AGN Disks Harden the Mass Distribution of Stellar-mass Binary Black Hole Mergers

Yi Yang, I. Bartos, Zoltán Haiman, Bence Kocsis, Z. Márka, Nicholas C. Stone, Szabolcs MárkaThe Astrophysical Journal 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) accretion disks can significantly alter the mass distribution of merging binary black holes (BBHs), preferentially selecting heavier black holes. This "hardening" of the mass spectrum by AGN disks could explain a substantial fraction of observed BBH mergers and offers a new way to distinguish formation channels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing detection rate of stellar-mass binary black hole (BBH) mergers by gravitational-wave observatories like LIGO and Virgo is providing unprecedented insights into their origins. However, accurately modeling the various astrophysical environments where these binaries form is crucial for interpreting these observations and identifying distinct populations. One proposed formation channel is the merging of BBHs within the accretion disks of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs). This paper investigates how the unique environment of an AGN disk influences the properties of merging BBHs, specifically focusing on their mass distribution.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of analytical modeling and Monte Carlo simulations. They first develop a framework to calculate the orbital alignment timescale of stellar-mass black holes (BHs) within an AGN accretion disk, considering factors like the BH's orbital parameters, the AGN disk properties (viscosity, temperature, density), and the central supermassive black hole (SMBH) mass and accretion rate. This model accounts for gas damping that forces inclined orbits to align with the disk.

Subsequently, they use Monte Carlo simulations to model the process:

  1. Orbital Alignment: Singleton BHs in the galactic nucleus are assumed to align their orbits with the AGN disk due to gas damping.
  2. Binary Formation: Aligned BHs are assumed to form binaries within "migration traps" in the disk.
  3. Merger: These binaries then merge rapidly due to gas torques.

The simulations explore various initial black hole mass functions (characterized by a power-law index $\beta$), SMBH masses ($M_*$), and AGN accretion rates ($\dot{m}_*$). They specifically investigate how the mass distribution of merging BBHs differs from the initial distribution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and simulations rather than observational datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AGN Disks as "Mass Filters": The core insight is that the orbital dynamics within AGN disks act as a selective process. Heavier BHs are more efficiently captured and aligned with the disk, leading to a preference for more massive BBH mergers.
  • Hardened Mass Spectrum: This selection process "hardens" the initial black hole mass function, meaning the distribution shifts towards higher masses. The power-law index of the merging BBH mass distribution becomes steeper (more top-heavy) compared to the initial distribution.
  • Independence from Specific AGN Parameters: Remarkably, the degree to which the mass function is hardened ($\Delta \beta \approx -1.3$) appears to be largely independent of the specific SMBH mass and accretion rate within the simulated ranges. This suggests a universal effect of the AGN disk environment.
  • Significant Contribution to Detections: The AGN channel, with its hardened mass spectrum, is predicted to contribute a significant fraction (10-50%) of observed BBH mergers, even if its overall merger rate is comparable to other channels. This is because the "harder" spectrum means a larger proportion of these mergers will fall within the detectable mass range.
  • Potential for Electromagnetic Counterparts: While not the primary focus, the paper briefly touches upon the possibility of electromagnetic emission from BBH mergers in AGNs due to mini-accretion disks, which could be a valuable tool for identifying these events.

Key Results

  • Mass Function Hardening: The power-law index of the merging BBH mass distribution shifts by $\Delta \beta \approx -1.3$ compared to the initial mass function.
  • Predicted Merger Rate: The authors estimate an AGN-assisted BBH merger rate of approximately $4 \text{ Gpc}^{-3} \text{yr}^{-1}$.
  • Contribution to Detections: This rate, combined with the hardened mass spectrum, suggests that AGN-assisted mergers could account for 10-50% of gravitational-wave detections.
  • Mass Ratio Distribution: The mass ratio distribution of merging BBHs in AGNs is found to be largely independent of the initial mass function index and SMBH mass, showing a peak around $q \approx 0.2$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications in Binary Formation: The paper assumes that binaries form from random pairings of captured BHs within the disk. In reality, the spatial distribution of BHs (heavier ones closer to the SMBH) might lead to a preference for merging BHs with similar masses, resulting in mass ratios closer to 1.
  • Inhomogeneous Disks: The authors acknowledge that AGN disks can be clumpy and inhomogeneous, which might affect orbital alignment timescales and broaden their distribution. They conservatively assume no interaction in these regions.
  • BHs Already in Binaries: The study primarily focuses on singleton BHs aligning with the disk. Future work should consider scenarios where BHs are already in binaries before entering the AGN disk.
  • Repeated Mergers: The effect of repeated mergers within migration traps, which could further harden the mass spectrum, is mentioned as a potential area for future investigation.
  • Electromagnetic Signatures: Further exploration of how AGN-assisted mergers can be differentiated from other dynamical formation channels, potentially through electromagnetic counterparts or localization, is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The growing number of stellar-mass binary black hole mergers discovered by Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo are starting to constrain the binaries’ origin and environment. However, we still lack sufficiently accurate modeling of binary formation channels to obtain strong constraints, or to identify subpopulations. One promising formation mechanism that could result in different black hole properties is binaries merging within the accretion disks of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Here we show that the black holes’ orbital alignment with the AGN disks preferentially selects heavier black holes. We carry out Monte Carlo simulations of orbital alignment with AGN disks, and find that AGNs harden the initial black hole mass function. Assuming an initial power-law mass distribution , we find that the power-law index changes by Δ β ∼ 1.3, resulting in a more top-heavy population of merging black holes. This change is independent of the mass of, and accretion rate onto, the supermassive black hole in the center of the AGN. Our simulations predict an AGN-assisted merger rate of ∼4 Gpc −3 yr −1 . With its hardened mass spectra, the AGN channel could be responsible for 10%–50% of gravitational-wave detections.
BibTeX
@article{yang2019agn,
  author = {Yi Yang and I. Bartos and Zoltán Haiman and Bence Kocsis and Z. Márka and Nicholas C. Stone and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{AGN Disks Harden the Mass Distribution of Stellar-mass Binary Black Hole Mergers}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ab16e3},
}
Figure