Alzheimer's Disease Blood Biomarkers Associated With Neuroinflammation as Therapeutic Targets for Early Personalized Intervention

Sher Li Oh, Meikun Zhou, E Chin, Gautami Amarnath, Chee Hoe Cheah, Kok Pin Ng, Nagaendran Kandiah, Eyleen L. K. Goh, Keng‐Hwee ChiamFrontiers in Digital Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages machine learning on blood gene expression data to identify novel biomarkers for early detection of Alzheimer's Disease (AD) and its precursor, Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). By pinpointing specific inflammatory pathways, the research offers a promising avenue for personalized interventions and improved diagnostic capabilities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diagnosing Alzheimer's Disease (AD) definitively often requires post-mortem examination, a significant limitation for early intervention. While clinical assessments and neuroimaging exist, they can be subjective and less sensitive to early-stage cognitive decline, particularly Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). Current therapeutic strategies are most effective when initiated early, but identifying individuals at risk or in the prodromal stages of AD remains a challenge. This paper aims to address this by identifying reliable blood-based biomarkers that can detect MCI and AD, focusing on the role of neuroinflammation, which is increasingly understood to be a key driver of neurodegeneration in AD.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage machine learning pipeline to analyze blood gene expression data. Key techniques include:

  • Boruta Algorithm: This statistically driven method was used for feature selection to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) that serve as potential biomarkers. Boruta compares the importance of actual features against "shadow" features (randomized versions of the actual features) to rigorously select significant genes.
  • Random Forest (RF) Classifier: RF models were utilized for both classification (distinguishing between CN, MCI, and AD groups) and for assessing the variable importance of genes. RFs are known for their flexibility in handling non-linear relationships and their robustness.
  • SMOTE (Synthetic Minority Oversampling Technique): To address class imbalance in the datasets (where some groups have significantly fewer samples than others), SMOTE was applied to oversample minority classes, ensuring more balanced training and testing sets. This is crucial for preventing biased model performance.
  • Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA): Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathways were analyzed to understand the biological functions and pathways implicated by the identified DEGs. This helps to contextualize the biomarkers within known biological processes.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  • National Neuroscience Institute (NNI) Dataset: This dataset, collected from a Singaporean cohort, served as the discovery cohort for identifying DEGs. It comprised 254 subjects (99 cognitively normal (CN), 61 MCI, and 94 AD).
  • Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) Dataset: This publicly available dataset was used for external validation of the identified biomarkers. It included 744 subjects (261 CN, 439 MCI, and 44 AD).

The NNI dataset was split into training (80%) and testing (20%) sets for internal validation, while the ADNI dataset was used for external validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heterogeneity of AD: UMAP visualizations revealed that there isn't a clear, distinct clustering of genes that perfectly separates CN, MCI, and AD subjects. This highlights the inherent heterogeneity of AD, suggesting that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to diagnosis and treatment is unlikely to be effective.
  • Inflammation as a Key Player: The study strongly implicates neuroinflammation in the progression of MCI and AD. The identified DEGs were enriched in several inflammatory signaling pathways, reinforcing the link between inflammatory processes and neurodegeneration.
  • Pathway-Level Biomarkers: Instead of focusing solely on individual genes, the research emphasizes the importance of identifying dysregulated pathways. This provides a more holistic view of the biological mechanisms at play and offers broader therapeutic targets.
  • Early Detection Potential: The ability to classify subjects with greater than random accuracy, even in the MCI stage, suggests that these blood-based biomarkers could enable earlier detection and intervention, potentially slowing disease progression.

Key Results

  • Differentially Expressed Genes (DEGs): The study identified sets of DEGs for each pairwise comparison: 17 genes for CN vs. MCI, 10 genes for CN vs. AD, and 16 genes for MCI vs. AD.
  • Classification Accuracy:
    • Internal Validation (NNI dataset): Classification accuracies were significantly higher than random chance for all pairwise comparisons (CN vs. MCI, CN vs. AD, MCI vs. AD).
  • External Validation (ADNI dataset): When using the identified DEGs as features, the models achieved mean highest accuracies of 59.55% (CN vs. MCI), 55.96% (CN vs. AD), and 56.65% (MCI vs. AD). These accuracies, while moderate, were significantly above the 50% random chance threshold and demonstrated generalizability across datasets.
  • Key Inflammatory Pathways: Gene set enrichment analysis identified five crucial pathways implicated in MCI and AD development: PI3K-Akt, IL-17, JAK-STAT, TNF, and Ras signaling pathways. These pathways were found to be differentially expressed across the disease stages.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Discovery Cohort: The NNI dataset, while valuable, is relatively small. The authors suggest that future validation should ideally be conducted on a much larger dataset, potentially incorporating established AD biomarkers like amyloid and tau.
  • Blood-Brain Correlation: The complex relationship between blood and brain gene expression makes interpreting blood-based findings challenging. While some studies show correlation, it's not yet definitively established for MCI. Further investigation is needed to confirm if blood transcriptional changes accurately reflect neurophysiological changes in the brain.
  • MCI Heterogeneity: The classification of MCI is inherently challenging due to its heterogeneity, with some individuals progressing to AD, others remaining stable, and some even reverting to CN. This variability can influence feature selection.
  • Longitudinal Monitoring: Given the dynamic nature of inflammatory pathways and potential for false positives, the authors propose tracking longitudinal changes in these identified pathways for each individual, rather than relying on a single time-point diagnosis.
  • Broader Biomarker Comparison: Future work could involve comparing these blood biomarkers against those for other inflammatory conditions to ensure specificity for AD.
  • Therapeutic Potential: The identified pathways (IL-17 and TNF signaling) are already targets for existing FDA-approved drugs, suggesting a direct translational potential for personalized medicine in AD and MCI.

Summary updated

Abstract

The definitive diagnosis of Alzheimer's Disease (AD) without the need for neuropathological confirmation remains a challenge in AD research today, despite efforts to uncover the molecular and biological underpinnings of the disease process. Furthermore, the potential for therapeutic intervention is limited upon the onset of symptoms, providing motivation for studying and treating the AD precursor mild cognitive impairment (MCI), the prodromal stage of AD instead. Applying machine learning classification to transcriptomic data of MCI, AD, and cognitively normal (CN) control patients, we identified differentially expressed genes that serve as biomarkers for the characterization and classification of subjects into MCI or AD groups. Predictive models employing these biomarker genes exhibited good classification performances for CN, MCI, and AD, significantly above random chance. The PI3K-Akt, IL-17, JAK-STAT, TNF, and Ras signaling pathways were also enriched in these biomarker genes, indicating their diagnostic potential and pathophysiological roles in MCI and AD. These findings could aid in the recognition of MCI and AD risk in clinical settings, allow for the tracking of disease progression over time in individuals as part of a therapeutic approach, and provide possible personalized drug targets for early intervention of MCI and AD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{oh2022alzheimer,
  author = {Sher Li Oh and Meikun Zhou and E Chin and Gautami Amarnath and Chee Hoe Cheah and Kok Pin Ng and Nagaendran Kandiah and Eyleen L. K. Goh and Keng‐Hwee Chiam},
  title = {{Alzheimer's Disease Blood Biomarkers Associated With Neuroinflammation as Therapeutic Targets for Early Personalized Intervention}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Digital Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fdgth.2022.875895},
}
Figure