Age-Related Changes in European Portuguese Vowel Acoustics

Luciana Albuquerque, Catarina Oliveira, António Teixeira, Pedro Sa-Couto, Daniela FigueiredoInterspeech 2019

TL;DR

This study investigates how vowel acoustics change with age and gender in European Portuguese speakers. It reveals that while vowel duration consistently increases with age, fundamental frequency (F0) shows complex age- and gender-dependent patterns. Notably, formant frequencies (F1, F2) and vowel space area (VSA) do not systematically decrease with age, challenging some prior assumptions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The aging process affects human speech production, leading to changes in acoustic properties. However, research on age-related changes in vowel acoustics has yielded conflicting findings, particularly concerning fundamental frequency (F0) and formant frequencies (F1, F2). This ambiguity makes it difficult to establish normative patterns for aging speech, which is crucial for clinical assessments, speech technology development, and understanding human communication across the lifespan. This paper aims to address this by providing a comprehensive analysis of vowel acoustics in European Portuguese (EP) speakers across a wide age range (35-97 years), considering both gender and specific vowel characteristics.

Methods

The researchers collected speech samples from 113 native European Portuguese speakers, divided into four age groups and balanced for gender. They analyzed the acoustic properties of 9 oral vowels produced in disyllabic words embedded in carrier sentences. Key acoustic parameters measured included:

  • Fundamental Frequency (F0): Estimated using the cross-correlation algorithm, with median values taken from the central 40% of each vowel to minimize consonant influence.
  • Formant Frequencies (F1, F2): Determined using the Burg-LPC algorithm at the central 40% of the vowel, with an optimization procedure to find the best formant ceiling for each speaker and vowel.
  • Vowel Duration: Measured from the beginning to the end of each vowel.
  • Vowel Space Area (VSA): Calculated as the polygon area based on the mean values of F1 and F2 for each oral vowel, serving as an indicator of articulatory capability.

Statistical analysis involved three-way mixed ANOVAs for duration, F0, F1, and F2, with vowel as a within-subject factor and gender and age as between-subject factors. A two-way ANOVA was used for VSA. Outliers exceeding 2.5 standard deviations from the mean were excluded.

Datasets

The study introduced a new dataset of European Portuguese oral vowels produced by 113 adult speakers across four age groups. This dataset was collected using standardized recording procedures and manually segmented for accuracy. It serves as a benchmark for EP vowel acoustics in aging speakers, differing from previous studies by its broad age range and comprehensive acoustic analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vowel Duration is a Reliable Indicator of Age: Unlike other acoustic parameters, vowel duration consistently and significantly increases with age in both genders. This aligns with the general understanding of speech slowing down in older adults.
  • F0 Patterns are Complex and Gender-Differentiated: F0 does not simply decrease with age. While women's F0 tends to decrease after middle age, men's F0 shows a decrease until middle age, followed by an increase in older age, suggesting a convergence of F0 between genders with increasing age.
  • Formant Frequencies Remain Relatively Stable: Contrary to some previous research, this study found no systematic decrease in F1 and F2 frequencies with age. This suggests that the vocal tract's resonant frequencies may be more resilient to aging than previously thought, or that articulatory adjustments compensate for potential changes.
  • Vowel Space Area (VSA) Shows No Significant Age Effect: The VSA, often used as a proxy for articulatory precision, did not show a significant decline with age. While there was a trend towards a slight decrease, particularly in men, this was not statistically significant, challenging the hypothesis that older speakers have a reduced articulatory capability.
  • Gender Differences Persist Across Age: Acoustic parameters like F0, F1, and F2 consistently show gender-dependent patterns, with women generally exhibiting higher F0 and formant values than men, regardless of age.

Key Results

  • Vowel Duration: Increased significantly with age (F(3;103)=7.4; p<0.001). The older age group (≥ 80) had the longest vowel duration. No significant gender difference in average vowel duration was found.
  • Fundamental Frequency (F0): Women had significantly higher F0 (192.0 Hz) than men (139.3 Hz) (F(1;103)=106.5; p<0.001). A significant age by gender interaction was observed (F(3;103)=3.2; p=0.028), reflecting different age trajectories for F0 in men and women.
  • Formant Frequencies (F1, F2): Women presented higher F1 and F2 than men (main effect of gender: F(1;103)=82.8; p<0.001 for F1, F(1;101)=426.2; p<0.001 for F2). No significant age differences were found for F1 (F(3;103)=0.8; p=0.482) or F2 (F(3;101)=0.4; p=0.774).
  • Vowel Space Area (VSA): Women had significantly larger VSA than men (F(1;101)=1409.9; p<0.001). No statistical effect of age on VSA was found (F(3;101)=1.1; p=0.339).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their study provides a comprehensive dataset, it is cross-sectional. Future work should involve a longitudinal study to track changes within individuals over time. They also suggest exploring the relationship between vowel acoustics and articulatory adjustments using advanced instrumental techniques like ultrasonography and magnetic resonance imaging. Additionally, a broader life span study, including younger speakers, is proposed to provide a more complete picture of vowel aging.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{albuquerque2019age,
  author = {Luciana Albuquerque and Catarina Oliveira and António Teixeira and Pedro Sa-Couto and Daniela Figueiredo},
  title = {{Age-Related Changes in European Portuguese Vowel Acoustics}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure