Agent-based modeling of a price information trading business

Saad Ahmad Khan, Ladislau BölöniISCIS 2011 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces an agent-based simulation of a "Gas Price Information Trader" (GPIT) business that buys real-time gas price data from drivers and resells it to other drivers. The research explores the economic viability and market dynamics of such a business, demonstrating that a dynamic negotiation strategy can lead to profitable outcomes for both the information trader and its customers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of creating sustainable information trading businesses in markets where there isn't a strong emotional or political motivation for voluntary participation, leading to potential "free-riding." Specifically, it focuses on the gas price information market, where existing solutions like online price trackers often rely on ad revenue or government initiatives. The authors propose an agent-based model to simulate a business that incentivizes participation through direct financial benefit for all parties involved – drivers selling information, drivers buying information, and the information trader itself. The core problem is to understand if and how such a business can be economically viable and what market dynamics emerge from agent interactions.

Methods

The authors developed an agent-based simulation incorporating several key components:

  • Agent-Based Modeling: Drivers are modeled as autonomous agents with realistic geographic data, lifestyle-dependent driving patterns, and vehicle models. The GPIT is also an agent.
  • Economic Model: The system is designed such that all participants (trader and drivers) must profit financially for the business to be stable. Profits are derived from the price differences in gas stations, which customers can exploit with the GPIT's information.
  • Negotiation Protocol: A dynamic, case-by-case negotiation process is used to determine the price of information. Both the GPIT and the drivers adapt their negotiation strategies based on historical profits.
  • Adaptive Negotiation Strategies:
    • Customer Strategy: Uses a monotonic, uniform concession with a reservation price, adapting its initial offer based on past negotiations.
  • Trader Strategy (GPIT): Employs a reservation price-based monotonic concession model with an adaptive learning process using exponential smoothing to weigh recent deals. It also uses a Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) indicator to model and adapt to customer concession behavior.
  • Environment Modeling: The simulation uses real-world geographic data for East Orlando, including major employers, residential and shopping areas, and gas station locations. Driving directions and trip times are sourced from Google Maps. Gas prices are modeled based on real-world data from GasBuddy.com, with simulated temporal and spatial variations.
  • Scenario Generation: A baseline scenario of daily driving patterns is created, and "needs" events (requiring refueling) are generated dynamically.

Datasets

  • Geographic Data: Real-world geographic data for East Orlando, including locations of employers, residential areas, shopping areas, and gas stations, sourced from Google Maps.
  • Driving Data: Driving directions and trip times acquired from Google Maps.
  • Gas Price Data: Real-world gas price data from GasBuddy.com for the year 2009-2010.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Financial Self-Interest as a Motivator: The research strongly suggests that financial self-interest, rather than altruism, can be a powerful driver for participation in information markets, even for seemingly mundane information like gas prices.
  • Dynamic Negotiation is Crucial: A fixed pricing strategy is shown to be less effective than a dynamic, case-by-case negotiation. The ability of agents to adapt their offers based on past interactions is key to finding mutually beneficial prices.
  • The "Rachet Effect" in Pricing: Even with a fixed price, some customers are willing to pay for information, but this doesn't necessarily lead to high profits for the trader, highlighting the importance of dynamic pricing.
  • Promotional Offers as a Catalyst: Promotional offers (free information) are effective in establishing the initial negotiation history needed for customers to experience savings and thus become willing to pay for future information.
  • MACD for Adaptive Concession: The use of MACD to model customer concession behavior and adapt the GPIT's concession rate is an innovative approach to dynamic negotiation.

Key Results

  • Viable Economic Model: The proposed agent-based simulation demonstrates that the information trading business model is viable, with the potential to generate profits for both the GPIT and its customers.
  • Optimal Pricing Range: The study indicates a stable price/profit curve with a maximum profit for the trader occurring at an information price of approximately $3.
  • Price Elasticity: The "price elasticity analysis" (Figure 6) shows that demand for information is high when it's free (promotional offer) and decreases as the cost increases. However, the highest success ratio for negotiations is achieved at prices around the dynamically determined optimal value.
  • Dynamic Pricing Superiority: Profits obtained using dynamic pricing are significantly higher and more sustainable compared to fixed pricing strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Geographic Scope: The simulation is focused on East Orlando, a specific metropolitan area. The generalizability of findings to other urban environments with different driving patterns, gas station distributions, and price volatilities may vary.
  • Simplistic Customer Behavior: While adaptive, the customer negotiation strategy is described as monotonic and uniform. More complex behaviors, such as irrationality or varying levels of risk aversion, could be explored.
  • Privacy Concerns: The paper mentions the cost of privacy for drivers selling information but doesn't deeply explore the implications or potential solutions for privacy concerns, which could be a barrier to adoption.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more complex negotiation strategies, incorporating more sophisticated models of customer behavior, and investigating the impact of privacy concerns on the system's viability. Further research could also focus on scaling the model to larger, more diverse urban environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe an agent-based simulation of a fictional (but feasible) information trading business. The Gas Price Information Trader (GPIT) buys information about real-time gas prices in a metropolitan area from drivers and resells the information to drivers who need to refuel their vehicles. Our simulation uses real world geographic data, lifestyle-dependent driving patterns and vehicle models to create an agent-based model of the drivers. We use real world statistics of gas price fluctuation to create scenarios of temporal and spatial distribution of gas prices. The price of the information is determined on a case-by-case basis through a simple negotiation model. The trader and the customers are adapting their negotiation strategies based on their historical profits. We are interested in the general properties of the emerging information market: the amount of realizable profit and its distribution between the trader and customers, the business strategies necessary to keep the market operational (such as promotional deals), the price elasticity of demand and the impact of pricing strategies on the profit.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khan2011agent,
  author = {Saad Ahmad Khan and Ladislau Bölöni},
  title = {{Agent-based modeling of a price information trading business}},
  booktitle = {ISCIS},
  year = {2011},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=PeCsM6eou1},
}
Figure