Aircraft observations of gravity wave activity and turbulence in the tropical tropopause layer: prevalence, influence on cirrus and comparison with global-storm resolving models

Rachel Atlas, Christopher S. Bretherton2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses aircraft data to investigate the interplay between gravity waves, turbulence, and cirrus cloud formation in the tropical tropopause layer (TTL). It provides the first observational evidence that small-scale vertical motions, driven by both gravity waves and turbulence, are crucial for forming high ice water content cirrus clouds, which significantly impact atmospheric dehydration. The research also highlights shortcomings in current global storm-resolving models in capturing these small-scale vertical wind dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The tropical tropopause layer (TTL) is a critical region for Earth's climate, acting as a gateway for water vapor into the stratosphere. TTL cirrus clouds play a significant role in dehydrating the atmosphere, influencing stratospheric water vapor content and thus radiative forcing and ozone levels. While previous modeling studies have suggested that small-scale vertical motions (less than 100 km) – specifically gravity waves and turbulence – are key to initiating homogeneous freezing and controlling the microphysical properties (like ice crystal number concentration) of TTL cirrus, this hypothesis lacked direct observational confirmation. Furthermore, understanding the relative roles of gravity waves and turbulence, and how they interact with cirrus formation, is essential for improving climate models.

Methods

The researchers analyzed high-rate (20 Hz) vertical wind data from five NASA aircraft campaigns, alongside ice water content (IWC) measurements. They developed an algorithm to distinguish between different atmospheric conditions: quiescent, long-wavelength gravity wave activity (LW GWA), short-wavelength gravity wave activity (SW GWA), and turbulence. Vertical wind variance was used as a proxy for turbulence, while specific criteria were applied to classify LW GWA and SW GWA based on spatial scales and wind variability. They also analyzed the relationship between these vertical motions and TTL cirrus microphysical properties (IWC and ice crystal number concentration). Finally, they compared observed vertical wind power spectra with simulations from four global storm-resolving models (GSRMs) to evaluate model performance.

Datasets

The study utilized data from five NASA flight campaigns:

  • Airborne Tropical TRopopause Experiment (ATTREX) in 2013 and 2014
  • Pacific Oxidants, Sulfur, Ice, Dehydration, and cONvection (POSIDON)
  • Tropical Composition, Cloud and Climate Coupling Experiment (TC4)
  • Cirrus Regional Study of Tropical Anvils and Cirrus Layers - Florida Area Cirrus Experiment (CRYSTAL-FACE)

Brightness temperature data from the NCEP/CPC's Merged IR product (MERGIR) was used to identify deep convective cores. Simulations from four global storm-resolving models (DYAMOND-1 intercomparison) were also used:

  • Nonhydrostatic ICosahedral Atmospheric Model (NICAM)
  • Global System for Atmospheric Modeling (gSAM)
  • Finite-Volume Cubed-Sphere Dynamical Core (FV3)
  • ICON (Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic Weather and Climate Model)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Turbulence and gravity waves are not independent: The study found that turbulence rarely occurs in the absence of gravity wave activity, suggesting a strong co-occurrence and potential causal link.
  • Cirrus formation is strongly linked to vertical motion: High ice water content (IWC) cirrus clouds are significantly more likely to form when gravity waves are present, and even more so when turbulence is also active. This provides observational support for modeling studies.
  • Small-scale motions are key to dehydration: High-IWC cirrus, which are more effective at dehydrating the TTL, are strongly associated with both gravity wave activity and turbulence. This highlights the importance of these small-scale processes for atmospheric water vapor regulation.
  • Models struggle with small-scale dynamics: Global storm-resolving models, even with fine grid spacing, tend to underestimate vertical wind variability at scales relevant to TTL cirrus formation, particularly at wavelengths less than 100 km.

Key Results

  • Vertical wind variability in the TTL is well-represented by a normal distribution with a standard deviation of 0.2–0.4 m s⁻¹.
  • Turbulence is enhanced within cirrus clouds with high ice water content (IWC > 10⁻³ g m⁻³), which also exhibit high ice crystal number concentrations.
  • Turbulence is more frequent closer to deep convection (lower TTL, 14-15.5 km) and further from convection (upper TTL, 15.5-17 km).
  • High-IWC cirrus are about 20 times more likely when gravity wave activity is present and 50 times more likely when both gravity waves and turbulence are present, compared to quiescent conditions.
  • Four global storm-resolving models (gSAM, ICON, FV3, NICAM) all underestimate vertical wind power at wavelengths less than 100 km compared to aircraft observations. gSAM showed the least bias among the models.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their study provides strong observational evidence for the link between small-scale vertical motions and TTL cirrus, it cannot definitively rule out cloud-driven turbulence as a dominant source. Clues suggest clear-sky sources of turbulence might be more prevalent. Future work could involve more closely examining these turbulent sources. Additionally, the study highlights the need for improved resolution in global storm-resolving models to better capture the small-scale vertical wind variability crucial for TTL processes. Future studies could explore the impact of increased vertical and horizontal resolution in regional cloud-resolving models.

Summary updated

Abstract

The tropical tropopause layer (TTL) is a sea of vertical motions. Convectively-generated gravity waves create vertical winds on scales of a few to 1000s of kilometers as they propagate in a stable atmosphere. Turbulence from gravity wave breaking, radiatively-driven convection and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities stirs up the TTL on the kilometer scale. TTL cirrus, which moderate the water vapor concentration in the TTL and stratosphere, form in the cold phases of large-scale (> 100 km) wave activity. It has been proposed in several modelling studies that small-scale (< 100 km) vertical motions control the ice crystal number concentration and the dehydration efficiency of TTL cirrus, but this has yet to be confirmed with observations. High-rate vertical winds measured by aircraft are a valuable and underutilized tool for constraining small-scale TTL vertical wind variability, examining its impacts on TTL cirrus, and evaluating atmospheric models. We use 20 Hz data from five National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) campaigns to quantify small-scale vertical wind variability in the TTL, and to see how it varies with ice water content, distance from deep convective cores, and height in the TTL. We find that 1 Hz vertical winds are well represented by a normal distribution with a standard deviation of 0.2–0.4 m s-1. We find that turbulence is enhanced within cirrus with high ice water content (IWC) (g m-3), which also have high ice crystal number concentrations. Consistent with a previous study, we find that turbulence is enhanced over the tropical West Pacific and within 500 km of convection, and is most common in the lower TTL (14–15.5 km) closer to deep convection, and in the upper TTL (15.5–17 km) further from deep convection. An algorithm to classify turbulence, and long wavelength (5 km < λ < 100 km) and short wavelength (λ < 5 km) gravity waves during level flight legs is applied to data from the Airborne Tropical TRopopause Experiment (ATTREX). The most commonly sampled conditions are a quiescent atmosphere with negligible small-scale vertical wind variability, and long wavelength gravity wave activity with or without turbulence. Turbulence rarely occurs in the absence of gravity wave activity. High-IWC cirrus are rare in a quiescent atmosphere, but 20 times more likely when there is gravity wave activity and 50 times more likely when there is also turbulence, confirming the results of the aforementioned modeling studies. Spectral analysis of vertical wind observed in level flight legs over the tropical West Pacific TTL is compared with simulations by four global storm-resolving models with horizontal grid spacings of 3–5 km, sampled over the same region. All four models have too little resolved vertical wind at horizontal wavelengths less than 100 km, but this bias is much less pronounced in global SAM than the other models.
BibTeX
@misc{atlas2022aircraft,
  author = {Rachel Atlas and Christopher S. Bretherton},
  title = {{Aircraft observations of gravity wave activity and turbulence in the tropical tropopause layer: prevalence, influence on cirrus and comparison with global-storm resolving models}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2022-491},
}

Loading related content...

Figure