Age constraints on the Agegraphic Dark Energy Model

Yi Zhang, Rong-Gen Cai, Hui Li, Hao Wei, Desheng WuarXiv 2007 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We investigate the age constraint on the agegraphic dark energy model by using two old galaxies (LBDS 53W091 and LBDS 53W069) and the old high redshift quasar APM 08279+5255. We find that the agegraphic dark energy model can easily accommodate LBDS 53W091 and LBDS 53W069. To accommodate APM 08279+5255, one can take the reduced Hubble parameter as large as $h=0.64$, when the fraction matter energy density $\Omega_{m0} \approx 0.22$.

Introduction

Modern cosmology faces a significant challenge in explaining the observed accelerated expansion of the universe. While the Cosmological Constant ($\Lambda$) is the standard explanation, it is plagued by theoretical fine-tuning issues. The Agegraphic Dark Energy (ADE) model offers a quantum gravity-inspired alternative, suggesting that dark energy density is inversely proportional to the square of the universe's age, rooted in the uncertainty relation of spacetime fluctuations.

A critical test for any cosmological model is the "age crisis"—the existence of Old High Redshift Objects (OHROs) that appear older than the predicted age of the universe at their observed redshifts. This paper evaluates the ADE model's ability to resolve this crisis by comparing theoretical age predictions with observational data from specific high-redshift objects.

Methodology

The authors analyze a spatially flat universe containing pressureless matter and agegraphic dark energy. By applying the Károlyházy relation to define dark energy density $\rho_q$, they derive evolution equations for the dark energy density fraction $\Omega_q$. Numerical integration of the Hubble parameter over redshift allows for the calculation of the dimensionless age of the universe ($T_z$) for various matter densities ($\Omega_{m0}$) and model parameters ($n$). These theoretical predictions are then compared against the observed ages of three specific OHROs to determine the permissible parameter space.

Observational Data

The study utilizes three primary "standard clocks" from observational astronomy:

  1. LBDS 53W091: A galaxy at redshift $z = 1.55$ with an estimated age of 3.5 Gyr.
  2. LBDS 53W069: A galaxy at redshift $z = 1.43$ with an estimated age of 4.0 Gyr.
  3. APM 08279+5255: A high-redshift quasar at $z = 3.91$. The authors adopt a conservative lower age limit of 2.0 Gyr for this object, noting that some estimates suggest ages as high as 3.0 Gyr.

Results and Analysis

The analysis reveals that while the LBDS galaxies are easily accommodated by the ADE model, the quasar APM 08279+5255 provides the most stringent constraints. For the model to remain viable, it requires specific combinations of the Hubble constant ($h$) and matter density ($\Omega_{m0}$).

Figure 2: Parameter space for $h=0.64$. The model can accommodate the quasar at $\Omega_{m0} \approx 0.22$.

As shown in Figure 2, with a reduced Hubble parameter of $h = 0.64$, the ADE model can successfully account for all three objects when $\Omega_{m0} \approx 0.22$. This performance is notable compared to standard $\Lambda$CDM models, which often struggle to fit such old objects at the observed redshifts. The "oscillation" behavior seen at low matter densities corresponds to transitions in the Equation of State ($w$) of the universe.

However, the model's feasibility is highly sensitive to the Hubble constant. When using matter density values consistent with WMAP3 data ($\Omega_{m0} \approx 0.268$), a lower Hubble constant is required to maintain compatibility with the age of the quasar.

Figure 4: Parameter space for $h=0.59$, showing compatibility with WMAP3 matter density estimates.

Figure 4 illustrates that for $h = 0.59$, the allowed parameter region expands significantly, making the model compatible with higher matter density estimates like those from WMAP3. As $h$ decreases, the universe is effectively older at a given redshift, easing the tension with OHROs.

Conclusion

The Agegraphic Dark Energy model provides a potential resolution to the age crisis, provided the Hubble constant is relatively low ($h \leq 0.64$). The primary bottleneck remains the high-redshift quasar APM 08279+5255; if its age is confirmed to be higher than the 2.0 Gyr conservative limit, the ADE model—and many other cosmological models—would face severe challenges. Future research may focus on refined ADE models, such as those employing conformal time, which could offer different evolutionary dynamics and potentially better fits for a wider range of Hubble constant values.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the age constraint on the agegraphic dark energy model by using two old galaxies (LBDS 53W091 and LBDS 53W069) and the old high redshift quasar APM 08279+5255. We find that the agegraphic dark energy model can easily accommodate LBDS 53W091 and LBDS 53W069. To accommodate APM 08279+5255, one can take the reduced Hubble parameter as large as h=0.64, when the fraction matter energy density $Ω_{m0}\approx 0.22$.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2007age,
  author = {Yi Zhang and Rong-Gen Cai and Hui Li and Hao Wei and Desheng Wu},
  title = {{Age constraints on the Agegraphic Dark Energy Model}},
  year = {2007},
  eprint = {0708.1214},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0708.1214},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure