Alterations of Intrinsic Brain Connectivity Patterns in Depression and Bipolar Disorders: A Critical Assessment of Magnetoencephalography-Based Evidence

Golnoush Alamian, Ana-Sofía Hincapié, Etienne Combrisson, Thomas Thiery, Véronique Martel, Dmitrii Althukov, Karim JerbiFrontiers in Psychiatry 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Despite being the object of a thriving field of clinical research, the investigation of intrinsic brain network alterations in psychiatric illnesses is still in its early days. Because the pathological alterations are predominantly probed using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), many questions about the electrophysiological bases of resting-state alterations in psychiatric disorders, particularly among mood disorder patients, remain unanswered. Alongside important research using electroencephalography (EEG), the specific recent contributions and future promise of magnetoencephalography (MEG) in this field are not fully recognized and valued. Here, we provide a critical review of recent findings from MEG resting-state connectivity within major depressive disorder (MDD) and bipolar disorder (BD). The clinical MEG resting-state results are compared with those previously reported with fMRI and EEG. Taken together, MEG appears to be a promising but still critically underexploited technique to unravel the neurophysiological mechanisms that mediate abnormal (both hyper- and hypo-) connectivity patterns involved in MDD and BD. In particular, a major strength of MEG is its ability to provide source-space estimations of neuromagnetic long-range rhythmic synchronization at various frequencies (i.e., oscillatory coupling). The reviewed literature highlights the relevance of probing local and interregional rhythmic synchronization to explore the pathophysiological underpinnings of each disorder. However, before we can fully take advantage of MEG connectivity analyses in psychiatry, several limitations inherent to MEG connectivity analyses need to be understood and taken into account. Thus, we also discuss current methodological challenges and outline paths for future research. MEG resting-state studies provide an important window onto perturbed spontaneous oscillatory brain networks and hence supply an important complement to fMRI-based resting-state measurements in psychiatric populations.

Introduction

Psychiatric research has undergone a paradigm shift from examining isolated brain regions to studying large-scale network organization. However, the current "gold standard" for this research is functional MRI (fMRI), which measures blood oxygenation—a slow, indirect proxy for neural activity. fMRI cannot capture the rapid, oscillatory "conversations" (brain waves) between neurons that occur on a millisecond timescale.

While Electroencephalography (EEG) is fast enough to see these oscillations, it suffers from poor spatial resolution because the skull distorts electrical signals. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) offers a unique solution: it captures magnetic fields (which pass through the skull cleanly) with millisecond precision and enough spatial clarity to pinpoint exactly where in the brain these signals originate. This review paper, published in Frontiers in Psychiatry, provides a comprehensive look at how MEG is being used to map the "broken wiring" in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) and Bipolar Disorder (BD).

Methodology

The authors performed a systematic search of literature combining MEG, resting-state paradigms, and connectivity in MDD and BD. They evaluated these studies based on:

  • Source-space analysis: Moving beyond sensor-level data to estimate activity in specific anatomical regions.
  • Coupling metrics: How different studies measured "connectivity," such as coherence, phase-locking values, or envelope correlations.
  • Frequency bands: Analyzing how disruptions occur in specific rhythms (Delta, Theta, Alpha, Beta, Gamma).

The review synthesized findings from several clinical cohorts, including five primary studies for MDD (sample sizes n=5 to n=33) and one primary resting-state connectivity study for BD, highlighting a significant gap in current research.

Key Results and Insights

Major Depressive Disorder (MDD)

In depression, the Default Mode Network (DMN)—the circuit active during rumination and self-reflection—is often hyper-connected. MEG studies confirm this, specifically showing increased beta-band synchronization within DMN nodes. Conversely, "hypo-connectivity" (reduced communication) is observed between the Central Executive Network (dlPFC) and the limbic system (amygdala), which may explain the difficulty depressed patients have in regulating emotions.

Summary of MEG resting-state connectivity studies in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD).

Bipolar Disorder (BD)

Evidence for BD is currently limited, but existing research suggests frequency-specific fingerprints. The identified resting-state study found increased synchronization of delta oscillations and decreased synchronization of beta oscillations in the frontal lobe of euthymic BD patients compared to controls.

Summary of MEG resting-state connectivity studies in Bipolar Disorder (BD).

Treatment Signatures

MEG can track the effects of fast-acting treatments. For instance, ketamine was shown to "reset" hyper-connectivity between the amygdala and insula in depressed patients. Similarly, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) has been shown to resolve impaired prefronto-thalamic functional connections in responders after two weeks of treatment.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors identify several hurdles facing MEG research, including "signal leakage" (field spread causing artificial connectivity), a lack of consensus on mathematical metrics, and generally small clinical sample sizes. Future directions include the use of machine learning to classify patients based on their MEG "connectivity fingerprint" and more longitudinal studies to observe network changes over the course of treatment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite being the object of a thriving field of clinical research, the investigation of intrinsic brain network alterations in psychiatric illnesses is still in its early days. Because the pathological alterations are predominantly probed using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), many questions about the electrophysiological bases of resting-state alterations in psychiatric disorders, particularly among mood disorder patients, remain unanswered. Alongside important research using electroencephalography (EEG), the specific recent contributions and future promise of magnetoencephalography (MEG) in this field are not fully recognized and valued. Here, we provide a critical review of recent findings from MEG resting-state connectivity within major depressive disorder (MDD) and bipolar disorder (BD). The clinical MEG resting-state results are compared with those previously reported with fMRI and EEG. Taken together, MEG appears to be a promising but still critically underexploited technique to unravel the neurophysiological mechanisms that mediate abnormal (both hyper- and hypo-) connectivity patterns involved in MDD and BD. In particular, a major strength of MEG is its ability to provide source-space estimations of neuromagnetic long-range rhythmic synchronization at various frequencies (i.e., oscillatory coupling). The reviewed literature highlights the relevance of probing local and interregional rhythmic synchronization to explore the pathophysiological underpinnings of each disorder. However, before we can fully take advantage of MEG connectivity analyses in psychiatry, several limitations inherent to MEG connectivity analyses need to be understood and taken into account. Thus, we also discuss current methodological challenges and outline paths for future research. MEG resting-state studies provide an important window onto perturbed spontaneous oscillatory brain networks and hence supply an important complement to fMRI-based resting-state measurements in psychiatric populations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alamian2017alterations,
  author = {Golnoush Alamian and Ana-Sofía Hincapié and Etienne Combrisson and Thomas Thiery and Véronique Martel and Dmitrii Althukov and Karim Jerbi},
  title = {{Alterations of Intrinsic Brain Connectivity Patterns in Depression and Bipolar Disorders: A Critical Assessment of Magnetoencephalography-Based Evidence}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2017.00041},
}
Figure