Altered trends of local brain function in classical trigeminal neuralgia patients after a single trigger pain

Juncheng Yan, Luoyu Wang, Lei Pan, Haiqi Ye, Xiaofen Zhu, Qi Feng, Haibin Wang, Zhongxiang Ding, Xiuhong GeBMC Medical Imaging 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how brain activity changes in patients with classical trigeminal neuralgia (CTN) immediately after a single pain stimulus. Using fMRI, researchers found that brain function alterations persist for at least 30 minutes and exhibit distinct time-frequency characteristics, suggesting a complex, dynamic response to pain beyond the transient stimulus itself.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical trigeminal neuralgia (CTN) is a debilitating condition characterized by sudden, severe facial pain triggered by innocuous stimuli. While neurovascular compression is a suspected cause, the precise neural mechanisms underlying CTN, particularly how the brain responds to the acute pain experience, remain incompletely understood. Previous research has identified altered brain function in CTN patients compared to healthy controls, but few studies have examined the dynamic, time-dependent changes in brain activity during and after a pain stimulus. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating the temporal and frequency-specific alterations in brain function following a single pain trigger in CTN patients.

Methods

The study employed resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) to capture spontaneous brain activity. Participants underwent three scanning sessions: a baseline scan before any stimulation, a scan within 5 seconds after a single pain stimulus (triggering-5s), and a scan 30 minutes after the stimulus (triggering-30 min).

Two key metrics were used to analyze brain function:

  • Static Regional Homogeneity (sReHo): This measures the temporal synchronization of the BOLD signal within a voxel and its neighboring voxels. It was analyzed across five different frequency bands (classical, slow 2, slow 3, slow 4, and slow 5 Hz) to capture frequency-specific brain activity.
  • Dynamic Regional Homogeneity (dReHo): This method captures the temporal variability of sReHo, providing insights into how brain activity patterns change over time. A sliding window approach was used to calculate dReHo.

Statistical analysis involved repeated-measures ANOVA to compare sReHo and dReHo values across the three time points, with corrections for multiple comparisons. Spearman correlations were used to explore relationships between pain characteristics (VAS, disease duration) and brain activity.

Datasets

The study utilized rs-fMRI data from 48 classical trigeminal neuralgia (CTN) patients recruited from Hangzhou First People's Hospital. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pain's Lingering Effect: The brain's functional response to a single, transient pain stimulus in CTN patients is not immediate and dissipates quickly. Alterations in brain activity persist for at least 30 minutes post-stimulus, suggesting a sustained neural impact.
  • Time-Frequency Specificity: Brain function doesn't respond uniformly to pain. Different brain regions exhibit distinct patterns of change across various frequency bands (sReHo) and over time (dReHo), highlighting a complex interplay of temporal and frequency-dependent neural dynamics.
  • Complementary Measures: sReHo and dReHo provide complementary information. The brain regions showing altered sReHo were largely different from those showing altered dReHo, suggesting that both static synchronization and dynamic fluctuations are important for understanding CTN pathophysiology.
  • Dominant Trend: The most common pattern of change observed was a decrease in regional homogeneity at the triggering-5s time point, followed by an increase at the triggering-30 min time point. This suggests an initial disruption and subsequent compensatory or adaptive response.

Key Results

  • sReHo: The classical frequency band showed the most altered brain regions, followed by slow 4, slow 5, slow 3, and slow 2 frequency bands. Specific regions like the left angular gyrus, precuneus, and postcentral gyrus showed decreased sReHo at triggering-5s and increased sReHo at triggering-30 min. The visual cortex (middle occipital gyrus, calcarine) showed increased sReHo, suggesting its involvement in pain processing. The default mode network (DMN) regions (bilateral middle frontal gyrus, left precuneus) showed decreased sReHo.
  • dReHo: Four brain regions (midbrain, left thalamus, right putamen, and right anterior cingulate cortex) showed altered dReHo, distinct from the sReHo findings. The right ACC showed a gradual increase in dReHo, while the midbrain, left thalamus, and right putamen showed a decrease at triggering-5s and an increase at triggering-30 min.
  • Correlations: Negative correlations were found between VAS (pain intensity) and sReHo values in regions like the precuneus and MFG, suggesting that higher pain intensity is associated with lower regional homogeneity in these areas.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Time Window: The study only captured brain activity at 5 seconds and 30 minutes post-stimulus. To fully understand the recovery trajectory, longer scanning intervals are needed.
  • CTN Subtypes: CTN can be further classified into subtypes based on pain characteristics. Future research should investigate potential differences in brain function between these subtypes.
  • Sample Size and Symptom Variation: The study did not perform subgroup analyses based on symptom severity or duration. Expanding the sample size and conducting subgroup analyses would provide a more nuanced understanding.
  • Pain Experience: The study focused on patients who experienced pain after stimulation. Analyzing patients who did not experience pain after triggering would offer a comparative perspective.

Future work should aim to address these limitations by exploring longer time courses, stratifying patients by subtype, and investigating the role of specific brain regions and their dynamic interactions in the complex experience of trigeminal neuralgia pain.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yan2024altered,
  author = {Juncheng Yan and Luoyu Wang and Lei Pan and Haiqi Ye and Xiaofen Zhu and Qi Feng and Haibin Wang and Zhongxiang Ding and Xiuhong Ge},
  title = {{Altered trends of local brain function in classical trigeminal neuralgia patients after a single trigger pain}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Imaging},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s12880-024-01239-y},
}
Figure