Adversarial Domain Adaptation for Variational Neural Language Generation in Dialogue Systems

Van-Khanh Tran, Le-Minh NguyenCOLING 2018

TL;DR

This paper introduces VDANLG, a novel adversarial domain adaptation framework for neural language generation in dialogue systems. By leveraging variational autoencoders and a dual-critic adversarial training approach, VDANLG effectively adapts to new domains with limited target data, outperforming previous methods and demonstrating a promising path towards more robust and generalizable dialogue systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing dialogue systems that can converse naturally and effectively across various domains is a significant challenge. Traditionally, these systems require extensive domain-specific annotated data, which is often scarce for new or niche domains. This "domain adaptation" problem is particularly acute for Natural Language Generation (NLG), where generating coherent and contextually appropriate responses is crucial. Existing methods struggle to efficiently transfer knowledge from data-rich source domains to data-poor target domains, leading to a performance drop when encountering unseen domains. This paper tackles this challenge by proposing a method to adapt existing NLG models to new domains using minimal target data, thereby improving their generalization capabilities.

Methods

The core of the proposed approach is the Variational Domain-Adaptation Neural Language Generator (VDANLG). It builds upon a Variational Autoencoder (VAE) framework, specifically a Variational Recurrent Neural Network (VRNN), to model the underlying semantic space of dialogue acts and utterances using a latent variable z. This latent variable allows the model to capture richer semantic information.

The key innovation lies in the adversarial training procedure with two critics:

  1. Text Similarity Critic (SC): This critic aims to ensure that generated sentences are stylistically similar to those in the target domain. It classifies sentence pairs as either "similar" or "unsimilar" in terms of textual style.
  2. Domain Critic (DC): This critic is designed to make the feature distributions of the source and target domains indistinguishable. It classifies utterances as originating from the source, target, or being generated by the model.

These critics work in tandem with the generator. The generator is trained to produce outputs that fool both critics (i.e., appear similar to target domain text and indistinguishable from target domain data), while the critics are trained to correctly classify these outputs. This adversarial process guides the generator to adapt its learned representations and generation style towards the target domain. The method also incorporates KL cost annealing to encourage meaningful latent representations and a gradient reversal layer to facilitate domain-invariant feature learning.

Datasets

The paper utilizes existing datasets for training and evaluation. While specific dataset names are mentioned in the context of related work and experimental setups, the core experiments seem to involve adapting models between different domains within a larger dialogue system corpus. The paper mentions:

  • Source Domains: Hotel, Restaurant, Tv, Laptop.
  • Target Domains: Hotel, Restaurant, Tv, Laptop.
  • Counterfeit datasets are also mentioned for unsupervised domain adaptation experiments.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather focuses on evaluating adaptation performance across existing domain pairs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Variational inference is key for semantic understanding: The use of VAEs allows the model to learn a more robust and transferable representation of the underlying semantics of dialogue acts and utterances, which is crucial for adaptation.
  • Adversarial critics are essential for style and domain alignment: The dual-critic approach effectively guides the generator to not only produce semantically relevant text but also to adopt the stylistic nuances and domain-specific characteristics of the target domain.
  • Limited target data is sufficient with effective adaptation: The experiments demonstrate that even with as little as 1-7% of target domain data, the proposed VDANLG model can achieve competitive or superior performance compared to models trained on full target domain data.
  • Combining critics yields synergistic benefits: Ablation studies show that using both the Text Similarity Critic and the Domain Critic together leads to significantly better performance than using either critic alone or no critics at all.

Key Results

  • VDANLG significantly outperforms baseline models (e.g., RALSTM, Enc-Dec) in domain adaptation scenarios, especially when target domain data is scarce (1-7%).
  • In adaptation experiments, VDANLG achieved higher BLEU scores and lower ERR (Error Rate) compared to models trained from scratch or without critics. For instance, adapting to the target Hotel domain from the source Laptop domain, VDANLG achieved a BLEU score of 82.18 with an ERR of 2.89%, significantly outperforming a baseline without critics (78.70 BLEU, 15.17% ERR).
  • The model shows strong performance even in unsupervised domain adaptation settings, reducing slot error rates considerably.
  • Qualitative analysis of generated outputs shows that VDANLG produces more coherent and stylistically appropriate responses, with fewer errors like missing or misplaced slots, compared to other models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unsupervised Domain Adaptation: While the paper shows promising results in unsupervised domain adaptation, it acknowledges that this area requires further investigation.
  • Dataset Distance: The paper notes that the difficulty of domain adaptation can vary with the "distance" between source and target domains, and while the model generally performs well, there are instances where adaptation is challenging even for closer domain pairs.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further exploration of unsupervised domain adaptation as a promising direction. They also aim to investigate the model's ability to handle more complex scenarios and potentially improve its robustness in diverse and challenging dialogue environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{tran2018adversarial,
  author = {Van-Khanh Tran and Le-Minh Nguyen},
  title = {{Adversarial Domain Adaptation for Variational Neural Language Generation in Dialogue Systems}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure