Alteration in forward model prediction of sensory outcome of motor action in focal hand dystonia

André Lee, Shinichi Furuya, Matthias Karst, Eckart AltenmüllerFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Focal hand dystonia (FD) in musicians is a movement disorder affecting highly trained movements. Beyond motor execution, movement planning and sensorimotor integration are impaired. This study investigates whether a deficit in the Forward Model (FM)—which predicts sensory consequences of motor commands—plays a role in FD. By comparing 19 FD patients and 19 healthy controls on their perception of self-applied versus externally applied tactile stimuli, researchers found that FD patients exhibit altered FM function. Machine learning classification of affected hands achieved up to 94.7% accuracy, suggesting the cerebellum's involvement in the disorder's pathophysiology.

Introduction: The Predictive Brain and Dystonia

Focal hand dystonia (FD) is a debilitating condition for musicians, characterized by a loss of voluntary control during highly trained tasks. Traditionally viewed as a motor execution disorder, emerging evidence suggests the "software" of sensorimotor integration is at fault. A key component of this integration is the Forward Model (FM). In a healthy brain, the FM predicts the sensory consequences of an action, allowing the brain to attenuate (mute) self-produced sensations—the reason one cannot tickle oneself. This study explores whether a breakdown in this predictive mechanism contributes to the motor control failures seen in FD.

Methods: Measuring Sensory Attenuation

The researchers compared 19 musicians with FD against 19 healthy controls. A custom-built device was used to apply a constant, light pressure (0.17 N) to the fingertips (fingers II-V) of both hands.

The experimental setup used to apply tactile stimuli to the fingertips in both self-applied and externally applied conditions.

Participants rated the intensity of the sensation (on a scale of 0 to 1) under two conditions:

  1. Externally Applied (EA): The experimenter moved the pointer.
  2. Self-Applied (SA): The participant moved the pointer themselves.

The primary metric was the differential value (EA - SA). Healthy individuals typically perceive EA stimuli as more intense than SA stimuli due to sensory attenuation. To analyze the complex patterns across the hand, the team used a Support Vector Machine (SVM) to classify hands based on the 4-dimensional hyperspace of the four fingers' sensory data.

Key Results: A Systemic Failure of Prediction

The study found that the pattern of sensory prediction could accurately distinguish dystonic hands from healthy ones.

Mean perceived stimulus intensity for healthy musicians (HM) and musicians with dystonia (MD) across the four fingers of both hands.
  • High Classification Accuracy: The SVM correctly identified affected hands with 78.9% to 94.7% accuracy.
  • Intact Sensory Hardware: There was no difference between groups in the absolute perception of external stimuli, confirming that basic sensory pathways are functional. The deficit is specific to the prediction of self-action.
  • Systemic Hand Involvement: The high classification accuracy even for fingers not showing overt motor symptoms suggests that FD affects the internal model of the entire hand.
  • No Correlation with Severity: The degree of FM deficit did not correlate with the duration or clinical severity of the dystonia, suggesting it may be a core trait of the disorder.

Discussion and Insights

The results provide strong behavioral evidence that the cerebellum, the primary site for internal model processing, is a central node in the "dystonia network." The reduced ability to attenuate self-produced sensations suggests that the "efference copy" is not being used effectively to cancel out expected touch. This failure to distinguish self from non-self sensations likely contributes to the breakdown in fine motor control.

Limitations and Future Directions

A notable limitation is the age difference between the patient (avg. 40.8) and control (avg. 24.6) groups. Future research using fMRI is needed to confirm if these behavioral deficits correlate with abnormal activity in the cerebellum and anterior cingulate cortex. Such findings could pave the way for new diagnostic tools and biofeedback-based therapies for affected musicians.

Summary updated

Abstract

Focal hand dystonia in musicians is a movement disorder affecting highly trained movements. Rather than being a pure motor disorder related to movement execution only, movement planning, error prediction, and sensorimotor integration are also impaired. Internal models (IMs), of which two types, forward and inverse models have been described and most likely processed in the cerebellum, are known to be involved in these tasks. Recent results indicate that the cerebellum may be involved in the pathophysiology of focal dystonia (FD). Thus, the aim of our study was to investigate whether an IM deficit plays a role in FD. We focused on the forward model (FM), which predicts sensory consequences of motor commands and allows the discrimination between external sensory input and input deriving from motor action. We investigated 19 patients, aged 19-59 and 19 healthy musicians aged 19-36 as controls. Tactile stimuli were applied to fingers II-V of both hands by the experimenter or the patient. After each stimulus the participant rated the stimulus intensity on a scale between 0 (no sensation) and 1 (maximal intensity). The difference of perceived intensity between self- and externally applied (EA) stimuli was then calculated for each finger. For assessing differences between patients and controls we performed a cluster analysis of the affected hand and the corresponding hand of the controls using the fingers II-V as variables in a 4-dimensional hyperspace (chance level = 0.5). Using a cluster analysis, we found a correct classification of the affected finger in 78.9-94.7%. There was no difference between patients and healthy controls of the absolute value of the perceived stimulus intensity. Our results suggest an altered FM function in focal hand dystonia. It has the potential of suggesting a neural correlate within the cerebellum and of helping integrate findings with regard to altered sensorimotor processing and altered prediction in FD in a single framework.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2013alteration,
  author = {André Lee and Shinichi Furuya and Matthias Karst and Eckart Altenmüller},
  title = {{Alteration in forward model prediction of sensory outcome of motor action in focal hand dystonia}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2013.00172},
}
Figure