitrososphaera as the dominant AOA genus and Nitrosospira as the leading AOB genus.

Environmental analysis indicated that Total Organic Carbon (TOC), Ammonium ($NH_4^+$), and Chloride ($Cl^-$) were the most significant factors influencing community composition. AOA demonstrated a significantly larger niche breadth than AOB, allowing them to thrive in the low-TOC environments of the cave interior. Interestingly, co-occurrence networks in the inner zones showed positive associations between AOA and AOB, suggesting a collaborative survival strategy in these extreme habitats.

Conclusion

The findings of this study demonstrate that AOA are far better adapted to the alkaline, oligotrophic conditions of karst caves than AOB. Their higher gene abundance, deterministic assembly, and dominant functional contribution underscore their pivotal role in the nitrogen cycle of the subsurface biosphere. Future research should investigate the specific metabolic pathways, such as the hydroxypropionate/hydroxybutyrate cycle, that enable AOA to fix carbon efficiently in these dark, nutrient-limited environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Subsurface karst caves provide unique opportunities to study the deep biosphere, shedding light on microbial contribution to elemental cycling. Although ammonia oxidation driven by both ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) is well explored in soil and marine environments, our understanding in the subsurface biosphere still remained limited to date. To address this gap, weathered rock and sediment samples were collected from the Xincuntun Cave in Guilin City, an alkaline karst cave, and subjected to high-throughput sequencing and quantification of bacterial and archaeal <i>amoA</i>, along with determination of the potential nitrification rates (PNR). Results revealed that AOA dominated in ammonia oxidation, contributing 48-100% to the PNR, and AOA <i>amoA</i> gene copies outnumbered AOB by 2 to 6 orders. <i>Nitrososphaera</i> dominated in AOA communities, while <i>Nitrosopira</i> dominated AOB communities. AOA demonstrated significantly larger niche breadth than AOB. The development of AOA communities was influenced by deterministic processes (50.71%), while AOB communities were predominantly influenced by stochastic processes. TOC, NH<sub>4</sub><sup>+</sup>, and Cl<sup>-</sup> played crucial roles in shaping the compositions of ammonia oxidizers at the OTU level. Cross-domain co-occurrence networks highlighted the dominance of AOA nodes in the networks and positive associations between AOA and AOB, especially in the inner zone, suggesting collaborative effort to thrive in extreme environments. Their high gene copies, dominance in the interaction with ammonia oxidizing bacteria, expansive niche breadth and substantial contribution to PNR collectively confirmed that AOA better adapted to alkaline, oligotrophic karst caves environments, and thus play a fundamental role in nitrogen cycling in subsurface biosphere.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024ammonia,
  author = {Qing Li and Xiaoyu Cheng and Xiaoyan Liu and Pengfei Gao and Hongmei Wang and Chuntian Su and Qibo Huang},
  title = {{Ammonia-oxidizing archaea adapted better to the dark, alkaline oligotrophic karst cave than their bacterial counterparts}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2024.1377721},
}
Figure