Alexander Knox at SemEval-2023 Task 5: The comparison of prompting and standard fine-tuning techniques for selecting the type of spoiler needed to neutralize a clickbait

Mateusz Woźny, Mateusz LangoACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper compares two transfer learning techniques – prompting and fine-tuning – for classifying the type of spoiler (phrase, passage, or multipart) needed to neutralize clickbait. The authors found that standard fine-tuning of pre-trained language models significantly outperforms prompting for this task, with RoBERTa achieving the best results.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clickbait headlines are a pervasive issue on social media, designed to lure users with misleading or sensational titles. While detecting clickbait is important, it doesn't solve the problem. The authors build upon prior work that proposed using "spoilers" – short texts summarizing the linked content – to neutralize clickbait. However, simply generating a spoiler isn't enough; understanding what kind of spoiler is most effective is crucial. This paper tackles the problem of automatically classifying the type of spoiler (a single phrase, a short passage, or a combination of multiple parts) required to neutralize a given clickbait post and its associated content. This classification is a critical first step towards building a robust spoiler generation system.

Methods

The core of this research lies in comparing two distinct transfer learning approaches for text classification:

  • Prompting: This method leverages large language models (LLMs) like BLOOM by framing the classification task as a text generation problem. Instead of updating model weights, a carefully crafted "prompt" is fed to the LLM, which includes task instructions and a few examples. The LLM then "completes" the prompt to provide the desired output (the spoiler type). This approach is attractive because it doesn't require extensive fine-tuning or large labeled datasets. The authors explored various prompt structures and the impact of the number of few-shot examples. They also experimented with using LLMs to generate synthetic spoilers, which were then used to augment the training data for a subsequent classifier.
  • Standard Fine-Tuning: This is a more traditional transfer learning technique where a pre-trained language model (like RoBERTa, DistilBERT, or ALBERT) is further trained on a specific downstream task. The model's weights are updated through backpropagation using a labeled dataset. This method typically requires a larger dataset but is known for its robustness and ability to adapt the model deeply to the task. The authors applied this to the clickbait spoiler-type classification problem, using both original and LLM-generated spoilers.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is derived from the SemEval-2023 Task 5 dataset. The authors utilized the train.jsonl and validation.jsonl files for training and evaluation. Notably, the official test dataset for subtask 1 of SemEval-2023 Task 5 was not publicly available at the time of writing, so the authors used the provided validation examples as their test set and a portion of the training data as their validation set for experimental evaluation. They also generated synthetic spoilers using LLMs to augment the training data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fine-tuning reigns supreme: The most significant finding is that standard fine-tuning of pre-trained models consistently outperforms prompting for this specific spoiler-type classification task. This suggests that for tasks requiring nuanced understanding and classification, direct model adaptation is more effective than prompt-based generation.
  • Prompting's limitations: While prompting offers advantages in terms of data efficiency, its performance was notably lower. This highlights the challenge of crafting effective prompts and the potential for LLMs to struggle with precise classification tasks when guided solely by prompts.
  • Generated spoilers can help, but with caveats: Using LLM-generated spoilers to augment training data for fine-tuning models showed promise, leading to better results than prompting alone. However, this approach also increased computational time significantly.
  • Reproducibility challenges: The authors noted that their results for the RoBERTa model on the SemEval test set were slightly worse than those reported by Hagen et al. (2022) for the same model. They attribute this potential discrepancy to differences in training data structure, limited computational resources, and the inherent difficulty in reproducing neural model results due to various training process variations.

Key Results

  • Fine-tuning superiority: In the final experiment (Section 5.4), fine-tuned models achieved significantly better performance than prompting. For instance, RoBERTa achieved a balanced accuracy of 0.73, outperforming the best prompting results (around 0.40).
  • RoBERTa as the best model: Among the fine-tuned models tested (RoBERTa, DistilBERT, ALBERT), RoBERTa consistently delivered the highest performance across various metrics.
  • Prompting performance: The best performance achieved using prompting (Section 5.2) was around 0.40 balanced accuracy, and increasing the number of few-shot examples did not necessarily improve results.
  • SemEval Test Set Performance: On the SemEval-2023 test set, the fine-tuned RoBERTa model achieved a balanced accuracy of 0.70.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Prompt engineering complexity: The authors acknowledge that designing effective prompts is non-trivial and can require domain expertise. They suggest that automatic prompt generation techniques (like those by Shin et al., 2020) could be a valuable area for future research.
  • Model exploration: While RoBERTa performed well, the authors mention that other Transformer architectures, such as DeBERTa (which Hagen et al. (2022) explored), were not tested due to computational resource limitations. Investigating these models could yield further improvements.
  • Reproducibility: The authors highlight the general challenge of reproducing neural model results and suggest that more detailed reporting of hyperparameters and training configurations is needed for better reproducibility.
  • Generated spoiler quality: The paper notes that sometimes the generated spoilers were not of high quality, which could limit their helpfulness. Further research into improving the quality and relevance of LLM-generated spoilers is warranted.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wozny2023alexander,
  author = {Mateusz Woźny and Mateusz Lango},
  title = {{Alexander Knox at SemEval-2023 Task 5: The comparison of prompting and standard fine-tuning techniques for selecting the type of spoiler needed to neutralize a clickbait}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure