TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel risk assessment framework for slurry balancing shield tunnel construction by combining the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) with Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation (FSE). This approach systematically identifies and quantifies risks across five key dimensions (human, machine, material, method, environment), offering a more comprehensive and quantitative method for safety management than existing technology-focused research.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The rapid urbanization and increasing demand for underground space have led to the widespread adoption of shield tunneling, particularly the slurry balancing method, for its safety and efficiency. However, despite its prevalence, research on the safety risk management of this construction method is lagging, with most existing studies focusing on technical aspects like ground settlement or excavation mechanics. This leaves a critical gap in understanding and mitigating the multifaceted risks inherent in complex shield tunneling projects. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a systematic, whole-process approach to risk assessment that moves beyond purely technical considerations.
Methods
The core of this paper is the development of a hybrid risk assessment model that integrates two established techniques:
- Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): AHP is used to structure the problem by breaking down the overall risk into a hierarchical system of objectives, criteria, and alternatives. This involves creating a comprehensive index system with five primary risk categories (human, machine, material, method, environment), further broken down into second and third-level indicators. AHP is then employed to determine the relative weights of these indicators through pairwise comparisons, typically using expert judgment.
- Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation (FSE): To address the subjectivity inherent in AHP and to quantify risks that are difficult to measure precisely (like "human error" or "geological conditions"), FSE is introduced. This method uses fuzzy logic to handle uncertainty and vagueness. It involves defining a set of risk levels (e.g., "large," "relatively large," "normal," "relatively small," "small") and using expert evaluations to determine the degree of membership of each risk factor to these levels. The FSE then combines the factor weights derived from AHP with the fuzzy evaluation results to produce a comprehensive risk assessment for the project.
The paper also details the process of establishing the hierarchical model, constructing judgment matrices, performing consistency tests for AHP, and then applying the FSE to calculate the overall risk evaluation results.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on expert opinions and a case study for evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Holistic Risk Framework: The paper moves beyond a purely technical view of shield tunneling risks by adopting a "human-machine-material-method-environment" framework. This acknowledges that safety is a complex interplay of various factors, not just geological or mechanical challenges.
- Quantifying Subjectivity: By combining AHP (which inherently relies on expert judgment) with FSE, the authors provide a method to quantify subjective assessments into a more concrete risk score. This is crucial for making informed decisions in a field where many risks are qualitative.
- Prioritizing Risk Areas: The weighted analysis highlights that personnel, mechanical, and environmental risks are generally the most significant contributors to overall risk in slurry balancing shield construction. This allows project managers to focus their mitigation efforts strategically.
- Case Study Validation: The application of the AHP-FSE model to a real-world cross-river tunnel project (Nanjing Metro Line 3) demonstrates its practical applicability and effectiveness in assessing and managing risks.
Key Results
The case study of the Nanjing Metro Line 3 cross-river tunnel project, using the developed AHP-FSE model, indicated an overall small risk level and a generally safe condition. However, the analysis also revealed specific areas requiring attention:
- Personnel Risk: Found to be very small, suggesting good overall staff quality.
- Material Risk: While generally low, "dimensional discrepancy" and "stacking condition" were noted as areas needing strict inspection.
- Method Risk: "Drawings change" was identified as a potential accident driver, emphasizing the need for careful review of engineering drawings.
- Environmental Risk: Geological conditions were identified as a more significant risk factor, particularly in areas with poor geology, necessitating soil reinforcement measures.
- Mechanical and Construction Environment Risks: These were generally found to be within safe limits, indicating successful safety management in these aspects for the case project.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:
- Subjectivity in AHP: While FSE helps mitigate this, the initial weighting in AHP still relies on expert judgment, which can be subjective.
- Complexity of Risk Management: Risk management is a complex system that ideally should be considered across the entire project lifecycle and involve all stakeholders. The paper notes the difficulty in systematically integrating all aspects due to the complexity of construction technology and processes.
- Tacit Knowledge: The reliance on experienced engineers for risk control and management means that much critical knowledge remains tacit. Future work should focus on making this knowledge explicit.
- Model Refinement: The authors suggest that the proposed risk evaluation system has room for modification and improvement.
- Broader Application: While validated on a specific project, further research could explore the model's applicability to a wider range of slurry balancing shield construction scenarios and different geological conditions.
Summary updated