Advances and Challenges in Privacy Preserving Planning

Guy ShaniIJCAI 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper surveys the field of Collaborative Privacy-Preserving Planning (CPPP), a multi-agent planning problem where agents must achieve common goals while keeping certain information private. It outlines recent advancements in privacy models, algorithmic approaches, and heuristic computations, while also highlighting open challenges and future research directions in this critical area.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's increasingly interconnected world, autonomous agents (like robots, software agents, or even human teams) often need to collaborate to achieve complex goals. However, these agents may possess sensitive private information – such as their exact location, capabilities, or internal states – that they cannot reveal to others due to privacy concerns, competitive reasons, or security policies. This creates a fundamental challenge: how can agents plan and act together effectively without compromising their private data? This is the core problem addressed by Collaborative Privacy-Preserving Planning (CPPP). The paper highlights that traditional multi-agent planning assumes full information sharing, which is unrealistic in many practical scenarios. CPPP aims to bridge this gap by enabling collaborative planning under privacy constraints.

Methods

The paper discusses two primary algorithmic approaches to CPPP:

  • Joint Global Planning followed by Independent Local Extension: This approach first involves agents jointly creating a high-level plan composed of only public actions. Subsequently, each agent independently extends this global scheme with its private actions to form a complete, detailed multi-agent plan.
  • Distributed Forward Search: In this method, agents collaboratively run a distributed forward search to find a multi-agent plan directly. They communicate their progress to other agents, often by obfuscating private information before sharing.

A crucial component for both approaches is the use of heuristics to guide the search process. The paper details adaptations of classical planning heuristics to CPPP, with a significant focus on the challenge of computing these heuristics without disclosing private information. This often involves developing techniques to compute heuristic values based only on public information or carefully obfuscated private information.

The paper also delves into various privacy models, ranging from "weak privacy" (where agents can infer some information) to "strong privacy" (where agents cannot deduce the existence of private facts). It also discusses intermediate models like "agent privacy" and "cardinality preserving privacy."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a general framework and algorithmic approaches, using a logistics example for illustration rather than specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The inherent tension between collaboration and privacy: The core challenge in CPPP is balancing the need for agents to share information to coordinate effectively with the imperative to protect their private data.
  • No one-size-fits-all privacy model: The paper presents a spectrum of privacy definitions, from weak to strong, and intermediate concepts like agent and cardinality privacy, suggesting that the appropriate level of privacy depends on the specific application.
  • Heuristics are critical but complex in CPPP: While heuristics are essential for efficient planning, their computation in CPPP is significantly more challenging due to the need to avoid privacy breaches. This has led to novel adaptations of classical heuristics.
  • Algorithmic approaches are diverging: Two main paradigms exist: building a global plan first and then refining it locally, or performing a fully distributed search with careful information sharing. Both have their trade-offs.
  • Strong privacy is difficult to achieve: While desirable, achieving "strong privacy" (where private facts cannot be deduced at all) is computationally expensive and often leads to inefficient or incomplete planning algorithms.

Key Results

The paper is a survey and does not present new empirical results. Instead, it synthesizes findings from existing research:

  • It outlines various algorithmic advancements for CPPP, including planners like GPPP, DPP, MAFS, and MADLA, which offer different trade-offs in terms of privacy, efficiency, and completeness.
  • It details the adaptation of several classical planning heuristics (e.g., delete relaxation, landmarks, pattern databases) to the CPPP setting, highlighting the challenges and solutions for privacy-preserving computation.
  • It categorizes and explains different privacy models and their implications for planning.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper identifies several limitations and areas for future research:

  • Achieving strong privacy is often inefficient or incomplete: Current algorithms that guarantee strong privacy are either computationally demanding or may not always find a solution. Future work could focus on developing more efficient and complete strongly privacy-preserving algorithms.
  • Optimal planning for CPPP is underexplored: While heuristics are discussed, the problem of finding provably optimal plans in CPPP has not received sufficient attention.
  • Exploring alternative planning settings: The paper suggests extending CPPP to handle non-deterministic action effects and partial observability, which would require new planning representations (e.g., plan trees/graphs) and algorithms.
  • More refined privacy metrics: Moving beyond binary privacy criteria to quantify leaked information could allow for a more flexible trade-off between privacy and efficiency.
  • Investigating the implications of different privacy models: Further research is needed to understand the representational power and practical implications of various privacy definitions.
  • Real-world applicability: While CPPP is motivated by real-world examples, further work is needed to demonstrate its effectiveness and scalability in complex, dynamic environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shani2018advances,
  author = {Guy Shani},
  title = {{Advances and Challenges in Privacy Preserving Planning}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2018/816},
}
Figure