African American Entrepreneurial Sustainability

Edward TurnerScholarWorks 2016

Abstract

African Americans represent one of the fastest-growing entrepreneurial minority groups in the United States, yet they continue to face significant challenges in sustaining new business ventures. Current evidence indicates a staggering 61% failure rate within the first four years of operation, with a survival rate of only 39%. Addressing this gap is not merely a community concern but a macroeconomic necessity; reducing this failure rate could potentially contribute $2.5 trillion to the U.S. economy and generate nearly 12 million jobs. This case study explores the strategies and behaviors of a successful African American entrepreneur in Miami-Dade County who has maintained a profitable business for over 20 years. The findings highlight the critical roles of innovativeness, internal locus of control, self-efficacy, and the strategic leveraging of social and human capital.

The Entrepreneurial Gap

The "entrepreneurial gap" in the United States is a significant hurdle for economic equity. While the number of African American-owned businesses is surging, these enterprises often remain small, less profitable, and highly vulnerable to market fluctuations. The research conducted by Edward Turner seeks to move beyond macroeconomic descriptions of this problem to identify the specific behaviors that allow an entrepreneur to transition from a fragile startup to a sustainable, multi-million-dollar enterprise.

Methodology

This research utilized a qualitative single case study design to provide an in-depth exploration of a "positive outlier"—an award-winning African American dermatologist in Miami-Dade County. The participant has successfully operated a practice for over two decades, with annual revenues exceeding $1 million.

To ensure the validity and credibility of the findings, the study employed methodological triangulation, including:

  • Semi-structured Interviews: Ten open-ended questions designed to elicit rich descriptions of the participant's lived experience.
  • Document Review: Analysis of unpublished financial and marketing documents.
  • Media Review: Examination of published news articles regarding the entrepreneur and the business.
  • Member Checking: Returning findings to the participant to verify the accuracy of the researcher's interpretations.

Data were processed using NVivo 11 software, following a six-step thematic analysis process to identify emergent themes.

Key Pillars of Sustainability

The study identified three core pillars that allowed the entrepreneur to survive the critical first four years and achieve long-term growth:

1. Psychological Entrepreneurial Orientation

The participant demonstrated high levels of innovativeness (including the creation of patented products), an internal locus of control (the belief that one controls their own destiny), and high self-efficacy. Notably, the participant’s confidence was rooted in a combination of formal medical education and religious faith.

2. The Bootstrapping Pivot

Facing systemic barriers to traditional institutional lending, the entrepreneur utilized creative "bootstrapping" techniques during the startup phase. This included bartering for office space and securing loans from family and friends. Traditional bank debt was only pursued strategically after the business had achieved profitability and a proven track record.

3. Social and Human Capital

Lacking the budget for a professional sales force, the entrepreneur leveraged social capital within the local community. Referrals from barbers, pastors, and teachers created a "word-of-mouth" marketing engine within the ethnic enclave. Furthermore, the participant’s high level of human capital—specifically a medical degree and specialized training—served as a critical differentiator, allowing entry into a high-barrier, sustainable industry.

Results and Analysis

The thematic analysis yielded specific frequencies for the core subthemes identified in the data:

  • Entrepreneurial Characteristics: Innovativeness (36.65%), Internal Locus of Control (36.65%), and Self-efficacy (26.70%).
  • Resource Management: Human Capital (55%) and Social Capital (45%).
  • Financial Capital: A heavy reliance on bootstrapping (58%) followed by strategic debt (a $50,000 bank loan) once the model was proven.

These findings suggest that sustainability is achieved when an entrepreneur successfully "bridges" informal social networks with formal systems, such as patents and bank credit, once the business model has been validated.

Implications for Social Change

The insights from this study contribute to social change by providing a blueprint for other minority entrepreneurs. By understanding the necessity of psychological resilience, the strategic use of community networks, and the importance of bootstrapping, African American entrepreneurs can better navigate the "valley of death" in early-stage business.

Future research should involve larger sample sizes across different industries and geographic locations to test the transferability of these strategies. Additionally, exploring the specific transition points from bootstrapping to formal financing remains a critical area for further investigation to help close the entrepreneurial gap.

Summary updated

Abstract

African Americans are among the fastest growing entrepreneurial minority group in the United States, but they continue to struggle with sustaining these new business ventures. Evidence suggests that African American business entrepreneurs experience an increased failure rate with a 4-year business survival rate of 39%. Reducing the failure rate would significantly add to the U.S. economy (an estimated $2.5 trillion) and create nearly 12 million more jobs. The purpose of this single case study was to explore the strategies and behaviors of an award-winning African American entrepreneur in Miami Dade County who has remained in business over 20 years. The conceptual framework for this study was entrepreneurship theory. The data were collected through a semistructured interview with the participant, a review of published news media data, and a review of financial and marketing documents. Member checking was completed with the participant to strengthen credibility and trustworthiness of interpretations. The findings revealed several qualities about this entrepreneur, including innovativeness, internal locus of control, and self-efficacy attributed to business success. The participant also leveraged education and family networks as social capital to reach firm sustainability, as well as bootstrapping to mitigate the lack of financial capital. The information learned from these findings may contribute to social change by providing insight into the necessary strategies and behaviors required by African American entrepreneurs to stay in business beyond 4 years.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{turner2016african,
  author = {Edward Turner},
  title = {{African American Entrepreneurial Sustainability}},
  booktitle = {ScholarWorks},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure