Allocation of emergency medical resources for epidemic diseases considering the heterogeneity of epidemic areas

Bin Hu, Guanhua Jiang, Xinyi Yao, Wei Chen, Tingyu Yue, Qitong Zhao, Zongliang WenFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a dual-mechanism framework for managing medical logistics during an epidemic: first, a modified SEIHR model forecasts time-varying resource demand based on local infection rates and treatment capacities; second, a bi-objective optimization model balances the trade-off between maximizing fair resource distribution and minimizing transportation costs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

During a public health emergency, medical resources (like PPE, ventilators, or medicine) are chronically scarce. Logistics managers face a "wicked problem": how do you distribute limited supplies across multiple regions when those regions have vastly different infection rates, population densities, and existing medical infrastructures?

Existing models often treat demand as static or fail to account for the heterogeneity of different areas—the fact that one city might be at the peak of its curve while another is just beginning. Furthermore, there is a fundamental tension between fairness (ensuring every area reaches a minimum satisfaction threshold) and efficiency (minimizing the distance and time vehicles travel).

Methods

The authors develop a two-stage recursive mechanism:

  1. Demand Forecasting (Modified SEIHR): Standard epidemiological models (SEIR) track Susceptible, Exposed, Infected, and Recovered populations. The authors add a "Hospitalized" (H) compartment. This is critical because resource demand is more closely tied to the number of patients requiring active clinical care than to the total number of infected individuals. The model also incorporates local parameters for treatment capacity ($\delta$) and recovery rates ($\gamma$) to reflect regional differences.
  2. Resource Allocation (MILP): They formulate a Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) model with two competing objectives:
  3. Objective 1: Maximize the weighted demand satisfaction rate. Urgency weights ($\omega$) are calculated based on the ratio of infected/hospitalized people in a specific area relative to the total across all areas.
  4. Objective 2: Minimize the total vehicle travel distance.
  5. Optimization Techniques: To solve this multi-objective problem, they employ the $\epsilon$-constraint method (treating one objective as a constraint while optimizing the other) and the weighting sum method to find a Pareto-optimal balance. The models were validated using LINGO and the MATLAB YALMIP toolbox.

Datasets

The study relies on a hypothetical numerical simulation rather than a specific historical dataset.

  • Scenario: 8 epidemic areas with varying initial populations (2M to 8M) and 4 supply points (A, B, C, D) with fixed inventory levels.
  • Parameters: The authors assigned specific values for exposure rates, latency, and treatment capacities to simulate the "heterogeneity" of the regions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "H" Factor: By explicitly modeling the "Hospitalized" state, the logistics model becomes much more sensitive to the actual strain on a local healthcare system compared to models that only look at raw infection numbers.
  • Dynamic Urgency: The urgency weight ($\omega_j^t$) is time-varying. As an area's epidemic situation worsens, its priority for receiving resources automatically increases in the optimization model.
  • The Fairness Threshold: The model includes a "minimal demand satisfaction rate" constraint ($X_{j,min}^t$). This prevents the optimization from completely abandoning remote or "expensive to reach" areas in favor of efficiency, ensuring a baseline level of equity.
  • Supply Point Diminishing Returns: The research suggests that while increasing the number of supply points serving a single area can improve satisfaction rates, it leads to a "waste of transportation resources" (increased distance and complexity) after a certain threshold.

Key Results

  • Fairness vs. Distance: In the base case, as the required minimum satisfaction rate ($X_{j,min}^t$) was pushed higher (from 0.7 to 0.92), the total vehicle travel distance increased significantly (from ~4,045 km to ~4,815 km) to meet those equity targets.
  • Supply Point Impact: When the model allowed an epidemic area to be served by up to two supply points ($K=2$) instead of just one ($K=1$), the weighted satisfaction rate improved from 0.946 to 0.952, but at the cost of increasing total travel distance from 4,045 km to 4,740 km.
  • Sensitivity to Treatment Capacity: The simulation showed that increasing local medical treatment capacity ($\delta$) not only reduces the peak number of infected individuals but also shifts the peak earlier, allowing for more rapid resource reallocation to other regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hypothetical Data: The primary limitation is the lack of real-world validation using historical COVID-19 or Ebola data.
  • Static Population: The model assumes a steady population and does not account for migration or "fleeing" from epidemic centers, which significantly impacts disease spread.
  • Logistics Simplification: The study does not consider specific vehicle counts, transportation modes (air vs. ground), or the production capacity of the manufacturers themselves.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest incorporating vehicle routing optimization (VRP) and considering the "substitutability" of different medical resources in future iterations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background The resources available to fight an epidemic are typically limited, and the time and effort required to control it grow as the start date of the containment effort are delayed. When the population is afflicted in various regions, scheduling a fair and acceptable distribution of limited available resources stored in multiple emergency resource centers to each epidemic area has become a serious problem that requires immediate resolution. Methods This study presents an emergency medical logistics model for rapid response to public health emergencies. The proposed methodology consists of two recursive mechanisms: (1) time-varying forecasting of medical resources and (2) emergency medical resource allocation. Considering the epidemic's features and the heterogeneity of existing medical treatment capabilities in different epidemic areas, we provide the modified susceptible-exposed-infected-recovered (SEIR) model to predict the early stage emergency medical resource demand for epidemics. Then we define emergency indicators for each epidemic area based on this. By maximizing the weighted demand satisfaction rate and minimizing the total vehicle travel distance, we develop a bi-objective optimization model to determine the optimal medical resource allocation plan. Results Decision-makers should assign appropriate values to parameters at various stages of the emergency process based on the actual situation, to ensure that the results obtained are feasible and effective. It is necessary to set up an appropriate number of supply points in the epidemic emergency medical logistics supply to effectively reduce rescue costs and improve the level of emergency services. Conclusions Overall, this work provides managerial insights to improve decisions made on medical distribution as per demand forecasting for quick response to public health emergencies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2023allocation,
  author = {Bin Hu and Guanhua Jiang and Xinyi Yao and Wei Chen and Tingyu Yue and Qitong Zhao and Zongliang Wen},
  title = {{Allocation of emergency medical resources for epidemic diseases considering the heterogeneity of epidemic areas}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.992197},
}
Figure