Alteration of Brain Structure With Long-Term Abstinence of Methamphetamine by Voxel-Based Morphometry

Zhixue Zhang, Lei He, Shucai Huang, Lidan Fan, Yining Li, Ping Li, Jun Zhang, Jun Liu, Ru YangFrontiers in Psychiatry 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used voxel-based morphometry (VBM) to investigate brain structure changes in individuals with long-term methamphetamine abstinence (over 14 months). They found that abstinent users showed increased gray matter volume in the cerebellum and decreased volume in visual processing areas, suggesting partial recovery and the continued importance of these regions in addiction and recovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Methamphetamine (MA) addiction is a significant public health issue, characterized by profound effects on brain structure and function. While many studies have examined brain changes in individuals abstinent for short periods, there's a notable gap in understanding the long-term structural consequences of MA use and the potential for recovery after extended abstinence. This lack of knowledge hinders the development of more effective long-term treatment and rehabilitation strategies. This paper aims to address this gap by investigating brain gray matter volume (GMV) in individuals who have been abstinent from MA for at least 14 months.

Methods

The researchers employed Voxel-Based Morphometry (VBM), a neuroimaging analysis technique that allows for automated, whole-brain assessment of structural differences. Specifically, they used the VBM8 toolbox to process MRI data. The process involved:

  • Bias correction: Correcting for intensity variations in the MRI images.
  • Segmentation: Differentiating gray matter from other brain tissues.
  • Spatial normalization: Aligning each subject's brain to a standard anatomical template (Montreal Neurological Institute space).
  • Modulation: Adjusting gray matter volumes to account for the spatial normalization process, preserving local tissue concentration.
  • Smoothing: Applying a Gaussian kernel to blur the images, which helps to increase statistical power.

To compare GMV between groups and assess correlations, they used:

  • Two-sample t-tests (AlphaSim corrected): To identify significant differences in GMV between the abstinent methamphetamine-dependent (AMD) group and healthy controls (HC). This correction method accounts for multiple comparisons across the brain.
  • Partial correlation coefficients: To examine the relationship between GMV in specific brain regions and variables related to MA use and abstinence (e.g., duration of abstinence, age of first use), while controlling for covariates like age, education, smoking, and drinking.

Datasets

The study utilized MRI data from:

  • 44 abstinent methamphetamine-dependent (AMD) subjects: These individuals had abstained from MA for at least 14 months and were recruited from a mandatory detoxification center.
  • 40 healthy control (HC) subjects: These individuals served as a comparison group.

No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing MRI data collected from these participant groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cerebellum as a potential recovery zone: The finding of increased GMV in the cerebellum of abstinent users, contrary to some previous studies showing reductions, suggests that this region might be undergoing a recovery process after long-term abstinence. The cerebellum is implicated in cognitive and emotional functions, so its recovery could be crucial for overall functional improvement.
  • Visual cortex vulnerability and recovery: Decreased GMV in the visual cortex (calcarine and cuneus) in abstinent users highlights the lasting impact of MA on visual processing areas. This could be linked to how drug cues trigger craving and relapse, suggesting that these areas remain sensitive even after prolonged abstinence.
  • Abstinence duration matters: The positive correlation between the duration of abstinence and GMV in the left cerebellum crus is a significant finding. It strongly suggests that longer periods of abstinence are not only associated with structural changes but may actively contribute to the recovery of cognitive functions mediated by the cerebellum.

Key Results

  • GMV Differences: Compared to healthy controls, AMD subjects showed:
  • Increased GMV: In the bilateral cerebellum (specifically, cerebellar crus).
  • Decreased GMV: In the right calcarine and right cuneus (regions associated with visual processing).
  • Correlation: The duration of abstinence in the AMD group was positively correlated with GMV in the left cerebellum crus (p = 0.040, r = 0.626). No other significant correlations were found between GMV and MA use/abstinence variables.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional design: The study did not collect baseline MRI data from AMD subjects before abstinence. This prevents establishing a definitive causal link between abstinence and the observed brain changes.
  • Smoking history: While smoking was controlled for as a covariate, its potential influence on gray matter volume cannot be entirely ruled out, as smoking itself is known to affect brain structure.
  • Male-only sample: The study included only male participants. Sex differences in brain responses to drugs and in addiction progression are well-documented, meaning these findings may not generalize to female users.

Future research could address these limitations by:

  • Conducting longitudinal studies to track brain changes over time during abstinence.
  • Including non-smoking subgroups or more robustly controlling for smoking effects.
  • Investigating sex differences in brain alterations associated with MA abstinence.
  • Exploring the neural mechanisms underlying the observed changes in visual and cognitive regions and their role in relapse prevention.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> A large portion of previous studies that have demonstrated brain gray matter reduction in individuals who use methamphetamine (MA) have focused on short-term abstinence, but few studies have focused on the effects of long-term abstinence of methamphetamine on brain structures. <b>Materials and Methods:</b> Our study includes 40 healthy controls and 44 abstinent methamphetamine-dependent (AMD) subjects who have abstained for at least 14 months. For every AMD subject, the age when they first used MA, the total time of MA use, the frequency of MA use in the last month before abstinence, the duration of abstinence and the craving score were recorded. Here we used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to measure the gray matter volume (GMV) of each subject with voxel-based morphometry method. Two-sample <i>t</i>-test (AlphaSim corrected) was performed to obtain brain regions with different gray matter volume (GMV) between groups. In addition, partial correlation coefficients adjusted for age, years of education, smoking, and drinking were calculated in the AMD group to assess associations between the mean GMV values in significant clusters and variables of MA use and abstinence. <b>Results:</b> Compared with the healthy control group, AMD group showed increased gray matter volumes in the bilateral cerebellum and decreased volumes in the right calcarine and right cuneus. Moreover, GMV of left cerebellum are positively correlated with the duration of abstinence in the AMD group (<i>p</i> = 0.040<i>, r</i> = 0.626). <b>Conclusions:</b> The present study showed that the gray matter volume in some brain regions is abnormal in the AMD subjects with long-term abstinence. Changes in gray matter volume of visual and cognitive function regions suggested that these areas play important roles in the progress of MA addiction and abstinence. In addition, positive correlation between GMV of the left cerebellum crus and duration of abstinence suggested that prolonged abstinence is beneficial to cognitive function recovery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018alteration,
  author = {Zhixue Zhang and Lei He and Shucai Huang and Lidan Fan and Yining Li and Ping Li and Jun Zhang and Jun Liu and Ru Yang},
  title = {{Alteration of Brain Structure With Long-Term Abstinence of Methamphetamine by Voxel-Based Morphometry}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00722},
}
Figure