Amino-acid selective isotope labeling enables simultaneous overlapping signal decomposition and information extraction from NMR spectra

Takuma Kasai, Shunsuke Ono, S. Koshiba, Masayuki Yamamoto, Toshiyuki Tanaka, Shiro Ikeda, T. KigawaJournal of Biomolecular NMR 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces SiPex, a novel NMR analysis method that combines amino-acid selective isotope labeling (AASIL) with tensor decomposition to simultaneously resolve overlapping signals and extract protein dynamics information. By treating spectral data as a multi-dimensional tensor, SiPex can decompose complex spectra and directly link amino acid identity to relaxation properties, bypassing the need for traditional chemical shift assignments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a powerful tool for studying the structure and dynamics of biomolecules like proteins. However, a major hurdle in protein NMR analysis is signal overlap, where signals from different residues in the protein can have very similar spectral positions. This overlap makes it difficult to accurately measure signal intensities, which are crucial for quantitative analyses, particularly for protein dynamics studies using techniques like 15N relaxation measurements. Traditional methods often rely on multi-dimensional NMR experiments or spectral reconstruction, which can be time-consuming or introduce inaccuracies. Furthermore, assigning specific signals to specific amino acid residues (chemical shift assignment) is a prerequisite for most quantitative analyses, a process that can be challenging for large or intrinsically disordered proteins.

Methods

The core innovation presented is SiPex (Stable-isotope-assisted Parameter extraction). This method leverages two key components:

  1. Amino-Acid Selective Isotope Labeling (AASIL): Instead of uniformly labeling the entire protein with isotopes (like 15N or 13C), AASIL involves selectively labeling specific amino acids. The authors utilize a "SiCode" labeling scheme, which uses a specific pattern of isotopic labeling across multiple samples to encode the identity of amino acids. This creates a "labeling ratio" for each amino acid type in each sample.
  2. Tensor Decomposition: SiPex treats the NMR data as a multi-dimensional tensor. Specifically, it combines spectra from different AASIL samples (providing amino acid information) with spectra acquired under different relaxation conditions (providing dynamics information). This creates a four-order tensor. Tensor decomposition (specifically, PARAFAC/CANDECOMP, also known as PD) is then applied to this tensor. The decomposition separates the mixed signals into individual components, each representing a unique residue or set of residues.

The novelty lies in how SiPex integrates these two aspects. The intensity patterns arising from the AASIL labeling scheme are used as an additional dimension in the tensor. This "SiCode dimension" provides amino acid information directly, allowing the decomposition algorithm to distinguish between overlapping signals that might otherwise appear identical in standard spectral dimensions. Crucially, the loading vectors of the decomposed components contain both the amino acid identity (from the SiCode dimension) and the relaxation information (from the relaxation dimension).

Datasets

The study uses two main protein datasets:

  • Human ubiquitin 3A mutant (Ub3A): This protein was used to demonstrate the SiCode labeling scheme and the decomposition of simulated overlapping signals.
  • Nrf2-ECH-homology 2 (Neh2) domain of the Nrf2 protein: This intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) was used to showcase SiPex's ability to handle crowded spectral regions typical of IDPs.

The authors also mention using a uniformly labeled protein for comparison with conventional methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Amino Acid Identity as a Spectral Dimension: The most significant insight is the clever use of AASIL to create an "amino acid identity" dimension within the NMR data tensor. This dimension provides a powerful constraint for tensor decomposition, enabling the separation of signals that are degenerate in chemical shift.
  • Bypassing Chemical Shift Assignments: SiPex offers a paradigm shift by directly linking amino acid identity to relaxation properties. For residues with unique labeling patterns (e.g., those appearing only once in the protein sequence), their amino acid identity can be determined without needing to know their precise chemical shifts. This is a major advantage for analyzing challenging proteins.
  • Simultaneous Decomposition and Relaxation Analysis: The method elegantly integrates signal decomposition and relaxation measurements into a single tensor decomposition problem. This allows for the simultaneous extraction of both structural (amino acid identity) and dynamic (relaxation parameters) information.
  • Robustness to Overlap and NUS: SiPex demonstrates robustness in decomposing signals even when they are highly overlapped or when using non-uniformly sampled (NUS) data, which is crucial for reducing experimental time. The ability to directly analyze time-domain NUS data without Fourier transformation is a significant advantage.

