Algebras of Higher Operads as Enriched Categories

Michael Batanin, Mark WeberAppl. Categorical Struct 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper bridges the gap between two approaches to higher category theory: the "globular" and "simplicial" perspectives. It establishes a precise correspondence between algebras of "normalised $\omega$-operads" and categories enriched over a specific type of "lax monoidal structure" on globular sets, offering a new way to understand and construct higher categorical structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Defining and working with higher category theory (categories with more than one dimension of structure) has historically been approached in two main ways: the globular approach, which defines structures all at once using operads, and the simplicial approach, which builds them up inductively, like defining a 2-category as a category enriched in 1-categories. While the simplicial approach offers a natural inductive intuition, it's been challenging to formalize this within the more combinatorial globular framework. This paper aims to reconcile these by showing how the inductive "enrichment" idea of the simplicial approach can be precisely formulated using globular operads. Specifically, it addresses how to connect the algebras of a given operad (a combinatorial tool for defining higher structures) to the concept of categories enriched over a specific mathematical structure (a lax monoidal category).

Methods

The paper introduces and utilizes several key mathematical concepts:

  • $\omega$-operads and Normalised $\omega$-operads: These are combinatorial objects used in the globular approach to define higher categorical structures. Normalised operads are a specific type that doesn't add structure at the object level.
  • Lax Monoidal Categories and Multitensors: These generalize the familiar concept of a monoidal category. A multitensor is essentially a lax monoidal structure on a category. The paper shows how to construct a canonical multitensor from a monad.
  • Enriched Categories: This is the core concept from category theory where the "hom-sets" (sets of arrows between objects) are replaced by objects from another category. The paper focuses on categories enriched over a lax monoidal category.
  • T-operads and T-multitensors: These are generalizations of operads and multitensors, respectively, related to a specific monad T.
  • Parametric Right Adjoints (p.r.a.): A technical property of functors that is crucial for establishing the equivalences presented in the paper.

The paper establishes equivalences between:

  1. Normalised $\omega$-operads and T-multitensors.
  2. Algebras of a normalised $\omega$-operad and categories enriched over the corresponding T-multitensor.

This is achieved by developing the theory of multitensors, showing how they relate to monads, and then applying these general results to the specific case of the strict $\omega$-category monad.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Globular and Simplicial Views: The paper provides a concrete mechanism to translate the inductive "enrichment" intuition of simplicial higher category theory into the language of globular operads. This is a significant step towards a unified understanding of higher categories.
  • Algebras as Enriched Categories: The core insight is that algebras of a normalised operad can be precisely characterized as categories enriched over a specific lax monoidal structure. This offers a new perspective on what "higher categorical structures" truly are.
  • The Power of T-multitensors: The paper develops the theory of T-multitensors, showing their deep connection to T-operads and providing a framework for studying enriched categories in a general setting.
  • Inductive Definition of the Strict $\omega$-Category Monad: A key technical contribution is a purely inductive combinatorial description of the strict $\omega$-category monad, which is fundamental for understanding strict $\omega$-categories.

Key Results

  • An equivalence is established between normalised $\omega$-operads and a specific type of multitensor (T-multitensors).
  • An equivalence is established between the algebras of a normalised $\omega$-operad and categories enriched over the corresponding T-multitensor.
  • The paper provides a detailed, inductive combinatorial description of the strict $\omega$-category monad.
  • The results are shown to specialize to finite dimensions, connecting to the standard definition of strict $n$-categories.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalization to Higher Dimensions: While the paper focuses on $\omega$-operads, it mentions that the results can be adapted to finite-dimensional $n$-operads. Further work is suggested in [3] to explore the theory of lifted lax monoidal structures, which would capture more complex examples like the Gray tensor product.
  • Combinatorial Complexity: The paper deals with highly abstract and combinatorial structures. While it aims for clarity, the complexity of the definitions and proofs might be a barrier for some readers.
  • Specific Monad Properties: The theory relies on specific properties of the monad T (being p.r.a and V being lextensive). Extending these results to more general settings could be a direction for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{batanin2011algebras,
  author = {Michael Batanin and Mark Weber},
  title = {{Algebras of Higher Operads as Enriched Categories}},
  journal = {Appl. Categorical Struct.},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1007/s10485-008-9179-7},
}
Figure