Age- and Gender-Specific Differences in the Seasonal Distribution of Diabetes Mortality in Shandong, China: A Spatial Analysis

Wenxiu Zheng, Jie Chu, Jie Ren, Jing Dong, Hilary Bambrick, Ning Wang, Kerrie Mengersen, Xiaolei Guo, Wenbiao HuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals significant spatial and seasonal variations in diabetes mortality across Shandong Province, China, highlighting that eastern regions, women, and the elderly (over 75) face the highest risks. Winter emerges as the peak mortality season, particularly in western and southern areas, suggesting a need for targeted, region-specific public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diabetes is a growing global health crisis, with China bearing a substantial burden. While the overall prevalence and mortality of diabetes are well-documented, understanding the granular spatial and temporal patterns, especially concerning specific demographic groups, remains a challenge. This paper addresses the critical need to identify where and when diabetes mortality is highest within Shandong Province, a region with a diabetes mortality rate exceeding the national average. By dissecting these patterns by age and gender, the study aims to provide crucial data for developing more effective, localized prevention and intervention strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted spatial analysis approach. They utilized a geographic information system (GIS) to map and analyze data from 31 mortality surveillance points across Shandong Province in 2014. Key techniques included:

  • Spatial Kriging Interpolation: This geostatistical method was used to estimate and visualize diabetes mortality rates across the entire county/district level, filling in the gaps between surveillance points.
  • Spatial Clustering (SaTScan and LISA): SaTScan was employed to identify statistically significant clusters of high and low diabetes mortality. Local Indicators of Spatial Association (LISA) maps were used to further pinpoint areas of spatial autocorrelation, identifying "hot spots" (high-high clusters) and "cold spots" (low-low clusters), as well as spatial outliers.
  • Negative Binomial Regression: This statistical model was used to assess the association between diabetes mortality and geographical factors like longitude, latitude, and elevation, helping to explain spatial variations.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: To ensure the robustness of their findings, the researchers conducted a sensitivity analysis using data from 10 surveillance points spanning 2011-2020.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study comprised daily diabetes mortality data collected from 31 mortality surveillance points across Shandong Province in 2014. This data was sourced from the China National Death Surveillance System, which covers deaths from all age groups, but for this study, only individuals aged over 30 were included due to insufficient data for younger age groups. The ICD-10 codes E10-E14 were used to identify diabetes-related deaths.

For sensitivity analysis, data from 10 surveillance points in Shandong Province from 2011 to 2020 was utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Eastern Shandong is a Hotspot: The study consistently points to the eastern and coastal regions of Shandong as having the highest diabetes mortality rates. This suggests that geographical location plays a significant role, potentially linked to environmental or socio-economic factors prevalent in these areas.
  • Winter is the Deadliest Season: Across most of the province, winter stands out as the season with the highest diabetes mortality. This seasonality is particularly pronounced in western and southern regions, hinting at the impact of cold temperatures or seasonal lifestyle changes on diabetes outcomes.
  • Vulnerable Demographics: Women and the elderly (particularly those over 75) are identified as the most vulnerable groups. This underscores the need for gender- and age-specific public health messaging and interventions.
  • Regional Differences in Seasonality: Interestingly, the difference in mortality between winter and summer is less pronounced in the eastern and coastal regions compared to other parts of the province. This could be due to more stable climatic conditions or different adaptive behaviors in these areas.
  • Shandong's Higher Burden: The study confirms that Shandong Province has a higher diabetes mortality rate than the national average in China, emphasizing the urgency of addressing this public health issue within the region.

Key Results

  • Overall Mortality: The overall diabetes mortality rate in the 31 surveillance points was 14.19/100,000 in 2014, significantly higher than the national average.
  • Spatial Clusters: A statistically significant high-risk cluster (RR: 1.58) was identified in the eastern region, while a low-risk cluster (RR: 0.71) was found in the north-western region.
  • Gender Differences: Women experienced higher mortality (16.84/100,000) compared to men (12.15/100,000).
  • Age Differences: Mortality increased with age, with the highest rate observed in individuals over 75 years old (93.91/100,000).
  • Seasonal Pattern: Winter was the highest-risk season across all subgroups.
  • Geographical Associations: Longitude was positively associated with mortality, indicating higher rates in the east. Elevation showed a positive association in some groups but was not statistically significant for all. Latitude did not show significant associations.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The sensitivity analysis using 2011-2020 data confirmed the general spatial and seasonal patterns observed in the 2014 data.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Interpolation Bias: Using data from 31 surveillance points to interpolate for the entire province might introduce some discrepancies.
  • Single Year Data: The primary analysis relied on 2014 data, which, while having the most surveillance points, may not fully represent long-term trends. The limited number of consistent surveillance points over a decade (only ten) also restricts more comprehensive longitudinal analysis.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Exploring Risk Factors: Investigating potential social and environmental risk factors (e.g., temperature, green space, elevation, lifestyles) to better understand the observed spatial and seasonal patterns.
  • Longer-Term Studies: Conducting longer-term research using data from inconsistent points to capture more comprehensive temporal trends.
  • Bayesian Spatiotemporal Methods: Employing more advanced statistical methods to simultaneously account for spatial and temporal correlations, providing richer insights for early warning systems.
  • mHealth and AI: Exploring the potential of mobile health (mHealth) applications and artificial intelligence chatbots for chronic disease surveillance, management, and early warning systems, especially for diabetes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diabetes mortality in Shandong is higher than the national average in China. This study first explored diabetes mortality variation spatially at the county/district level among adults aged over 30 years in terms of age and gender, specifically by season. Daily diabetes mortality data were collected from 31 mortality surveillance points across Shandong Province in 2014. A geographic information system, spatial kriging interpolation and a spatial clustering method were used to examine the spatial patterns of diabetes mortality at the county/district level by season. Sensitivity analysis was conducted using diabetes mortality data from 10 mortality surveillance points from 2011 to 2020. As a result, the total diabetes mortality in eastern counties/districts was the highest (relative risk (RR) of cluster: 1.58, <i>p</i> = 0.00) across the whole province. For subgroups, women had higher mortality (16.84/100,000) than men (12.15/100,000), people aged over 75 years were the most vulnerable (93.91/100,000) and the highest-risk season was winter. However, the mortality differences between winter and summer were smaller in eastern and coastal regions than in other regions for all gender- and age-specific groups. The findings provide further evidence for early warning and precision preventative strategies for diabetes mortality in different regions of Shandong Province. Future research is required to identify the risk factors for diabetes and understand the differences in the social and environmental contexts.
BibTeX
@article{zheng2022age,
  author = {Wenxiu Zheng and Jie Chu and Jie Ren and Jing Dong and Hilary Bambrick and Ning Wang and Kerrie Mengersen and Xiaolei Guo and Wenbiao Hu},
  title = {{Age- and Gender-Specific Differences in the Seasonal Distribution of Diabetes Mortality in Shandong, China: A Spatial Analysis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192417024},
}
Figure