Advancing recognition justice in telecoupled critical mineral supply chains: The promise of social media

Datu Buyung Agusdinata, Hallie Eakin, Nicole Darnall, Bohan Jiang, Hugo Romero AravenaEnergy 2023 · DOI

Introduction

The global transition to low-carbon energy is fundamentally dependent on critical minerals, with lithium at the forefront of the electric vehicle (EV) revolution. However, this "green" transition often creates a geographic and cognitive divide between the "Receiving Systems"—the remote regions where mining occurs—and the "Sending Systems"—the global centers of policy, capital, and consumption. This paper investigates how social media can bridge this gap, advancing recognition justice by making the grievances of marginalized mining communities visible to global stakeholders.

A Framework for Recognition Justice

In telecoupled systems, information about local environmental harms, such as water scarcity and ecosystem degradation, rarely reaches the consumers and producers who benefit from the resources. Recognition justice requires that these invisible communities be acknowledged. The authors propose a framework where social media acts as a "return flow" of immaterial information, bypassing traditional barriers to communication.

Conceptual framework of telecoupled systems and the role of social media in bridging the gap between receiving and sending systems.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-pronged computational approach to analyze digital discourse surrounding lithium mining in the Atacama region of Chile between 2015 and 2020.

  • Data Acquisition: Using the TWINT tool, they collected two datasets: a Local Dataset (1,722 georeferenced tweets from the Atacama region) and a Global Dataset (71,521 tweets related to mining and the environment).
  • Sentiment Analysis: The study utilized the multilingual XLM-roBERTa-base Large Language Model (LLM) to classify tweets into positive, negative, or neutral categories.
  • Text and Network Analysis: N-gram analysis identified dominant themes, while network mapping via Gephi revealed the structure of information flows and influential "hubs."

Key Findings: The Centrality of Water

The most significant insight from the text mining analysis is that for local communities, the lithium-driven energy transition is primarily experienced as a hydrological crisis. Negative sentiments were overwhelmingly tied to water scarcity and environmental degradation.

Top-30 bigrams and trigrams extracted from the Twitter datasets, highlighting the prevalence of water-related concerns.

As shown in the N-gram analysis, terms like "without water," "water cut," and "dry extraction" dominate the discourse. This empirical evidence suggests that water is the "lightning rod" for social license to operate in mining regions.

The "Boomerang Effect" and Information Brokers

Network analysis revealed a strategic "Boomerang Effect." Local individuals (IND) rarely engage directly with mining corporations on Twitter. Instead, they target NGOs and News Media (NM). These actors serve as essential information brokers, picking up local grievances and broadcasting them to a global audience.

The study found that while the network is sparse, a few highly connected hubs—such as indigenous organizations and environmental journalists—hold the network together. This "scale-free" structure means that recognition justice depends heavily on the visibility provided by these key intermediaries.

Conclusion

While social media offers a powerful tool for distal connectivity, challenges remain. The "digital divide" may exclude the most vulnerable indigenous populations, and digital recognition does not automatically translate into procedural or distributive justice. However, the study demonstrates that sentiment spikes and digital discourse can serve as early warning signals for supply chain managers, potentially forcing a shift toward more equitable and transparent mineral sourcing practices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{agusdinata2023advancing,
  author = {Datu Buyung Agusdinata and Hallie Eakin and Nicole Darnall and Bohan Jiang and Hugo Romero Aravena},
  title = {{Advancing recognition justice in telecoupled critical mineral supply chains: The promise of social media}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.erss.2023.103264},
}
Figure