Agreement and correlation of abdominal skeletal muscle area measured by CT and MR imaging in cirrhotic patients

Zhengyu Xu, Jia Luo, Dawei Yang, Hui Xu, Jidong Jia, Zhenghan YangBMC Medical Imaging 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the agreement and correlation of abdominal skeletal muscle area (SMA) measurements between CT and MRI in cirrhotic patients. The findings demonstrate that MRI, specifically using water-fat imaging, offers a highly consistent and accurate alternative to CT for assessing muscle mass in this patient population, which is crucial for diagnosing sarcopenia and predicting prognosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sarcopenia, a gradual loss of muscle mass, is a significant complication in cirrhotic patients, affecting 40-70% of them. It's linked to increased risks of infections, hepatic encephalopathy, and poorer survival. Accurately diagnosing sarcopenia is critical for guiding treatment and improving outcomes. Currently, CT-based measurement of skeletal muscle area (SMA) at the L3 vertebral level is the standard for assessing muscle mass in cirrhotic patients, as recommended by guidelines. However, cirrhotic patients often require frequent follow-ups, raising concerns about cumulative radiation exposure from repeated CT scans. While MRI is a non-radiation imaging technique with excellent soft-tissue contrast, its utility for SMA measurement in cirrhotic patients, particularly using modern sequences, has not been extensively studied. This paper aims to bridge this gap by evaluating the agreement and correlation between CT and MRI-based SMA measurements in cirrhotic patients, exploring whether MRI can serve as a reliable alternative to CT.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective study involving 38 cirrhotic patients who underwent both abdominal CT and MRI scans within a short timeframe. Skeletal muscle area (SMA) was measured at the mid-third lumbar vertebral (L3) level. For CT imaging, muscle and adipose tissue were distinguished based on Hounsfield unit differences. For MRI, they utilized water-fat imaging sequences (T1w in-phase, T1w out-of-phase, T1w water, and T1w fat) and employed semi-automatic segmentation techniques ("Region-Growing" and "Morpho"). A single radiologist with over 10 years of experience performed all measurements twice, with an interval of at least one month between assessments to minimize bias.

To evaluate the agreement and correlation, they used:

  • Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC): To assess intraobserver agreement (consistency of measurements by the same observer).
  • Pearson Correlation Coefficient: To quantify the linear relationship between CT and MRI measurements.
  • Bland-Altman Plots: To visually assess the agreement between the two imaging modalities by plotting the difference between measurements against their average.

These analyses were performed for all patients and further stratified by sarcopenia severity and Child-Pugh grades to investigate potential differences.

Datasets

The study utilized imaging data from 38 cirrhotic patients. These patients underwent both CT and MRI examinations as part of their diagnostic workup. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses existing patient imaging data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MRI as a Viable Alternative: The study strongly suggests that MRI, particularly water-fat imaging sequences, can reliably measure SMA in cirrhotic patients, offering a radiation-free alternative to CT.
  • High Agreement Across Modalities: The core finding is the excellent agreement and correlation between CT and MRI measurements of SMA, indicating that MRI can be used interchangeably with CT for this purpose.
  • Water-Fat Imaging's Superiority: Among the MRI sequences tested, T1w water images showed the strongest correlation and the minimum bias when compared to CT, highlighting its effectiveness for SMA assessment.
  • Consistency Across Disease Severity: The agreement between CT and MRI holds true across different stages of sarcopenia and Child-Pugh grades, meaning MRI can be used regardless of the patient's disease severity or liver function status.
  • Sarcopenia Drivers: The discussion points to malnutrition as a primary driver of sarcopenia in cirrhotic patients, rather than liver function itself, which may explain why SMA doesn't consistently decrease with worsening Child-Pugh scores.

Key Results

  • Intraobserver Agreement: Both CT and MRI showed very high intraobserver agreement, with ICC values ranging from 0.991 to 0.996.
  • CT vs. MRI Correlation: CT and MRI measurements of SMA were highly correlated (r=0.991–0.998, P<0.01).
  • Best MRI Sequence: T1w water images demonstrated the strongest correlation (r=0.998, P<0.01) and the minimum bias (0.68%) compared to CT.
  • Bias: The bias between CT and MRI measurements ranged from 0.68% to 3.02%.
  • Sarcopenia and Child-Pugh Grades: The agreement and correlation between CT and MRI remained high across different sarcopenia severity subgroups and Child-Pugh grades, with Pearson correlation coefficients generally above 0.990 and biases within acceptable ranges.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study included 38 patients, which they note is relatively small, partly due to the requirement for patients to undergo both CT and MRI scans within a short period.
  • Multiple MRI Scanners: MR images were acquired on different machines, although primary imaging parameters were kept consistent.
  • Single Observer: All measurements were performed by a single, experienced observer. While they cite previous research suggesting good interobserver agreement, this remains a potential area for further investigation.
  • Limited MRI Sequences: The study focused on water-fat imaging sequences. Future research could explore other MRI sequences for SMA assessment.

Future work could involve larger, multi-center studies to confirm these findings and explore the clinical utility of MRI-based SMA measurements in guiding treatment decisions and predicting outcomes in cirrhotic patients. Investigating interobserver agreement for MRI-based SMA measurements would also be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{xu2022agreement,
  author = {Zhengyu Xu and Jia Luo and Dawei Yang and Hui Xu and Jidong Jia and Zhenghan Yang},
  title = {{Agreement and correlation of abdominal skeletal muscle area measured by CT and MR imaging in cirrhotic patients}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Imaging},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s12880-022-00932-0},
}
Figure