AI Planning for Hybrid Systems

Enrico ScalaIJCAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores AI planning for "hybrid systems" – systems with both continuous (like physics) and discrete (like on/off switches) behaviors. The authors propose a model-based approach using heuristic search to tackle the complexity of these systems, aiming for explainable AI solutions that don't rely on massive datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Planning for physical systems, like robots or industrial plants, is challenging because their behavior isn't just a series of discrete steps. Instead, their state evolves continuously over time, influenced by underlying physics (differential equations) and punctuated by discrete events or actions. Traditional AI planning often struggles with this mix of continuous dynamics and discrete decision-making. Languages like PDDL+ attempt to model these hybrid systems, but the inherent complexity makes planning difficult, leading some to turn to black-box machine learning approaches. This paper argues for a return to model-based reasoning, specifically focusing on how to build planners that can effectively handle these hybrid systems, especially when data is scarce and explainability is crucial.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in adapting Best-First Search (BFS), a standard AI planning technique, for hybrid systems. The authors propose two key ingredients:

  1. A modified BFS algorithm: This algorithm needs to handle "spontaneous/controllable numeric changes" and general numeric expressions. The approach involves discretizing time and treating planning as a sequential decision problem. The BFS explores possible futures by expanding nodes representing states and generating successor nodes by considering both actions and time progression. Time progression is handled by updating state variables based on the system's continuous dynamics.
  2. Relaxation-based heuristics: To guide the BFS efficiently, the paper discusses designing heuristics that are sensitive to the hybrid nature of the problem. This involves relaxing the problem into a simpler, sequential numeric planning problem. Two main relaxation strategies are highlighted:
  3. Subgoaling-based relaxation: This approach treats processes and events as controllable by the agent, allowing the use of existing heuristics for numeric planning. It focuses on "achievers" – actions that contribute to satisfying goals.
  4. Interval-based relaxation: This method views states not as single points but as intervals of possible values for numeric variables. Actions expand these intervals, and the heuristic estimates the cost to reach a goal by analyzing these intervals. This approach is more general but can be less efficient.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid systems are the future of AI in the physical world: Many real-world applications (robotics, autonomous systems) inherently involve hybrid dynamics, making planning for them critical.
  • Model-based planning can offer explainability: Unlike black-box ML, model-based approaches provide a clear understanding of why a plan is generated, which is vital for safety-critical applications.
  • Time discretization is a practical bridge: While challenging, discretizing time allows existing BFS planning frameworks to be adapted for continuous dynamics.
  • Heuristics are key to scalability: The complexity of hybrid systems necessitates sophisticated heuristics to guide search effectively and avoid exploring an unmanageable state space.
  • Balancing generality and efficiency in heuristics is hard: Subgoaling-based heuristics are efficient but limited in the complexity of dynamics they can handle, while interval-based heuristics are more general but can be computationally expensive.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present specific quantitative results from experiments but rather outlines the theoretical framework and challenges. It demonstrates how planning in hybrid systems can be cast as a sequential decision problem and discusses the types of heuristics that can guide the search. The authors highlight the promise of these techniques for delivering explainable AI solutions.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges several open challenges:

  • Deeper understanding of computational complexity: The complexity of hybrid systems, especially with unbounded numeric variables, needs further investigation.
  • Bridging relaxation techniques: Finding ways to effectively combine the strengths of subgoaling-based and interval-based relaxation heuristics is an open area.
  • Neural network heuristics: Exploring the use of neural networks to learn heuristics for hybrid systems is a promising direction.
  • Trajectory constraints: Extending planning to handle complex trajectory constraints (e.g., using signal temporal logic) in hybrid systems is a significant open problem, with current work largely focused on classical planning.
  • Practical application of advanced techniques: While many theoretical advancements exist, their widespread adoption in practical applications is still limited.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{scala2023ai,
  author = {Enrico Scala},
  title = {{AI Planning for Hybrid Systems}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2023/805},
}
Figure