Agricultural practices influence soil microbiome assembly and interactions at different depths identified by machine learning

Yujie Mo, Raven L. Bier, Xiaolin Li, Melinda D. Daniels, Andrew Smith, Lei Yu, Jinjun KanResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Soil microbiomes are critical to soil health and sustainable agriculture, yet their assembly and distribution across different soil depths under varying management practices remain poorly understood. This study applied machine learning-based methods to identify prokaryotic and fungal community patterns across soil depths (0–60 cm) in fields managed with different tillage, fertility sources, and cover crops. Results indicate that fertility source is the primary driver of microbial assembly, particularly for fungi, though its impact diminishes with depth. Tillage was found to predominantly affect the top 20 cm, enhancing microorganism dispersal and amplifying stochastic processes, particularly in prokaryotic communities. Notably, machine learning models demonstrated that biotic interactions are significantly stronger predictors of microbial abundance than abiotic environmental factors. These findings highlight the multifaceted impact of agricultural practices on microbial assembly and the power of machine learning to decode complex ecological interactions.

Introduction

Sustainable agriculture relies heavily on the functional stability of soil microbiomes. However, soil is often treated as a two-dimensional surface in research, overlooking the fact that microbial communities change drastically with depth. Management practices like tillage, fertilization, and cover cropping alter these communities, but traditional statistical methods often struggle with the high-dimensional, sparse, and non-linear nature of microbiome data. This study addresses these gaps by employing robust predictive frameworks to understand how management decisions influence microbial assembly and interaction networks from the surface down to 60 cm.

Methods

Researchers utilized data from the Rodale Institute’s Farming Systems Trial (FST), comparing organic (legume and manure) and conventional (synthetic fertilizer) systems. Soil cores were analyzed at four depth increments: 0–10, 10–20, 20–30, and 30–60 cm. To move beyond linear statistics, the study employed:

  • Manifold Learning (t-SNE): To capture non-linear relationships in microbial ordination.
  • Random Forest (RF) & SHAP: To predict microbial abundance and identify key biomarkers using the SHapley Additive exPlanations framework.
  • Neutral Community Model (NCM): To distinguish between deterministic processes (environmental selection) and stochastic processes (random dispersal and birth/death events).
  • Co-occurrence Networks: To identify "hub taxa" that exert disproportionate influence on community structure.

Key Insights and Results

Tillage as a Randomizer

Tillage significantly altered the assembly processes in the top 20 cm of soil. By physically mixing the soil, tillage enhanced microorganism dispersal but also amplified stochasticity. The Neutral Community Model (NCM) revealed that random processes played a larger role in these shallower depths, potentially jeopardizing the stable biotic interactions found in undisturbed soil.

Neutral Community Model (NCM) fit statistics showing higher stochasticity (m) and better fit (R²) in shallower depths for prokaryotes.

Fertility Source and Depth Sensitivity

The type of fertility source (organic vs. synthetic) was the most pronounced driver of microbial assembly, especially for fungal communities. While the influence of tillage and cover crops was largely confined to the 0–20 cm range, the signal from fertility sources remained detectable down to 60 cm. Organic fertility sources fostered sensitive modules dominated by fungi, suggesting a more integrated microbial network compared to synthetic treatments.

The Dominance of Biotic Interactions

A pivotal finding of the machine learning analysis was that "biotic factors"—the presence and abundance of other microbes—were much stronger predictors of a specific microbe's abundance than "abiotic factors" like soil pH, carbon, or nitrogen. This suggests that microbial "social networks" are the primary stabilizers of community structure.

Performance of RF models highlighting that biotic factors are superior predictors of microbial abundance compared to abiotic factors across depths.

Conclusions

Agricultural management practices impact soil microbiomes through a complex interplay of assembly processes, interactions, and the recruitment of specific taxa. Tillage acts as a randomizing force in topsoil, while fertility sources shape long-term community architecture across the soil profile. By leveraging machine learning, this research demonstrates that microbial interactions are more predictive of community composition than environmental variables alone, offering a new lens through which to optimize soil health for sustainable agriculture.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold>Soil microbiomes are critical to soil health and sustainable agriculture. Microbiome structures differ across agricultural soils that experience different management practices, such as tillage, fertilizers, and cover crops. Environmental factors, including those related to soil management, and microbiome-interactions alter these microbial communities. However, the full extent of these influences and relationships is not comprehensively understood. Here, we applied machine learning-based methods to identify prokaryotic and fungal assembly and distribution across various soil depths from fields under different agricultural practices.<bold>Results:</bold>Fertility source was the most pronounced agricultural factor for microbial assembly, especially for fungal communities, and this impact lessened as soil depth increased. Furthermore, fertility source shaped co-occurrence patterns within the microbial community, leading to fertility source-sensitive modules dominated by fungi down to 30 cm soil depth. Tillage predominantly affected microbial communities in soil depths of 0-20 cm, and not only enhanced microorganism dispersal but also amplified stochastic processes, especially in the prokaryotic community. However, tillage potentially jeopardized interactions within the microbiome. In contrast to the fertility source and tillage, cover crops had a less pronounced effect on microbial communities, with no clear depth-dependent patterns; however, they still affect microbial co-occurrence patterns to some extent. Additionally, microorganisms at varying depths, specifically 0-20 cm for tillage and cover crops and 0-60 cm for fertility sources, were indicative of different agricultural practices.<bold>Conclusions:</bold>Our result showed that the impact of agricultural practices on microbial communities is multifaceted, including the assembly process, interactions, and recruitment of specific microorganisms. We also demonstrated that machine learning models can overcome certain limitations of traditional methods, offering enhanced insights into the mechanisms underlying microbial assembly and distribution in agriculture soils.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mo2024agricultural,
  author = {Yujie Mo and Raven L. Bier and Xiaolin Li and Melinda D. Daniels and Andrew Smith and Lei Yu and Jinjun Kan},
  title = {{Agricultural practices influence soil microbiome assembly and interactions at different depths identified by machine learning}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3959167/v1},
}
Figure