Algebraic higher symmetry and categorical symmetry: A holographic and entanglement view of symmetry

Liang Kong, Lan, Tian, Xiao-Gang Wen, Zhi-Hao Zhang, Hao ZhengDSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) 2020

TL;DR

This paper introduces "algebraic higher symmetry," a generalization of symmetry that goes beyond traditional group structures. It proposes that these symmetries can be understood and classified through the lens of "categorical symmetry," which is equivalent to topological orders in higher dimensions. This provides a holographic and entanglement-based perspective on symmetries, revealing that gapped states must partially break these symmetries, while the full symmetry is only realized in gapless states.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of understanding and classifying symmetries in quantum systems, particularly those that go beyond the familiar framework of Lie groups or discrete groups. Traditional "global symmetries" act uniformly across a system. However, more complex "higher symmetries" can act on lower-dimensional submanifolds (like strings or membranes), and these transformations can form structures more general than groups, termed "higher groups." The authors introduce "algebraic higher symmetry" as an even broader concept, where the symmetry transformations might not even be invertible. A key problem is to find a unified and mathematical framework to describe, classify, and understand the implications of these generalized symmetries, especially their connection to anomalies and topological phases of matter.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in the development and application of higher category theory to describe symmetries. Specifically:

  • Algebraic Higher Symmetry: Introduced as a generalization of higher symmetries, characterized by operators that might not be invertible and can act on various submanifolds.
  • Local Fusion n-Categories: These are proposed as the mathematical objects that classify anomaly-free algebraic higher symmetries.
  • Categorical Symmetry: This concept is introduced as a holographic and entanglement-based view of symmetry, equivalent to a non-invertible gravitational anomaly or a topological order in one higher dimension.
  • Holographic Principle: The paper leverages the idea that anomalies in a system can be understood as topological orders in a higher-dimensional bulk. This allows for a "boundary-bulk" correspondence for symmetries.
  • Gauging Algebraic Higher Symmetry: A method is proposed to "gauge" these generalized symmetries, leading to higher gauge theories.
  • Classification of Phases: The framework is used to classify gapped liquid phases, including SPT and SET orders, with algebraic higher symmetries.

The approach moves away from purely group-theoretic definitions towards a more abstract, categorical framework, connecting symmetries to the structure of excitations and their fusion rules.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is theoretical and focuses on mathematical frameworks and conceptual development rather than empirical data or computational simulations on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry as Topological Order: The most profound insight is the equivalence between algebraic higher symmetry and categorical symmetry, which is identified with topological orders in one higher dimension. This provides a powerful holographic perspective, suggesting that symmetries are deeply intertwined with the topological properties of quantum systems.
  • Gapped vs. Gapless States: A crucial consequence of categorical symmetry is that gapped ground states must spontaneously break part of the symmetry, while the full symmetry is only realized in gapless states. This offers a new way to understand the distinction between different phases of matter.
  • Classification Power of Higher Categories: The paper demonstrates that local fusion n-categories are the natural mathematical structures for classifying algebraic higher symmetries and their associated phases. This highlights the utility of abstract mathematical tools in understanding complex physical phenomena.
  • Duality and Holo-Equivalence: The concept of "holo-equivalence" is introduced to describe symmetries that are equivalent from a holographic perspective, even if their underlying transformations differ. This reveals deeper connections between seemingly different symmetry structures.
  • Generalization Beyond Groups: The work significantly extends the understanding of symmetry beyond traditional group theory, opening avenues for studying more complex and exotic symmetry structures in quantum systems.

Key Results

  • Definition and Classification of Algebraic Higher Symmetry: The paper formally defines algebraic higher symmetry and proposes that anomaly-free versions are classified by local fusion n-categories.
  • Categorical Symmetry as Holographic View: Algebraic higher symmetry is shown to be equivalent to categorical symmetry, which is identified with topological orders in one higher dimension.
  • Gauging and Anomalies: Methods for gauging algebraic higher symmetries and classifying their anomalies are presented.
  • Classification of Gapped Phases: The framework leads to a classification of gapped liquid phases (including SPT and SET orders) for systems with categorical symmetries.
  • Emergence of Symmetries: The paper discusses how algebraic higher symmetries and categorical symmetries can emerge at low energies due to energy scale separation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mathematical Rigor: The authors acknowledge that the precise mathematical definitions of weak n-categories are still under development, and their approach relies on physical interpretations and some preliminary mathematical frameworks.
  • Generalization to Fermions and Anyons: While some results are extended to fermionic systems, a full treatment for arbitrary anyonic systems is left for future work.
  • Specific Examples: While examples are discussed, a deeper exploration of concrete lattice models realizing these algebraic higher symmetries and their emergent properties is suggested.
  • Physical Interpretation of Automorphisms: The precise physical meaning of certain mathematical structures, like automorphisms of condensable algebras and their relation to physical properties, requires further investigation.
  • Uniqueness of Minimal Gapless States: The paper notes that it's not clear whether the minimal gapless state for a given categorical symmetry is unique.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce the notion of algebraic higher symmetry, which generalizes higher symmetry and is beyond higher group. We show that an algebraic higher symmetry in a bosonic system in $n$-dimensional space is characterized and classified by a local fusion $n$-category. We find another way to describe algebraic higher symmetry by restricting to symmetric sub Hilbert space where symmetry transformations all become trivial. In this case, algebraic higher symmetry can be fully characterized by a non-invertible gravitational anomaly (i.e. an topological order in one higher dimension). Thus we also refer to non-invertible gravitational anomaly as categorical symmetry to stress its connection to symmetry. This provides a holographic and entanglement view of symmetries. For a system with a categorical symmetry, its gapped state must spontaneously break part (not all) of the symmetry, and the state with the full symmetry must be gapless. Using such a holographic point of view, we obtain (1) the gauging of the algebraic higher symmetry; (2) the classification of anomalies for an algebraic higher symmetry; (3) the equivalence between classes of systems, with different (potentially anomalous) algebraic higher symmetries or different sets of low energy excitations, as long as they have the same categorical symmetry; (4) the classification of gapped liquid phases for bosonic/fermionic systems with a categorical symmetry, as gapped boundaries of a topological order in one higher dimension (that corresponds to the categorical symmetry). This classification includes symmetry protected trivial (SPT) orders and symmetry enriched topological (SET) orders with an algebraic higher symmetry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kong2020algebraic,
  author = {Liang Kong and Lan, Tian and Xiao-Gang Wen and Zhi-Hao Zhang and Hao Zheng},
  title = {{Algebraic higher symmetry and categorical symmetry: A holographic and entanglement view of symmetry}},
  booktitle = {DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure