Algebraic and Geometric Models for Space Networking

William Bernardoni, Robert Cardona, Jacob Cleveland, Justin Curry, Robert Green, Brian Heller, Alan Hylton, Tung Lam, Robert Kassouf-ShortarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper presents a mathematical framework for space networking using time-varying graphs (TVGs) represented as matrices over specialized algebraic structures called semi-rings. By integrating these algebraic tools with Topological Data Analysis (TDA), the authors develop novel methods to quantify connectivity, account for significant propagation delays, and automatically classify satellite constellations based on their temporal topology.

Introduction: The Challenge of Orbital Connectivity

Traditional networking protocols, such as TCP/IP, are built on the assumption of low-latency, relatively static architectures. Space networking fundamentally breaks these assumptions. In orbit, "line-of-sight" between satellites or ground stations is intermittent due to orbital mechanics and planetary occlusions. Furthermore, the speed of light introduces significant propagation delays—ranging from 1.2 seconds for the Moon to over 20 minutes for Mars—rendering traditional feedback-based protocols ineffective.

Figure 1: Visualization of satellite connectivity and line-of-sight constraints in an Earth-centered inertial frame.

To scale toward a "Solar System Internet," the industry must move away from manual scheduling toward automated systems capable of modeling, analyzing, and routing data through networks that are constantly in motion and plagued by long delays.

Methodology: Algebra and Topology

The researchers bridge the gap between abstract mathematics and satellite engineering through two primary lenses:

1. Algebraic Semi-Rings

The authors define a TVG as a matrix where each entry represents a subset of time—the "lifetimes" during which a link exists. By treating these subsets as elements of a semi-ring (where addition is union and multiplication is intersection), they can use matrix operations to calculate multi-hop connectivity. Key constructions include:

  • Kleene Star: Used to find the transitive closure of the network to determine multi-hop reachability.
  • Propagation Delay Semi-Ring: A novel structure that incorporates signal travel time, modeling how messages "age" as they traverse space.
  • Universal Contact Semi-Ring (UCS): A complex structure designed to model "store-and-forward" protocols, where satellites hold data in memory until a new link window opens.
Figure 2: Temporal connectivity windows (lifetimes) between ground stations and satellites, modeled as a time-varying graph.

2. Topological Data Analysis (TDA)

The paper employs zigzag persistence to track how the "shape" of the network—specifically its connected components and cycles—evolves over time. This process produces "barcodes," which serve as visual and mathematical summaries of how long certain topological features persist.

Experimental Results and Insights

The study utilized real-world orbital data from the STARLINK constellation (over 3,000 satellites) and high-fidelity simulations via NASA’s Satellite Orbital Analysis Program (SOAP). Key findings include:

  • The n=40 Phase Transition: For STARLINK sub-networks, a "phase transition" in connectivity was discovered. Once a randomly sampled sub-network exceeds approximately 40 satellites, the probability of the network being strongly connected increases significantly.
  • Topology as a Fingerprint: The time-varying topology alone is sufficient to distinguish between lunar and Martian networks. Using a K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN) classifier on zigzag persistence barcodes, the authors achieved 93% to 98% accuracy in identifying constellation types without needing spatial coordinates.
  • Temporal Diameter: Simulations of 100-node STARLINK clusters demonstrated a "temporal diameter" (the maximum hops needed to connect any two nodes at any time) of typically 6 or 7.
  • Non-Convergence in Deep Space: In networks with significant propagation delay (e.g., Earth-to-Mars), the standard Kleene star operator may never converge, providing an algebraic explanation for the fundamental difficulty of deep-space routing.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the TDA approach is powerful, it is computationally intensive; a 50-node simulation required nearly 200 minutes to process on a high-end laptop. Additionally, the current model assumes that any line-of-sight enables communication, ignoring hardware constraints like the limited number of antennas per satellite. Future work will focus on developing faster algorithms that operate directly on matrix TVGs and exploring how orbital periodicity can be used to simplify the underlying mathematics.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{bernardoni2023algebraic,
  author = {William Bernardoni and Robert Cardona and Jacob Cleveland and Justin Curry and Robert Green and Brian Heller and Alan Hylton and Tung Lam and Robert Kassouf-Short},
  title = {{Algebraic and Geometric Models for Space Networking}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2304.01150},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01150},
}
Figure