Agreement between anterior segment Optical Coherence Tomography, Lenstar and Ultrasound Biomicroscopy measurements of anterior segment parameters

Ziyan Yu, Ting Huang, Yu Qiao, Jun Kong, Bo QuResearch Square 2019 · DOI

Introduction

In clinical ophthalmology, precise measurements of the eye's anterior segment are vital for successful outcomes. Specifically, Central Corneal Thickness (CCT) and Anterior Chamber Depth (ACD) are critical parameters for calculating intraocular lens (IOL) power in cataract surgery and for screening and managing glaucoma. While Ultrasound Biomicroscopy (UBM) has long been a standard tool, newer non-contact optical methods like Anterior Segment Optical Coherence Tomography (AS-OCT) and Lenstar have become increasingly popular due to their speed and patient comfort. This study evaluates the agreement and interchangeability of these three distinct technologies.

Methods

Researchers at the 4th Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University conducted a retrospective cross-sectional study involving 83 eyes from 54 patients (mean age ~59 years). The study compared three devices:

  1. AS-OCT (CASIA SS-1000): A swept-source OCT providing high-resolution 3D cross-sections.
  2. Lenstar (LS 900): An optical biometer utilizing laser interferometry.
  3. UBM (MD-300L): A high-frequency ultrasound device requiring a coupling medium and physical contact.

All measurements were taken by a single operator with five-minute intervals between tests to ensure consistency. Statistical analysis included Pearson correlation to assess relationship strength and Bland-Altman analysis to determine clinical agreement limits.

Key Results

The study found exceptionally high correlations between all three devices for both ACD and CCT measurements (all $r > 0.92, P < 0.001$).

Anterior Chamber Depth (ACD)

The mean ACD measurements were:

  • AS-OCT: 2.30 mm
  • UBM: 2.25 mm
  • Lenstar: 2.22 mm

While there was no significant difference between Lenstar and UBM, AS-OCT tended to yield slightly higher values.

Central Corneal Thickness (CCT)

The mean CCT measurements were:

  • UBM: 542.89 µm
  • Lenstar: 539.55 µm
  • AS-OCT: 534.15 µm

Significant statistical differences were noted between the three devices for CCT, with UBM providing the thickest measurements and AS-OCT the thinnest.

Discussion: Understanding the Differences

Despite the high correlation, the subtle differences in measurements can be attributed to the underlying physics and procedural requirements of each device.

  • The Gravity Factor: UBM measurements of ACD are typically shorter because the patient is in a supine position. Gravity causes the lens-iris diaphragm to shift forward, shallowing the chamber compared to the upright positioning used for AS-OCT and Lenstar.
  • The Tear Film Variable: Optical methods (AS-OCT and Lenstar) are sensitive to the tear film. AS-OCT allows for manual software adjustments to exclude the tear film, potentially offering a more accurate measurement of the corneal tissue itself.
  • Physics vs. Physiology: The higher CCT values observed with UBM may stem from the liquid coupling medium, which can slightly "thicken" the perceived tear film layer during manual measurement boundary selection.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that AS-OCT, Lenstar, and UBM provide highly consistent and clinically compatible measurements. Bland-Altman plots confirmed that over 95% of data points fell within the limits of agreement. While minor statistical variations exist due to patient positioning and measurement physics, these three "gold standard" tools can be used interchangeably for most diagnostic and surgical planning purposes in a clinical setting.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Purpose To compare anterior chamber depth (ACD) and central corneal thickness (CCT) measurements by anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT), Lenstar and ultrasound biomicroscopy (UBM). Methods A retrospective cross section study. A total of 83 eyes from 54 patients were included. Central corneal thickness (CCT) and anterior chamber depth (ACD) values obtained from three devices (AS-OCT, Lenstar and UBM) were recorded. All patients were collected from Oct. 2015 to Aug. 2016 in the Fourth Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University. Differences of these three devices (ACD and CCT) were statistically analyzed by randomized blocks analysis. Pearson correlative analysis and Bland-Altman analysis were used to compare the correlation and agreement. Results There’s no significant difference in measuring ACD by Lenstar and UBM (P&gt;0.05), but there were significant differences in other two groups (AS-OCT and UBM, AS-OCT and Lenstar) (P&lt;0.05). There were significant differences in the mean CCT measured by the three devices (P&lt;0.05). There were high correlation in measuring ACD (all P&lt;0.001, r1=0.928,r2=0.982,r3=0.932, respectively), and CCT(all P&lt;0.001,r1=0.957,r2=0.949,r3=0.928, respectively). Conclusion AS-OCT, Lenstar and UBM yielded comparable results and are all can be used interchangeably for anterior segment measurements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2019agreement,
  author = {Ziyan Yu and Ting Huang and Yu Qiao and Jun Kong and Bo Qu},
  title = {{Agreement between anterior segment Optical Coherence Tomography, Lenstar and Ultrasound Biomicroscopy measurements of anterior segment parameters}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.427/v1},
}
Figure