Age-dependent differences in the neutralization of the intervocalic voicing contrast: evidence from an apparent-time study on east franconian

Viola Müller, Jonathan Harrington, Felicitas Kleber, Ulrich ReuboldInterspeech 2011

TL;DR

This study investigates how East Franconian German speakers of different ages neutralize the voicing contrast between intervocalic stops (/d/ vs. /t/). They found that older speakers neutralize this contrast more than younger speakers, suggesting a sound change in progress where the contrast is being re-established, likely influenced by Standard German.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many German dialects, the distinction between voiced (/d/) and voiceless (/t/) stops in intervocalic positions (like in "leiden" vs. "leiten") has been neutralized, often shifting towards a "lenis" (softer) pronunciation. This means that words that were once distinct might sound the same. However, Standard German maintains this contrast, albeit with subtle acoustic cues beyond just voicing. This paper asks whether this neutralization is complete in East Franconian, a specific German dialect, and crucially, whether this process is influenced by age, suggesting a potential sound change driven by exposure to Standard German. They hypothesize that younger speakers, being more exposed to Standard German, might show less neutralization and thus better preservation of the voicing contrast compared to older speakers.

Methods

The researchers employed an "apparent-time study," which uses speakers of different ages to infer changes over time. They combined two main methods:

  • Acoustic Analysis: They analyzed recordings of East Franconian speakers producing minimal pairs like "leiden" (/laɪdən/, to suffer) and "leiten" (/laɪtən/, to direct). They focused on the vowel-to-stop duration ratio (V/(V+C)), a known acoustic cue for distinguishing intervocalic voiced and voiceless stops. A higher ratio indicates a longer vowel relative to the stop, often associated with voiced stops. They analyzed these words both in isolation and embedded in short stories to see if context affected the contrast.
  • Forced-Choice Perception Experiment: They created a synthetic auditory continuum of sounds ranging from "leiden" to "leiten" by manipulating the V/(V+C) ratio. Participants were asked to identify each sound as either "leiden" or "leiten." This allowed them to assess how listeners perceive the contrast and whether they perceive a clear boundary between the two sounds.

Datasets

The study used recordings from:

  • 32 East Franconian speakers: Divided into two age groups: 16 young speakers (15-25 years) and 16 older speakers (51-74 years).
  • 5 Standard German speakers: Used as a reference group for comparison.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; existing recordings were analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sound Change in Progress: The most significant finding is that the intervocalic voicing contrast is not fully neutralized in East Franconian, and there's evidence of a sound change actively re-establishing this contrast, particularly in younger speakers.
  • Age Matters: Older East Franconian speakers neutralize the contrast more significantly than younger speakers. This suggests that the younger generation is preserving or re-acquiring the contrast, likely due to the influence of Standard German.
  • Production vs. Perception Mismatch (in Older Speakers): While older speakers showed some acoustic evidence of contrast in isolated word production, their perception experiment indicated they did not distinguish between the sounds as clearly as younger speakers. This suggests that the re-establishment of the contrast might be happening at different rates in production and perception.
  • Standard German as an Influence: The comparison with Standard German speakers, who maintained the contrast acoustically, supports the idea that exposure to the standard variety is driving this change in East Franconian.

Key Results

  • Production:
    • Older East Franconian speakers neutralized the voicing contrast to a greater extent than younger speakers.
  • Younger East Franconian speakers preserved the contrast acoustically (using V/(V+C) ratio), though to a lesser extent than Standard German speakers.
  • Older speakers showed some contrast in isolated words but not in sentences, suggesting hyperarticulation might play a role in isolated speech.
  • Perception:
    • Young East Franconian listeners showed a categorical perception of the contrast (a clear boundary between "leiden" and "leiten").
  • Older East Franconian listeners did not show a clear categorical boundary, indicating a more gradual perception or lack of distinction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Apparent-Time Limitations: While useful, apparent-time studies infer diachronic change from synchronic data. Real-time studies (tracking the same individuals over time) would provide more definitive evidence.
  • Hyperarticulation: The authors acknowledge that older speakers' contrast in isolated words might be due to hyperarticulation, a speaking style adopted when aware of being recorded.
  • Rate of Change: A key future direction is to investigate whether perception and production changes occur at the same rate. The authors are exploring this with a larger group of listeners, as the current study suggests a potential divergence in how quickly the contrast is being re-established perceptually versus productively.
  • Influence of Other Factors: While Standard German influence is suggested, further research could explore other sociolinguistic factors that might contribute to this sound change.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{muller2011age,
  author = {Viola Müller and Jonathan Harrington and Felicitas Kleber and Ulrich Reubold},
  title = {{Age-dependent differences in the neutralization of the intervocalic voicing contrast: evidence from an apparent-time study on east franconian}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure