Algebras of diagonal operators of the form scalar-plus-compact are\n Calkin algebras

Pavlos Motakis, Daniele Puglisi, Andreas S. ToliasarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper solves a significant problem in functional analysis by proving that for any Banach space $X$ with a Schauder basis, the algebra of its "scalar-plus-compact" diagonal operators can be realized as a Calkin algebra. By constructing a sophisticated new class of Banach spaces, the authors demonstrate that classical structures like James spaces and various Hereditarily Indecomposable (HI) spaces are actually isomorphic to the quotient algebras of bounded operators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The central question in this sub-field of operator theory is: Which unital Banach algebras can occur as Calkin algebras?

The Calkin algebra of a Banach space $X$, denoted $Cal(X)$, is the quotient $\mathcal{L}(X)/\mathcal{K}(X)$, where $\mathcal{L}(X)$ represents all bounded linear operators and $\mathcal{K}(X)$ represents the ideal of compact operators. For a Hilbert space, the Calkin algebra is "huge" and simple. However, in 2011, Argyros and Haydon shocked the field by constructing a space where the Calkin algebra is just one-dimensional (the "scalar-plus-compact" property).

This paper addresses the gap between these two extremes. Specifically, it asks if we can "prescribe" a specific algebra of diagonal operators (those that act like infinite matrices with entries only on the main diagonal) and find a space whose Calkin algebra matches that prescription.

Methods

The authors employ a highly technical construction to build a new Banach space $\mathcal{Y}_X$ tailored to a given space $X$. The key techniques include:

  • Bourgain-Delbaen/Argyros-Haydon Method: They use this framework to ensure the space has very few operators (preventing the Calkin algebra from becoming too large or uncontrollable).
  • Horizontally Block Finite Representability: They define a new type of direct sum, $\mathcal{X} = (\bigoplus X_k)^X_{utc}$, which allows the target space $X$ to be "crudely" represented within the block structure of the new space.
  • Rapidly Increasing Sequences (RIS) and Exact Pairs: These are standard but advanced tools in the study of HI spaces, used here to "test" the behavior of operators and prove they must be of the form "scalar plus diagonal plus compact."
  • Isomorphism with $\epsilon$-control: They don't just prove an algebraic isomorphism; they show that for any $\epsilon > 0$, the space can be constructed such that the isomorphism $\Phi$ satisfies $\|\Phi\| \|\Phi^{-1}\| \leq 1 + \epsilon$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a work of pure mathematics, the results are derived through formal proofs rather than empirical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Master Theorem" (Theorem I): The most striking insight is that the complexity of $X$ (its basis, its reflexivity) can be mirrored perfectly in the Calkin algebra of a much more complex space $\mathcal{Y}_X$.
  • Quasi-reflexivity: The authors successfully construct the first examples of quasi-reflexive Calkin algebras. A space is quasi-reflexive if it is "almost" reflexive (its second dual has codimension 1 or $n$ over its image).
  • Jamesification: They show that the "Jamesification" of a space—a process that turns a space into a non-reflexive, quasi-reflexive version of itself—results in an algebra that is a Calkin algebra.
  • Commutativity: The algebras studied here, $\mathbb{R}I \oplus \mathcal{K}_{\text{diag}}(X)$, are always commutative and semi-simple, providing a clear structural counterpoint to the non-commutative Calkin algebras of Hilbert spaces.

Key Results

  • Theorem I: For every Banach space $X$ with a Schauder basis, there exists a space $\mathcal{Y}_X$ such that $Cal(\mathcal{Y}_X) \cong \mathbb{R}I \oplus \mathcal{K}_{\text{diag}}(X)$.
  • Theorem II: There exists a Hereditarily Indecomposable (HI) Calkin algebra that is quasi-reflexive of order one.
  • Theorem VI: Every non-reflexive Banach space with a normalized unconditional basis is isomorphic (as a Banach space) to a Calkin algebra.
  • Approximation: Every bounded operator on the constructed space $\mathcal{Y}_X$ can be expressed as the limit of a sequence of operators of the form $a_0 I + \sum a_k I_k + K_n$, where $I_k$ are projections and $K_n$ are compact.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several open frontiers:

  • Reflexivity (Problem 1): Does there exist a Calkin algebra that is both reflexive and infinite-dimensional? This remains a major "holy grail" in the field.
  • Diagonalization (Problem 2): Can we find a space with an unconditional basis where every bounded operator is just a diagonal operator plus a compact one?
  • Uncountable Cases (Problem 4): Can $C(K)$ for an uncountable compact space $K$ be realized as a Calkin algebra? Current methods primarily handle countable compacta.
  • Submultiplicativity: The paper notes that while many difference bases are submultiplicative (useful for algebra structures), it is not yet proven for all conditional spreading sequences.

Summary updated

Abstract

For every Banach space $X$ with a Schauder basis consider the Banach algebra\n$\\mathbb{R} I\\oplus\\mathcal{K}_\\mathrm{diag}(X)$ of all diagonal operators that\nare of the form $\\lambda I + K$. We prove that $\\mathbb{R}\nI\\oplus\\mathcal{K}_\\mathrm{diag}(X)$ is a Calkin algbra i.e., there exists a\nBanach space $\\mathcal{Y}_X$ so that the Calkin algebra of $\\mathcal{Y}_X$ is\nisomorphic as a Banach algebra to $\\mathbb{R}\nI\\oplus\\mathcal{K}_\\mathrm{diag}(X)$. Among other applications of this theorem\nwe obtain that certain hereditarily indecomposable spaces and the James spaces\n$J_p$ and their duals endowed with natural multiplications are Calkin algebras,\nthat all non-reflexive Banach spaces with unconditional bases are isomorphic as\nBanach spaces to Calkin algebras, and that sums of reflexive spaces with\nunconditional bases with certain James-Tsirelson type spaces are isomorphic as\nBanach spaces to Calkin algebras.\n
BibTeX
@misc{motakis2017algebras,
  author = {Pavlos Motakis and Daniele Puglisi and Andreas S. Tolias},
  title = {{Algebras of diagonal operators of the form scalar-plus-compact are\textbackslash\{\}n Calkin algebras}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1711.01340},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1711.01340},
}

Loading related content...

Figure