Key Results

  • Successful Decomposition of Simulated and Real Overlapping Signals: SiPex successfully decomposed simulated overlapping signals in Ub3A, accurately identifying the amino acids and extracting relaxation parameters that agreed well with conventional methods. It also successfully decomposed real overlapping signals from Ub3A.
  • Analysis of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins (IDPs): The method was applied to the crowded spectral region of the Nrf2 Neh2 domain, an IDP. SiPex identified several amino acid residues and their associated relaxation parameters, with some assignments confirmed by traditional methods.
  • Direct Time-Domain NUS Analysis: The study demonstrated that SiPex can directly analyze non-uniformly sampled time-domain NMR data, bypassing the need for spectral reconstruction and Fourier transformation, while still achieving accurate decomposition and information extraction.
  • Quantitative Agreement: The relaxation parameters (R1, R2, and NOE) obtained by SiPex for resolved signals showed good agreement with those obtained by conventional methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Number of Components (F): The determination of the correct number of components (F) for the tensor decomposition is not always straightforward and requires trial-and-error or statistical analysis. The authors suggest that F=2 was appropriate for their examples, but this can vary.
  • Experimental Optimization: Further optimization of experimental settings, such as the balance of acquisition time between different experiments (HSQC, HNCO, relaxation) and the scheduling of NUS data acquisition, is needed.
  • Algorithm Improvement: For more challenging targets with highly complex spectral overlap, further improvements to the tensor decomposition algorithm, potentially incorporating specific knowledge about labeling patterns or exponential decay properties, are suggested.
  • Generalizability of CSL: While SiPex is demonstrated with SiCode, the authors note that other combinatorial selective labeling (CSL) methods could be adapted by treating their labeling patterns as special cases of SiCode.

The authors envision SiPex expanding the applicability of NMR by overcoming signal assignment and overlapping problems, particularly for difficult target proteins.

Summary updated

Abstract

Signal overlapping is a major bottleneck for protein NMR analysis. We propose a new method, stable-isotope-assisted parameter extraction (SiPex), to resolve overlapping signals by a combination of amino-acid selective isotope labeling (AASIL) and tensor decomposition. The basic idea of Sipex is that overlapping signals can be decomposed with the help of intensity patterns derived from quantitative fractional AASIL, which also provides amino-acid information. In SiPex, spectra for protein characterization, such as <sup>15</sup>N relaxation measurements, are assembled with those for amino-acid information to form a four-order tensor, where the intensity patterns from AASIL contribute to high decomposition performance even if the signals share similar chemical shift values or characterization profiles, such as relaxation curves. The loading vectors of each decomposed component, corresponding to an amide group, represent both the amino-acid and relaxation information. This information link provides an alternative protein analysis method that does not require "assignments" in a general sense; i.e., chemical shift determinations, since the amino-acid information for some of the residues allows unambiguous assignment according to the dual selective labeling. SiPex can also decompose signals in time-domain raw data without Fourier transform, even in non-uniformly sampled data without spectral reconstruction. These features of SiPex should expand biological NMR applications by overcoming their overlapping and assignment problems.
BibTeX
@article{kasai2020amino,
  author = {Takuma Kasai and Shunsuke Ono and S. Koshiba and Masayuki Yamamoto and Toshiyuki Tanaka and Shiro Ikeda and T. Kigawa},
  title = {{Amino-acid selective isotope labeling enables simultaneous overlapping signal decomposition and information extraction from NMR spectra}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomolecular NMR},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/s10858-019-00295-9},
}
Figure