Aesthetic chills foster self-acceptance and emotional breakthrough in depression

Félix Schoeller, Abhinandan Jain, Vladimir Adrien, Pattie MaesPsyArXiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Aesthetic chills, a strong emotional reaction characterized by a specific bodily response of thermoregulatory mechanisms such as shivers and goosebumps, may hold scientific and clinical potential for reward-related or dopaminergic illnesses. In this first exploratory study, we examined the effects of chills stimulation on subjects clinically diagnosed with depression. Our results suggest that chill-inducing stimuli may have the potential to affect the core schema of depressed patients, specifically in terms of shame and self-acceptance. These results suggest that the mechanism of action during the chills response may resemble the form of problem resolution induced by the psychedelic and psychotherapeutic experience, leading to similar positive outcomes for the subject. Further research is needed to fully understand the effects of chills on mental health and to determine the feasibility and safety of using aesthetic chills as a therapeutic intervention.

Introduction

Depression is frequently marked by anhedonia—a state of emotional numbness—and a "core schema" of persistent negative beliefs, such as deep-seated shame and a sense of being inherently defective. While traditional psychotherapy aims to dismantle these rigid cognitive structures, the process is often slow and resource-intensive.

Recent breakthroughs in psychedelic-assisted therapy have highlighted the therapeutic power of "emotional breakthroughs"—sudden, peak experiences that allow patients to bypass mental defenses and gain transformative insights. However, the legal and safety barriers associated with pharmacological psychedelics limit their accessibility. This study explores whether "aesthetic chills"—the physiological response of shivers or goosebumps elicited by powerful art, music, or film—can induce similar peak experiences and emotional breakthroughs in individuals with depression.

Methods

The study recruited 96 participants clinically diagnosed with depression via the Prolific platform. Researchers employed a pre-test/post-test design to measure the impact of chills-inducing stimuli.

  1. Baseline Assessment: Participants reported their current mood (valence and arousal) and completed the Young Positive Schema Questionnaire (YPSQ-S3) to establish baseline levels of adaptive schemas like self-acceptance and trust.
  2. Stimulus Exposure: Participants were randomly assigned to watch one of two videos from ChillsDB, an open-source database of stimuli known to elicit aesthetic chills. The selected videos (a poignant commercial and a motivational speech medley) had a high probability ($\geq 0.8$) of inducing chills.
  3. Post-Stimulus Assessment: Immediately following the video, participants reported whether they experienced chills. They then completed the Emotional Breakthrough Inventory (EBI)—a tool originally developed for psychedelic research—and retook the YPSQ-S3 to evaluate changes in core beliefs.

Results

The experience of aesthetic chills was strongly associated with significant psychological shifts. Participants who felt chills reported markedly higher emotional breakthrough scores compared to those who did not.

Comparison of Emotional Breakthrough, Valence Drift, and Arousal Drift between participants who experienced chills and those who did not.

Key findings include:

  • Emotional Breakthroughs: The chills group achieved significantly higher EBI scores ($m = 5.18$) than the no-chills group ($m = 3.64, p < 0.001$). The intensity of the chills positively correlated with the magnitude of the breakthrough ($r = 0.546$).
  • Schema Modification: A statistically significant improvement in the self-acceptance schema was observed specifically within the chills group ($p = 0.002$). This suggests that aesthetic chills may temporarily "soften" rigid, negative self-beliefs.
  • Emotional Drift: Participants experiencing chills showed a significant positive shift in both valence (moving toward pleasantness) and arousal (moving toward excitement). This "drift" suggests a transition from a state of emotional stagnation to one of active engagement.
  • Accessibility: Interestingly, baseline mood did not predict the occurrence of chills, suggesting that the "chills" mechanism remains accessible even during periods of deep emotional numbness.

Discussion

These exploratory results suggest that aesthetic chills may serve as a non-pharmacological "backdoor" to emotional breakthroughs, mimicking the psychological "reset" observed in psychedelic therapy. The physiological resolution of tension inherent in the chills response appears to facilitate a cognitive-emotional resolution, particularly regarding self-acceptance.

However, several limitations must be noted. The study relied on a relatively small, self-reported sample and measured only immediate effects. Future research should incorporate objective physiological measures (e.g., skin conductance) and longitudinal tracking to determine if repeated exposure to chills-inducing stimuli can lead to sustained clinical improvements in depression. Aesthetic chills represent a promising, low-risk intervention for reward-related illnesses that warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aesthetic chills, a strong emotional reaction characterized by a specific bodily response of thermoregulatory mechanisms such as shivers and goosebumps, may hold scientific and clinical potential for reward-related or dopaminergic illnesses. In this first exploratory study, we examined the effects of chills stimulation on subjects clinically diagnosed with depression. Our results suggest that chill-inducing stimuli may have the potential to affect the core schema of depressed patients, specifically in terms of shame and self-acceptance. These results suggest that the mechanism of action during the chills response may resemble the form of problem resolution induced by the psychedelic and psychotherapeutic experience, leading to similar positive outcomes for the subject. Further research is needed to fully understand the effects of chills on mental health and to determine the feasibility and safety of using aesthetic chills as a therapeutic intervention.
BibTeX
@misc{schoeller2022aesthetic,
  author = {Félix Schoeller and Abhinandan Jain and Vladimir Adrien and Pattie Maes},
  title = {{Aesthetic chills foster self-acceptance and emotional breakthrough in depression}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.31234/osf.io/rhftq},
  howpublished = {PsyArXiv},
}
Figure