AMEX-AI-LABS: Investigating Transfer Learning for Title Detection in Table of Contents Generation

Dhruv Premi, Amogh Badugu, Himanshu Sharad BhattCOLING 2020

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of automatically identifying titles within documents, a crucial step for tasks like table of contents generation. They propose a transfer learning approach that leverages pre-trained models for document structure and character patterns, achieving state-of-the-art results on the FinToC 2020 challenge.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately identifying titles within a document is a fundamental problem in document structure analysis. This capability is essential for various downstream tasks, including automatically generating tables of contents, improving document search, and enabling better summarization. Humans can intuitively understand document structure, distinguishing titles from regular text based on layout, font, and semantic cues. However, replicating this human intuition computationally is challenging. Existing methods often rely on specific document types (e.g., those with explicit ToC pages) or struggle to generalize across diverse document layouts. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a robust title detection system that can learn from general document structures and adapt to specific domains.

Methods

The authors propose a three-component approach:

  1. Pre-trained Neural Network for General Structural Information: This component uses transfer learning to capture general document layout and character patterns. It consists of two sub-networks:
  2. Geometrical Network: This network utilizes 22 manually engineered features related to alignment, font properties (size, bold, italic), and distances between text blocks. These features are fed into a multi-layer neural network.
  3. Character Network: This network employs a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) that takes the first eight characters of a text block as input. The goal is to identify patterns indicative of titles, such as numbering schemes (e.g., "1.1", "a.1").
  4. Sequential Network for Domain-Specific Semantics: This component uses a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network to learn domain-specific semantic patterns. It leverages GloVe word embeddings and is trained on the target domain data.
  5. Joint Training: The final model combines the pre-trained structural models (geometric and character) with the domain-specific sequential model. The pre-trained weights are used to initialize the network, which is then fine-tuned on the target dataset. This approach aims to leverage both general structural knowledge and domain-specific semantic understanding.

Datasets

  • Arxiv: A large corpus of approximately 6000 documents from Arxiv was used for pre-training the geometric and character models.
  • FinToC: This dataset was used for training and evaluating the domain-specific sequential model and the final joint-trained model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transfer Learning is Key: Pre-training models on a large, general corpus (Arxiv) significantly boosts performance on a specific domain (FinToC). This highlights the power of transfer learning for capturing universal document structural properties.
  • Complementary Features: Combining geometric and character-based features proved more effective than using either alone. This suggests that different types of information are crucial for accurate title detection.
  • Domain-Specific Semantics Matter: While general structure is important, incorporating domain-specific semantic understanding via LSTMs further enhances performance.

Key Results

The paper reports achieving the top rank in the title detection task at the FinToC 2020 challenge. The final jointly trained model achieved an F-Score of 83.25 on the FinToC test set. This represents a significant improvement, with the authors noting a 5% rise compared to the geometric model alone and a 10% increase attributed to the transfer learning approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Character Network Performance: The authors acknowledge that the character network, while aiming to capture general patterns, did not achieve as high an F-Score as expected. They suggest that its benefits can be utilized in further steps.
  • Bidirectional and Attention Mechanisms: Due to time constraints, the authors were unable to explore bidirectional and attention mechanisms within the LSTM network, which could potentially further improve performance.
  • Domain-Independence: The authors suggest that the transfer learning approach could be improved by using better architectures and features that are more domain-independent.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{premi2020amex,
  author = {Dhruv Premi and Amogh Badugu and Himanshu Sharad Bhatt},
  title = {{AMEX-AI-LABS: Investigating Transfer Learning for Title Detection in Table of Contents Generation}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure