Aggregation of demand side flexibility in a smart grid: A review for European market design

Cherrelle Eid, Paul Codani, Yurong Chen, Yannick Pérez, Rudi A. Hakvoort2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews the role of aggregators in enabling demand-side flexibility in European smart grids, highlighting their crucial function in activating smaller consumers for demand response. It identifies key barriers to aggregator emergence in Europe, primarily regulatory and market design issues, and proposes policy recommendations to foster their development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing penetration of renewable energy sources and distributed generation (DG) in European electricity grids necessitates greater system flexibility to maintain stability. Demand Response (DR) is a key strategy to achieve this, but its full potential, especially from smaller residential and commercial customers, remains untapped. These smaller users often lack the individual capacity or technical means to participate directly in electricity markets. The paper addresses the challenge of activating this latent flexibility by examining the role of "aggregators" – market intermediaries that bundle these small, distributed resources into a tradable commodity. The core problem is that despite their technical and economic utility, aggregators are not widely established across Europe, and this paper seeks to understand why and propose solutions.

Methods

The paper employs a review and analysis methodology. It synthesizes existing literature on demand response, aggregators, and electricity market design. The authors define the core functions of an aggregator, drawing parallels to intermediary roles in other sectors. They then analyze the technical characteristics of flexibility resources and the needs of Transmission System Operators (TSOs). Finally, the paper presents case studies of existing aggregators in Europe and the US to illustrate different models and identify practical challenges. Based on this analysis, the authors derive policy recommendations for European market design.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review and analysis of existing literature and case studies, rather than an empirical study with specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aggregators as Essential Enablers: The paper strongly emphasizes that aggregators are not just beneficial but essential for unlocking the demand-side flexibility of small consumers. Without them, these resources remain largely inaccessible to the market.
  • Four Core Functions of Aggregators: The authors clearly delineate the four key functions of an aggregator: information management, bundling of services, matching and market clearing, and transaction guarantee. This provides a structured understanding of their operational role.
  • Technical Characterization of Flexibility: Understanding flexibility as a multidimensional product (direction, capacity/energy, availability, activation time, location) is crucial for effective aggregation and market participation.
  • European Market Design is a Major Barrier: The primary obstacle to aggregator growth in Europe is not technical, but rather regulatory and market design-related. Existing rules often have high minimum bidding volumes, strict duration requirements, and significant penalties, which disproportionately affect smaller, aggregated resources.
  • Lack of Smart Metering Hinders Performance Guarantees: The inability to reliably measure and verify actual demand response provision (due to a lack of widespread smart metering) is a significant barrier to the "transaction guarantee" function of aggregators and thus to profitable operation.
  • Need for Decentralized Markets: The paper anticipates a future where DSOs and TSOs will require more decentralized demand response, necessitating the development of new, local markets that can accommodate these smaller, geographically specific flexibility offers.

Key Results

The paper identifies that while aggregators exist and operate in some European countries (France, Belgium, Switzerland, Great Britain, Finland, Ireland), their presence is limited in many others due to regulatory barriers. The case studies highlight diverse aggregator models, from those focusing on large industrial users (Energy Pool) to those targeting residential customers (Voltalis) and even EV aggregation (Delaware EV pilot). The key "result" is the identification of specific barriers:

  • Lack of Smart Metering: Only Sweden and Italy have near 100% smart meter roll-out, leaving many customers with traditional meters, which impedes real-time data for aggregation.
  • Unadapted Market Design: Minimum bidding volumes, bid duration requirements, and penalties for non-supplied services in current European markets are not conducive to aggregated demand response.
  • Harmonization Gaps: The lack of harmonized market rules across European countries further complicates cross-border aggregation efforts.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Focus on European Context: While mentioning a US case study, the primary focus is on European market design, potentially limiting broader applicability.
  • Limited Quantitative Results: As a review paper, it doesn't present new empirical data or quantitative performance metrics for aggregators.
  • "Self-Emerging" Assumption: The paper assumes aggregators should "self-emerge," whereas policy intervention might be needed to actively foster their creation.

Future Work:

  • Development of Local Markets: The paper strongly suggests the need for new local markets to facilitate decentralized demand response and aggregation, particularly for local congestion management and DG optimization.
  • Policy Recommendations: The authors advocate for policy makers to create a more favorable environment by adapting market rules, potentially including lower bidding thresholds, flexible duration requirements, and clear performance criteria for DR.
  • Cross-Border Harmonization: Addressing the lack of harmonized market rules across Europe is crucial for enabling cross-border aggregation and a more integrated European energy market.
  • Exploring Hybrid Models: While not the paper's focus, the potential for aggregators to also act as electricity service suppliers (retailers) is mentioned as a possibility to avoid conflicts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The increased share of renewable generation and the integration of Distributed Generation (DG) require more electricity system flexibility. One way to increase this flexibility is to use the potentials of demand response (DR). In order to activate the full range of customers in DR, a new market intermediary actor is needed to aggregate the resources in an adequate technical and economical format. These actors, so called “aggregators”, can act as flexibility providers to support security of supply considering network, generation and consumers constraints. However, despite their technical and economical utility, aggregators are not self-emerging in many European countries. Consequently, this paper aims at identifying the main barriers accounting for this lack of aggregators in Europe. Eventually this paper provides a policy review for European market designs that support aggregation.
BibTeX
@misc{eid2015aggregation,
  author = {Cherrelle Eid and Paul Codani and Yurong Chen and Yannick Pérez and Rudi A. Hakvoort},
  title = {{Aggregation of demand side flexibility in a smart grid: A review for European market design}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1109/eem.2015.7216712},
}
Figure