TL;DR
This paper proposes a shift from subjective passenger surveys to an objective "Airline Service Quality Measurement" (ASQM) model based on five years of official complaint statistics. By analyzing nearly 80,000 complaints in China, the researchers demonstrate that while in-flight and ground services remain relatively stable, ticketing and flight delays are the primary, highly volatile drivers of passenger dissatisfaction.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Evaluating airline service quality is notoriously difficult. Traditional methods like the Customer Satisfaction Degree (CSD) or the SERVQUAL scale rely heavily on subjective surveys, which often suffer from small sample sizes, non-representative data, and the inherent bias of the "expected vs. experienced" gap.
The authors argue that these methods fail to capture the "true feelings" of the broader passenger base. To address this, they turn to Two-Factor Theory, which distinguishes between factors that cause satisfaction and those that cause dissatisfaction. By treating official complaints as an objective proxy for the "dissatisfaction factor," the paper seeks to provide a more robust, data-driven assessment of how 26 full-service and six low-cost airlines in China actually perform over time.
Methods
The researchers employed a two-pronged analytical approach:
- Optimal Scale Analysis (Multiple Correspondence Analysis): To visualize the relationship between categorical variables (complaint types) and temporal factors (years, quarters, months), the authors used MCA to map data into a low-dimensional space. This allowed them to identify "acute angle" relationships, signifying high correlations between specific times of year and specific service failures.
- ASQM Model: Drawing on the Civil Aviation Passenger Service Evaluation (CAPSE) index, the authors constructed a measurement model: $$P_j = \sum_i \frac{1 - \frac{N_{ij}}{C_i}}{2}$$ Where $P$ is the quality index, $N$ is the number of complaints, and $C$ is the air traffic volume. This formula normalizes raw complaint counts against passenger volume, allowing for a fair comparison between massive carriers and smaller regional airlines.
Datasets
The study utilized a comprehensive dataset derived from the Air Transport Consumer Complaint Bulletin issued by the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC).
- Timeframe: January 2015 to December 2019 (60 months).
- Volume: 79,773 total complaints (71,556 domestic and 8,217 foreign).
- Scope: 32 Chinese airlines (26 full-service, 6 low-cost/differentiated).
- Categorization: Complaints were coded into five levels, ranging from flight delays and ticketing issues to baggage handling and "special services" discrimination.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The August Peak: Complaints aren't just higher in summer because more people fly; they are disproportionately higher. August is the "perfect storm" where weather-related delays (thunderstorms) and high traffic volume lead to a spike in complex, multi-category complaints.
- Stability vs. Volatility: The data reveals that "in-flight service" and "ground service" are relatively stable across the industry. These are "hygiene factors"—passengers expect them to be decent, and airlines have largely standardized them. In contrast, "ticketing service" (driven by overselling) and "flight service" (delays) are highly volatile and represent the biggest threats to an airline's reputation.
- The Full-Service Advantage: Full-service airlines consistently outperformed low-cost carriers across all metrics. However, even full-service giants saw a 19.43% decrease in their average quality index over the five-year period, suggesting that as traffic volume grows, maintaining service standards becomes exponentially harder.
- The "Inverted V" Growth: Domestic complaints showed a cyclical, "inverted V" growth trend within each year, peaking in the third quarter.
Key Results
- Industry Performance: The average service quality index for full-service airlines was 3.79 (Medium level), while low-cost airlines averaged 2.73 (Lower level).
- The "Overselling" Problem: Ticketing service quality saw a significant decline across the board. For low-cost airlines, ticketing and flight service quality dropped by roughly 8.8% during the study period.
- Individual Outliers:
- Chongqing Airlines was highlighted for maintaining high quality across all categories.
- Happiness Airlines experienced the most dramatic decline, with a 73-fold increase in complaints leading to a 55.92% drop in its service quality index.
- Model Validation: The MCA showed a typical correlation value of 0.998 for domestic complaints, indicating that the time-related variables (month/season) are excellent predictors of complaint types.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that while complaints are an objective measure of dissatisfaction, they do not capture the "satisfaction" side of the Two-Factor Theory—the "delight" factors that don't result in a formal filing.
Future Research Directions: * Causal Analysis: Moving beyond when complaints happen to why specific operational failures (like the "overselling problem") are becoming more frequent. * Incentive Mechanisms: Investigating how employee incentive programs and hardware upgrades directly impact the reduction of complaint volumes. * Post-Pandemic Comparison: As this data ends in 2019, a natural next step would be comparing these "baseline" statistics to the volatile service environment of the COVID-19 and post-COVID eras.
Summary updated