Amidoxime Modified UiO-66@PIM-1 Mixed-Matrix Membranes to Enhance CO2 Separation and Anti-Aging Performance

Jiaming Gao, Yongchao Sun, Feifei Kang, Fei Guo, Gaohong He, Hanli Wang, Zhendong Yang, Canghai Ma, Xiaobin Jiang, Wu XiaoMembranes 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel mixed-matrix membrane (MMM) by incorporating amidoxime-modified UiO-66 (UiO-66-AO) into a PIM-1 polymer matrix. This modification significantly enhances CO2 separation performance and improves membrane stability against physical aging, offering a promising solution for efficient carbon capture.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The urgent need for effective carbon capture technologies to mitigate climate change has driven research into advanced membrane separation. While mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs), combining the advantages of polymers and inorganic fillers, show promise, they often suffer from poor interfacial compatibility between the two phases. This leads to the formation of non-selective pores, hindering both permeability and selectivity. Polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs), like PIM-1, offer high permeability but are prone to physical aging, which degrades their performance over time. This work aims to overcome these limitations by developing an MMM with improved interfacial adhesion and enhanced anti-aging properties for CO2 separation.

Methods

The researchers synthesized UiO-66-AO by modifying UiO-66 with an amidoxime group. This modified filler was then incorporated into a PIM-1 polymer matrix to create mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs). The key to their approach lies in the functionalization of the UiO-66 filler. The amidoxime groups (-NH2 and -OH) on UiO-66-AO are designed to form hydrogen bonds with the nitrogen and oxygen atoms in the PIM-1 polymer chains. This hydrogen bonding is hypothesized to improve the compatibility between the filler and the polymer matrix, thereby reducing non-selective pore formation.

The membranes were characterized using various techniques:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To visualize the surface and cross-section morphology, assessing filler dispersion and interfacial integrity.
  • X-ray Powder Diffraction (XRD): To confirm the crystal structure of the filler and its presence within the membrane.
  • Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR): To analyze the chemical structure and confirm the successful modification of UiO-66 and the interactions within the MMM.
  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): To evaluate the thermal stability of the membranes.
  • Gas Permeation Experiments: Using a self-made gas penetration test device, the permeability and selectivity of pure gases (CO2, N2, CH4) were measured at 25 °C and 2 bar.
  • Physical Aging Test: The membranes were aged in a cool, dry environment for 38 days, with CO2 permeability measured periodically to assess their stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and performance evaluation of novel membranes rather than training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrogen Bonding for Compatibility: The core innovation is the use of amidoxime functional groups on the UiO-66 filler to create hydrogen bonds with the PIM-1 polymer. This is a clever strategy to directly address the interfacial compatibility issue that plagues many MMMs.
  • Synergistic CO2 Affinity: The amidoxime group not only improves compatibility but also possesses inherent selectivity for CO2, potentially enhancing gas transport through the membrane.
  • Breaking the Robeson Upper Bound: The developed MMMs demonstrate performance that surpasses the established Robeson Upper Bound (2008) and approaches the more recent 2019 Upper Bound, indicating a significant advancement in CO2 separation capabilities.
  • Mitigating Physical Aging: The incorporation of UiO-66-AO significantly improves the membrane's resistance to physical aging, a critical challenge for PIM-based membranes, leading to more stable long-term performance.

Key Results

The UiO-66-AO@PIM-1 MMMs, particularly at a 10 wt% loading, showed remarkable improvements:

  • CO2 Permeability: Increased by 35.2% compared to pure PIM-1, reaching 7535.5 Barrer.
  • CO2/N2 Selectivity: Increased by 45.2% compared to pure PIM-1, reaching 26.9.
  • Robeson Upper Bound: The performance surpasses the 2008 Robeson Upper Bound and is close to the 2019 Upper Bound.
  • Anti-Aging Performance: After 38 days of aging, the CO2 permeability of the 10% UiO-66-AO@PIM-1 membrane only decreased to approximately 74% of its original value, a significant improvement over pure PIM-1, which experienced a 43.4% decrease in permeability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Interfacial Compatibility Improvement: While the hydrogen bonding strategy significantly improved compatibility, the authors suggest that cross-linking the filler and matrix through chemical reactions could further enhance interfacial integrity and prevent non-selective pore formation, especially at higher filler loadings.
  • Aging Mechanism Nuances: The paper notes that at higher UiO-66-AO loadings (10-30%), the diffusion coefficients of N2 and CH4 increased significantly, suggesting potential issues with filler-polymer combination and non-selective cavitation. Further optimization of filler loading and interfacial engineering is implied.
  • Broader Gas Pair Performance: While the focus is on CO2/N2 and CO2/CH4 separation, future work could explore the performance of these MMMs for other critical gas separation applications.
  • Scale-up and Cost-Effectiveness: The paper focuses on laboratory-scale synthesis and testing. Future research would need to address the scalability of the synthesis process and the economic viability of these membranes for industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mixed matrix membranes (MMMs) generally have some fatal defects, such as poor compatibility between the two phases leading to non-selective pores. In this work, PIM-1 was chosen as the polymer matrix, and UiO-66 modified with amidoxime (UiO-66-AO) was used as the filler to prepare the MMMs. In the MMMs, the amino and hydroxyl groups on UO-66-AO form a rich hydrogen bond network with the N and O atoms in the polymer PIM-1 chain to improve the compatibility between the polymer matrix and the filler. In addition, the selective adsorption of CO<sub>2</sub> by the amidoxime group can promote the transport of CO<sub>2</sub> in the membrane, which enhances the gas selectivity. The CO<sub>2</sub> permeability and CO<sub>2</sub>/N<sub>2</sub> selectivity of UiO-66-AO@PIM-1 MMMs are increased by 35.2% and 45.2% compared to pure PIM-1 membranes, reaching 7535.5 Barrer and 26.9, surpassing the Robeson Upper Bound (2008) and close to the 2019 Upper Bound. After 38 days of the aging experiment, the CO<sub>2</sub> permeability is approximately 74% of the original. The results show that the addition of UiO-66-AO has an obvious effect on improving the aging properties of the membrane. The UiO-66-AO@PIM-1 MMMs have a bright prospect for CO<sub>2</sub> separation in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2023amidoxime,
  author = {Jiaming Gao and Yongchao Sun and Feifei Kang and Fei Guo and Gaohong He and Hanli Wang and Zhendong Yang and Canghai Ma and Xiaobin Jiang and Wu Xiao},
  title = {{Amidoxime Modified UiO-66@PIM-1 Mixed-Matrix Membranes to Enhance CO2 Separation and Anti-Aging Performance}},
  booktitle = {Membranes},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/membranes13090781},
}
Figure