Aftermath suffered by RBI due to moratorium

Manisha Dey, Juan WangAsia‐Pacific 2021 · DOI

Abstract: Financial system is the backbone of the Indian economy. RBI holds the controlling power of the Indian financial system and takes measure to bring the stability by controlling the supply. Due to COVID 19 pandemic, Indian economy are going through very tough period and during this period main supportive hand raise by RBI by safeguarding the interest of the borrowers. The tool implemented by RBI was moratorium to support the borrowers by stake outing with know or unknown consequences. The paper focus on the current status of the Indian banks and the highlighted the negative and positive impact of moratorium on RBI. The paper highlights the measure taken by RBI to combat the stiff situation and also emphasis the role of RBI in reducing the risk of commercial banks.

Introduction

When the COVID-19 pandemic hit India, the economy faced an unprecedented liquidity crunch. To prevent mass defaults, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) introduced a moratorium—allowing borrowers to defer EMI payments without penalty. However, this intervention created a complex "aftermath" for the financial system. This paper examines the "double-edged sword" of this policy, quantifying the systemic stress it placed on Indian banks, specifically regarding asset quality, the solvency of overleveraged sectors like Housing Finance Companies (HFCs), and emerging operational risks.

Methods

This review article employs a qualitative and descriptive analysis based on secondary data synthesized from:

  • Regulatory Reports: Primarily the RBI’s Financial Stability Reports and "Trend and Progress of Banking in India."
  • Market Intelligence: Reports from credit rating agencies like Fitch Ratings.
  • Financial Metrics: Analysis of key indicators such as Gross Non-Performing Assets (GNPA), slippage ratios, and the Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR).

The study compares these metrics across different bank groups—Public Sector Banks (PSBs), Private Sector Banks (PVBs), Foreign Banks (FBs), and Small Finance Banks (SFBs)—to identify sectoral resilience.

Key Insights

The Paradox of Relief

The moratorium acted as a "compulsory financial binding" that provided immediate relief to borrowers but potentially "overshadowed" the structural benefits intended by the 2019 mega-merger of Indian Public Sector Banks (PSBs). While it prevented immediate defaults, it delayed the recognition of underlying asset quality issues.

NBFC Funding Gaps

Non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) were among the hardest hit. Operating on short-term liquidity, the gap between stalled cash inflows (due to the moratorium) and ongoing debt obligations widened significantly, increasing their total borrowing from 23.1% to 28.9%.

The "Slippage" Disparity

Analysis reveals a significant disparity in asset quality across bank types. Public Sector Banks (PSBs) consistently showed the highest slippage ratios and GNPA levels, peaking in 2018 before a slight decline leading into the pandemic period.

GNPA Ratio trends across different bank groups from March 2015 to March 2020.

Operational Risk Explosion

A critical finding is the surge in operational risk during the transition to pandemic-era banking. There was an 82% increase in the number of frauds in 2019-20 compared to 2017-18. PSBs reported over 80% of the total amount involved in these frauds, highlighting vulnerabilities in their operational frameworks during the crisis.

Distribution of the number of frauds across bank groups over three fiscal periods.

Key Results

  • Liquidity Injection: By dropping the repo rate to 4% and reverse repo to 3.35%, the RBI injected approximately Rs 1.37 lakh crore in liquidity.
  • Asset Quality Decline: Capital-to-risk-weighted assets of banks declined from 15% in September 2019 to 14.8% in March 2020.
  • Projected NPAs: Post-COVID non-performing assets are expected to rise to Rs 10 lakh crore.
  • Fraud Impact: Total losses due to operational risks and fraud reached Rs 1,13,375 crores in the 2019-20 fiscal year.
  • MSME Stress: Approximately 9% of MSMEs were found to be under extreme stress, struggling to meet asset quality requirements for new loans.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is a retrospective review and lacks a predictive mathematical model for the "NPA bubble." The 90-day relaxation in NPA classification may have merely delayed bad loan recognition. Future research should focus on the long-term efficacy of "write-off" strategies and capital optimization. As former RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan noted, full economic recovery is a long-term process requiring proactive reinforcement of the banking architecture.

Summary updated

Abstract

Financial system is the backbone of the Indian economy. RBI holds the controlling power of the Indian financial system and takes measure to bring the stability by controlling the supply. Due to COVID 19 pandemic, Indian economy are going through very tough period and during this period main supportive hand raise by RBI by safeguarding the interest of the borrowers. The tool implemented by RBI was moratorium to support the borrowers by stake outing with know or unknown consequences. The paper focus on the current status of the Indian banks and the highlighted the negative and positive impact of moratorium on RBI. The paper highlights the measure taken by RBI to combat the stiff situation and also emphasis the role of RBI in reducing the risk of commercial banks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dey2021aftermath,
  author = {Manisha Dey and Juan Wang},
  title = {{Aftermath suffered by RBI due to moratorium}},
  booktitle = {Asia‐Pacific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.46977/apjmt.2021v01i03.001},
}
Figure