Aero Elastic Analysis of Aero Spiked Body in a Supersonic Flow Field Using Experiment and Simulations

Shravya Manda, Prateek Prasanna, A. Kamalesh, G. Jagadeesh, P. TheerthamalaiJournal of Aerospace Sciences and Technologies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the aeroelastic behavior of aerospikes—critical drag-reduction components for supersonic vehicles—by combining wind tunnel experiments with 2-way coupled Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI) simulations. The researchers successfully characterized how oscillating shock waves at Mach 2.5 induce structural vibrations and stresses, finding that even small changes in the angle of attack significantly amplify mechanical loads.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

At supersonic speeds, vehicles face two major enemies: massive aerodynamic drag and intense aerodynamic heating. Aerospikes are elegant solutions; they are essentially needles protruding from the nose of a missile or aircraft that "push" the shock wave away from the body, creating a recirculating flow zone that reduces drag.

However, these spikes are thin and exposed to violent, unsteady flow fields. The interaction between the fluid (air) and the structure (the spike) can lead to "aeroelastic" effects—vibrations and deformations that are difficult to predict. If these oscillations match the natural frequency of the spike, it could lead to structural failure. This paper seeks to bridge the gap between theoretical flow physics and practical structural response to ensure these devices are both effective and durable.

Methods

The authors employed a dual-track approach to validate their findings:

  • Experimental Testing: Conducted in a supersonic wind tunnel at Mach 2.5. The model consisted of a flat-faced cylinder (50mm diameter) equipped with a steel aerospike. They used shadowgraphy (a high-speed optical technique) to visualize shock wave patterns and dynamic pressure sensors (Endevco) to record high-frequency pressure fluctuations.
  • 2-Way Coupled FSI Simulations: Using ANSYS Workbench (Fluent for fluid dynamics and Mechanical APDL for structural analysis), the team performed simulations where the fluid flow deforms the structure, and that deformation, in turn, alters the fluid flow. This "2-way" coupling is more computationally expensive but far more accurate for studying vibrations than traditional static simulations.
  • Comparative Analysis: They compared two different materials—steel and aluminum—to see how stiffness and density affect the spike's response at angles of attack (AoA) of 0° and 5°.

Datasets

This study does not use public machine learning datasets. Instead, it generates original experimental data from a 300mm x 300mm supersonic wind tunnel. This data served as a benchmark to validate the accuracy of their CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) and FSI models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Dancing" Shock Wave: The study confirmed that shock waves aren't static; they oscillate and pulsate. They identified a dominant pressure oscillation frequency of approximately 4.2 kHz in the flow field.
  • Frequency Mismatch: Interestingly, while the pressure fluctuated at 4.2 kHz, the resulting structural deformation and stress cycles in the spike occurred at a lower frequency of roughly 2.6 kHz. This suggests the structure acts as a mechanical filter or responds to specific harmonics of the flow.
  • The Angle of Attack (AoA) Penalty: At a 0° angle of attack, the forces are symmetric and deformations are negligible. However, tilting the model just 5° causes a massive spike in asymmetric forces and stresses, highlighting a critical design constraint for maneuvering vehicles.
  • Material Sensitivity: While both materials experienced similar stress levels (16 MPa at 5° AoA), the aluminum spike deformed more than three times as much as the steel spike (330 µm vs 100 µm), demonstrating the importance of material selection in managing aeroelastic stability.

Key Results

  • Validation: The FSI simulations matched the experimental pressure data within a 10% margin, proving the simulation's reliability for predicting transient flow fields.
  • Deformation: At Mach 2.5 and 5° AoA, the maximum tip deformation for a steel spike was 100 µm, while an aluminum spike reached 330 µm.
  • Stress: The maximum stress recorded at the root of the spike for both materials at 5° AoA was 16 MPa. At 0° AoA, the stress was significantly lower at 0.45 MPa.
  • Flow Visualization: Shadowgraph images successfully captured the transition between "attached" and "detached" shock wave patterns, which are the primary drivers of the unsteady pressure loads.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study is a snapshot of specific conditions (Mach 2.5, specific geometry). Limitations and areas for future exploration include:

  • Fatigue Analysis: While the study looks at instantaneous stress and deformation, the authors note that the high-frequency vibrations (kHz range) necessitate a deeper look into long-term fatigue and potential failure points.
  • Thermal Effects: The current study focuses on structural loads but does not fully integrate the "aerodynamic heating" aspect, which could soften the material and change its aeroelastic properties.
  • Higher Mach Numbers: Future research could extend these FSI models to hypersonic regimes (Mach 5+) where the interactions become even more non-linear and violent.

Summary updated

Abstract

The focus of this work is to study the structural response of an aero spiked body in a supersonic flow field of M 2.5 and at zero angle of attack. Fluid-Structure interaction simulations and wind tunnel testing have been carried out on the model for the above condition. 2-way coupled Fluid-Structure Interaction simulations have been carried out to study the aero elastic effect of the aero spike material. The wind tunnel testing for the select condition has been carried out at zero angle of attack for steel spike. The pressure measurement on the flat face cylinder from testing has been compared with that of the simulation data and presented here. Detailed analysis of aero spike deflections, stresses and induced forces due to the shock wave field have been discussed here in detail.
BibTeX
@article{manda2023aero,
  author = {Shravya Manda and Prateek Prasanna and A. Kamalesh and G. Jagadeesh and P. Theerthamalai},
  title = {{Aero Elastic Analysis of Aero Spiked Body in a Supersonic Flow Field Using Experiment and Simulations}},
  journal = {Journal of Aerospace Sciences and Technologies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.61653/joast.v70i2.2018.350},
}
Figure