Altered Functional Network Energy Across Multiscale Brain Networks in Preterm vs. Full-Term Subjects: Insights from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study

Qiang Li, Dawn Jensen, Zening Fu, Teddy Jakim, Masoud Seraji, Selami Süleymanoğlu, G. Hari Surya Bharadwaj, Jiayu Chen, Vince D. Calhoun, Jingyu LiubioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how preterm birth affects brain network stability in adolescents using functional network energy. They found that preterm-born adolescents have more stable, but less flexible, brain networks, particularly in visual, sensorimotor, and higher cognitive areas, compared to their full-term peers. This suggests long-term impacts of prematurity on brain organization and adaptability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Preterm birth, occurring before 40 weeks of gestation, can lead to lasting differences in brain development. While previous research has identified structural and functional brain abnormalities in preterm individuals, there's a knowledge gap regarding the long-term consequences into adolescence, especially concerning the dynamic organization of brain networks. Existing studies often focus on pairwise connections and may overlook the complex, multiscale nature of brain activity. This paper aims to address this by examining "functional network energy" – a measure of network stability and flexibility – across multiple scales of brain connectivity in a large adolescent cohort.

Methods

The researchers utilized a comprehensive, data-driven approach called Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to identify intrinsic connectivity networks (ICNs) within the brain. Specifically, they employed the NeuroMark_fMRI_2.2 template and a Multivariate Objective Optimization ICA with Reference (MOO-ICAR) framework to extract subject-specific ICNs and their time courses. This allowed them to analyze multiscale functional connectivity.

A key novel aspect is the application of "functional network energy" to assess network stability. This metric, derived from structural balance theory, quantifies how well-connected brain regions are within "triangles" of interaction. Low energy signifies stable, coordinated networks, while high energy indicates instability and potential for dynamic reconfiguration. They also used Pearson correlation to estimate functional connectivity. Statistical significance was determined using permutation tests to compare network energy between preterm and full-term groups.

Datasets

The study used data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study, a large, multisite, longitudinal study following over 10,000 children. For this analysis, they selected approximately 4,600 adolescents (1,849 preterm and 2,765 full-term) who were matched for sex and socioeconomic status and were nine years old at the time of their baseline scans. The data included resting-state fMRI scans acquired across different scanner platforms.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Preterm birth leaves a lasting mark on brain network dynamics: Even by adolescence, differences in brain network organization persist between preterm and full-term individuals.
  • Network Energy as a measure of stability/flexibility: Functional network energy provides a nuanced way to understand how stable or adaptable brain networks are, going beyond simple connectivity measures.
  • Three key networks show differential energy: The visual, sensorimotor, and higher cognitive networks are particularly affected, exhibiting distinct energy profiles in preterm vs. full-term adolescents.
  • Stability vs. Flexibility Trade-off: Preterm brains appear to prioritize stability (lower energy) at the cost of dynamic reconfiguration and flexibility, which could impact cognitive adaptability.

Key Results

The study identified significant differences in functional network energy between preterm and full-term adolescents in:

  • Whole-brain network: Preterm subjects showed significantly lower network energy.
  • Specific subnetworks: Significant differences were observed in the visual network (VI-OT, VI-OC), sensorimotor network (SM), and higher cognitive network (HC-FR, HC-TP).
  • Full-term subjects: Exhibited higher network energy, suggesting greater instability and a capacity for more dynamic information processing and flexibility.
  • Preterm subjects: Showed more stable networks with reduced energy, but this stability came with less dynamic reconfiguration and flexibility.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study focused on a specific age group (9-10 years old) and that further research is needed to understand the developmental trajectory of these differences.

Future work proposed includes:

  • Identifying specific brain regions: Pinpointing critical regions within the identified networks that are most affected by preterm birth.
  • Animal modeling: Using animal models to investigate the underlying microscopic neural mechanisms responsible for these developmental differences.
  • Longitudinal analysis: Expanding on the current cross-sectional findings by tracking these network energy dynamics over time as individuals mature.

Summary updated

Abstract

Infants born prematurely, or preterm, can experience altered brain connectivity, due in part to incomplete brain development at the time of parturition. Research has also shown structural and functional differences in the brain that persist in these individuals as they enter adolescence when compared to peers who were fully mature at birth. In this study, we examined functional network energy across multiscale functional connectivity in approximately 4600 adolescents from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study who were either preterm or full term at birth. We identified three key brain networks that show significant differences in network energy between preterm and full-term subjects. These networks include the visual network (comprising the occipitotemporal and occipital subnetworks), the sensorimotor network, and the high cognitive network (including the temporoparietal and frontal subnetworks). Additionally, it was demonstrated that full-term subjects exhibit greater instability, leading to more dynamic reconfiguration of functional brain information and increased flexibility across the three identified canonical brain networks compared to preterm subjects. In contrast, those born prematurely show more stable networks but less dynamic and flexible organization of functional brain information within these key canonical networks. In summary, measuring multiscale functional network energy offered insights into the stability of canonical brain networks associated with subjects born prematurely. These findings enhance our understanding of how early birth impacts brain development.
BibTeX
@misc{li2025altered,
  author = {Qiang Li and Dawn Jensen and Zening Fu and Teddy Jakim and Masoud Seraji and Selami Süleymanoğlu and G. Hari Surya Bharadwaj and Jiayu Chen and Vince D. Calhoun and Jingyu Liu},
  title = {{Altered Functional Network Energy Across Multiscale Brain Networks in Preterm vs. Full-Term Subjects: Insights from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.02.09.637316},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure