Age-Associated Hyper-Methylated Regions in the Human Brain Overlap with Bivalent Chromatin Domains

Corey T. Watson, Giulio Disanto, Geir Kjetil Sandve, Felix Breden, Gavin Giovannoni, Sreeram V RamagopalanPLoS 2012 · DOI

Abstract

Recent associations between age-related differentially methylated sites and bivalently marked chromatin domains have implicated these genomic regions in aging and age-related diseases. While previously identified in blood, this study demonstrates that age-associated hyper-methylated sites in the human brain are also highly enriched in bivalent domains. This enrichment is most pronounced in adults, particularly among the most significantly methylated sites. Genes affected are primarily involved in developmental processes, such as neuronal differentiation, suggesting that aging involves the epigenetic "closing off" of these pathways.

Introduction

Aging involves a systematic shift in gene regulation, notably through DNA methylation—an epigenetic mechanism typically associated with gene silencing. Previous research in blood cells indicated that age-related hyper-methylation targets bivalent chromatin domains. These domains, marked by both activating (H3K4me3) and repressing (H3K27me3) histone modifications, keep genes in a "poised" state, ready for activation during development. This study investigates whether a similar mechanism occurs in the human brain, potentially explaining the loss of cognitive plasticity over time.

Methods

The researchers conducted a meta-analysis using high-resolution epigenetic data from 108 human brain samples (dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) across fetal, child (0–10 years), and adult (>10 years) cohorts. Using the Genomic Hyperbrowser and Monte Carlo simulations (50,000 iterations), they tested for non-random overlaps between methylation sites and 1,792 bivalent domains identified in human embryonic stem cells. Functional annotation was performed using DAVID to identify the biological roles of the affected genes.

Results: Enrichment of Hyper-methylation in Bivalent Domains

The analysis revealed a specific and progressive enrichment of hyper-methylation within bivalent domains as the brain ages. While fetal tissues showed no significant overlap, adult brain samples exhibited a 4.73-fold enrichment for hyper-methylated sites ($P = 4.00 \times 10^{-5}$). This effect was even more dramatic when focusing on the top 100 most significantly changed sites, where enrichment reached 10.7-fold. Notably, sites that lose methylation (hypo-methylation) with age showed no such preference for bivalent regions.

Table 1: Enrichment analysis of age-associated methylation sites in bivalent domains across different age groups and methylation states.

Functional Consequences: Silencing Developmental Pathways

Gene Ontology (GO) analysis of the hyper-methylated bivalent regions in the adult brain identified a strong bias toward genes involved in "pattern specification," "embryonic morphogenesis," and "neuron differentiation." This suggests that the epigenetic machinery specifically targets and "locks" pathways essential for cellular plasticity and development during the aging process.

Table 2: Top biological functions for brain hyper-methylated adult-only sites overlapping bivalent genes.

Discussion

The findings suggest that hyper-methylation of bivalent domains is a universal epigenetic signature of aging, shared across tissues like blood and brain. In the brain, this process may represent a mechanical basis for age-related cognitive decline by silencing genes required for neuronal maintenance and differentiation. While the study establishes a strong correlation, further research is required to determine if this methylation is a driver or a passenger of the aging process and to explore its role as a potential biomarker for neurodegenerative diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent associations between age-related differentially methylated sites and bivalently marked chromatin domains have implicated a role for these genomic regions in aging and age-related diseases. However, the overlap between such epigenetic modifications has so far only been identified with respect to age-associated hyper-methylated sites in blood. In this study, we observed that age-associated differentially methylated sites characterized in the human brain were also highly enriched in bivalent domains. Analysis of hyper- vs. hypo-methylated sites partitioned by age (fetal, child, and adult) revealed that enrichment was significant for hyper-methylated sites identified in children and adults (child, fold difference = 2.28, P = 0.0016; adult, fold difference = 4.73, P = 4.00 × 10(-5)); this trend was markedly more pronounced in adults when only the top 100 most significantly hypo- and hyper-methylated sites were considered (adult, fold difference = 10.7, P = 2.00 × 10(-5)). Interestingly, we found that bivalently marked genes overlapped by age-associated hyper-methylation in the adult brain had strong involvement in biological functions related to developmental processes, including neuronal differentiation. Our findings provide evidence that the accumulation of methylation in bivalent gene regions with age is likely to be a common process that occurs across tissue types. Furthermore, particularly with respect to the aging brain, this accumulation might be targeted to loci with important roles in cell differentiation and development, and the closing off of these developmental pathways. Further study of these genes is warranted to assess their potential impact upon the development of age-related neurological disorders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{watson2012age,
  author = {Corey T. Watson and Giulio Disanto and Geir Kjetil Sandve and Felix Breden and Gavin Giovannoni and Sreeram V Ramagopalan},
  title = {{Age-Associated Hyper-Methylated Regions in the Human Brain Overlap with Bivalent Chromatin Domains}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0043840},
}
Figure