Advancing fishery-independent stock assessments for the Norway lobster (Nephrops norvegicus) with new monitoring technologies

Jacopo Aguzzi, Damianos Chatzievangelou, Nathan J. Robinson, Nixon Bahamón, Alan Berry, Marc Carreras, Joan B. Company, Corrado Costa, Joaquín del Río Fernández, Ahmad Falahzadeh, Spyros Fifas, Sascha Flögel, Jordi Grinyó, Jónas P. Jónasson, Patrik Jönsson, Colm Lordan, Mathieu Lundy, Simone Marini, Michela Martinelli, Ivan Masmitjà Rusiñol, Luca Mirimin, Atif Naseer, Joan Navarro, Narcís Palomeras, Giacomo Picardi, Cristina Silva, Sérgio Stefanni, Maria Vigo, Y. Vila, Adrian WeetmanFrontiers in Marine Science 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The Norway lobster, Nephrops norvegicus, supports a key European fishery. Stock assessments for this species are mostly based on trawling and UnderWater TeleVision (UWTV) surveys. However, N. norvegicus are burrowing organisms and these survey methods are unable to sample or observe individuals in their burrows. To account for this, UWTV surveys generally assume that “1 burrow system = 1 animal”, due to the territorial behavior of N. norvegicus. Nevertheless, this assumption still requires in-situ validation. Here, we outline how to improve the accuracy of current stock assessments for N. norvegicus with novel ecological monitoring technologies, including: robotic fixed and mobile camera-platforms, telemetry, environmental DNA (eDNA), and Artificial Intelligence (AI).

Introduction: The Challenge of Assessing Burrowing Stocks

The Norway lobster is one of Europe’s most valuable seafood commodities. However, managing its stocks presents significant biological challenges. Unlike pelagic fish, Nephrops spend the majority of their lives within complex U-shaped burrows in the seafloor sediment.

Traditional trawl surveys are limited because they only capture individuals when they emerge to feed or mate. This emergence behavior is highly sensitive to environmental factors such as light levels and tidal currents, introducing substantial bias into catch-per-unit-effort data. To mitigate this, researchers implemented UnderWater TeleVision (UWTV) surveys, where human operators count burrow systems from sled-mounted cameras. This method relies on the critical assumption of a 1:1 ratio between burrow systems and lobsters—an assumption that fails to account for multiple occupants, empty burrows, or occupancy by other species. A more robust, fishery-independent approach is required to validate sub-surface activity.

Technological Innovations in Monitoring

To move beyond the limitations of manual UWTV counting, several emerging technologies are being integrated into assessment workflows:

AI and Computer Vision

Deep Learning architectures, such as Faster R-CNN and MobileNet, are being deployed to automate burrow detection in video feeds. These systems can process thousands of hours of footage with a mean Average Precision (mAP) of approximately 80%, matching the performance of expert human counters while eliminating fatigue-related bias and standardizing results across different regional management units.

Autonomous Underwater Robotics

Stationary cabled observatories and mobile robotic platforms (e.g., crawlers like "Rossia" or biomimetic legged robots like "Silver 2") allow for long-term, non-invasive monitoring. Unlike traditional sleds, these platforms can observe emergence rhythms over months, providing data on how environmental variables like oxygen and light "gate" lobster activity.

Non-Visual Sensors and eDNA

  • Acoustic Telemetry: Tagging individuals allows for precise tracking of movement patterns in and out of burrows.
  • Environmental DNA (eDNA): Sampling water or sediment near burrow entrances can detect genetic traces of Nephrops, confirming occupancy even when the animal is not visible.

Current Assessment Status and Data Integration

The implementation of these technologies varies significantly across European waters. While the North Atlantic has a wealth of data, many Mediterranean stocks remain "data-limited," highlighting the need for technological expansion.

Figure 1: Spatial distribution of Fishery Units (FUs) and Geographical Subareas (GSAs) as of 2022, categorized by the type of UWTV monitoring employed.

Current assessments rely on time-series data of harvest rates and burrow counts. Figure 6 illustrates these trends across various Functional Units (FUs), highlighting the variability in stock health and the reliance on UWTV-derived burrow counts as a proxy for abundance.

Figure 6: Time series of harvest rates and UWTV burrow counts across different Functional Units.

Discussion and Future Directions

The primary uncertainty in current models is the "occupancy gap"—the difference between visible burrows and actual lobster numbers. Technologies like eDNA and stationary robotics offer a path to calibrate these ratios. Furthermore, AI provides a digital "yardstick" to standardize assessments internationally, reducing the human "drift" in accuracy between regions.

However, challenges remain. Mobile robots can resuspend sediment, obscuring visibility, and the persistence of eDNA in deep-sea sediments requires further calibration to avoid "ghost" detections. While the initial capital cost for advanced robotics is high, the long-term efficiency gains and increased precision are expected to lower the relative cost of monitoring, which currently stands at 1-2% of total landing value in well-monitored regions like Scotland and Iceland.

Conclusion

Integrating AI, autonomous robotics, and molecular tools into Nephrops stock assessments represents a paradigm shift from manual counting to holistic, multiparametric monitoring. This technological overhaul is essential for ensuring the long-term sustainability of this vital fishery.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Norway lobster, Nephrops norvegicus , supports a key European fishery. Stock assessments for this species are mostly based on trawling and UnderWater TeleVision (UWTV) surveys. However, N. norvegicus are burrowing organisms and these survey methods are unable to sample or observe individuals in their burrows. To account for this, UWTV surveys generally assume that “1 burrow system = 1 animal”, due to the territorial behavior of N. norvegicus . Nevertheless, this assumption still requires in-situ validation. Here, we outline how to improve the accuracy of current stock assessments for N. norvegicus with novel ecological monitoring technologies, including: robotic fixed and mobile camera-platforms, telemetry, environmental DNA (eDNA), and Artificial Intelligence (AI). First, we outline the present status and threat for overexploitation in N. norvegicus stocks. Then, we discuss how the burrowing behavior of N. norvegicus biases current stock assessment methods. We propose that state-of-the-art stationary and mobile robotic platforms endowed with innovative sensors and complemented with AI tools could be used to count both animals and burrows systems in-situ , as well as to provide key insights into burrowing behavior. Next, we illustrate how multiparametric monitoring can be incorporated into assessments of physiology and burrowing behavior. Finally, we develop a flowchart for the appropriate treatment of multiparametric biological and environmental data required to improve current stock assessment methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aguzzi2022advancing,
  author = {Jacopo Aguzzi and Damianos Chatzievangelou and Nathan J. Robinson and Nixon Bahamón and Alan Berry and Marc Carreras and Joan B. Company and Corrado Costa and Joaquín del Río Fernández and Ahmad Falahzadeh and Spyros Fifas and Sascha Flögel and Jordi Grinyó and Jónas P. Jónasson and Patrik Jönsson and Colm Lordan and Mathieu Lundy and Simone Marini and Michela Martinelli and Ivan Masmitjà Rusiñol and Luca Mirimin and Atif Naseer and Joan Navarro and Narcís Palomeras and Giacomo Picardi and Cristina Silva and Sérgio Stefanni and Maria Vigo and Y. Vila and Adrian Weetman},
  title = {{Advancing fishery-independent stock assessments for the Norway lobster (Nephrops norvegicus) with new monitoring technologies}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2022.969071},
}
Figure