Advancement of Circular Economy Through Interdisciplinary Collaboration: A Bibliometric Approach

Keita Nishimoto, Koji Kimita, Shinsuke Murakami, Yin Long, Kimitaka Asatani, Ichiro SakataarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Since the European Union introduced its Circular Economy Action Plan in 2015, the Circular Economy (CE) has transitioned from a niche concept to a dominant framework for sustainable development. By its very nature, the transition to a circular model requires a radical rethinking of product design, business strategies, consumer behavior, and waste management technologies. This inherent complexity makes CE a deeply interdisciplinary field. However, despite the exponential growth in research volume, the macro-level interactions between these diverse disciplines have remained largely opaque.

This study addresses this gap by quantitatively mapping the CE research landscape. By analyzing over 25,000 academic papers and 20,000 policy documents, the research tracks how scholars migrate into the field, identifies which sub-disciplines drive policy versus those that secure funding, and measures the tangible impact of interdisciplinary collaboration.

Methodology: From Bibliometrics to Semantic Mapping

To move beyond traditional keyword counting, the authors employed a sophisticated Natural Language Processing (NLP) pipeline to analyze literature at scale. The methodology integrated several key components:

  • Semantic Embeddings: Paper abstracts were processed using OpenAI’s text-embedding-3-small model, converting textual data into 1536-dimensional semantic vectors. This approach captures the conceptual meaning of research rather than just shared terminology.
  • Clustering and Visualization: Hierarchical clustering (Ward’s method) was applied to these vectors to categorize the literature into 6 major and 16 minor research fields. The resulting landscape was visualized using Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) for dimensionality reduction.
  • Tracking Researcher Trajectories: The study identified "active" CE researchers (those with 3+ papers post-2015) and analyzed their pre-2015 publication history to establish their original academic backgrounds.
  • Collaboration Metrics: The authors utilized the Jaccard coefficient to measure co-authorship intensity and cosine similarity to evaluate the conceptual overlap between different disciplines.

The CE Landscape: The Attention vs. Funding Trade-off

The analysis revealed a stark divergence in how different CE sub-fields are rewarded. A significant negative correlation exists between academic/policy attention and grant funding:

  1. The Business and Policy Pillar: Research focused on business models, supply chain frameworks, and conceptual CE definitions dominates both academic citations and policy documents. Approximately 50% of all CE citations in policy documents originate from the EU and Intergovernmental Organizations (IGOs) like the OECD and UN, with a heavy preference for these management-oriented papers.
  2. The Engineering and Technical Pillar: Conversely, "hard" engineering fields—such as metal adsorption, wastewater treatment, and resource recovery—receive significantly less citation volume and policy visibility. However, these fields secure substantially more grant funding per paper.

This suggests a symbiotic, albeit lopsided, ecosystem: business-oriented research generates the necessary "hype" and policy frameworks that unlock the economic resources required to fund technical implementation.

The Interdisciplinary Premium

One of the study's most critical findings is the quantifiable benefit of cross-disciplinary work. The data proves that interdisciplinary teams consistently outperform intradisciplinary teams in terms of research impact.

By comparing teams of equal size, the researchers found that papers co-authored by individuals from different original academic backgrounds (e.g., an engineer collaborating with an economist) achieved higher median citation counts than teams composed of researchers from the same field. This "interdisciplinary premium" holds true across various team sizes, suggesting that the integration of diverse perspectives is a primary driver of high-impact CE knowledge.

Identifying Missed Connections

Despite the benefits of collaboration, the study identified several "missed opportunities" where fields with high semantic similarity—meaning they deal with related problems—showed low co-authorship intensity. For instance, researchers in Renewable Energy and Wastewater Management operate in highly overlapping contexts but rarely collaborate.

Furthermore, a quantifiable spike in grant funding for technical fields like "Metal Adsorption & Recovery" and "Agriculture & Waste Reuse" began around 2016. While these fields are successfully acquiring resources, they remain somewhat isolated from the broader business and policy discourse that drives the CE narrative.

Conclusion

The transition to a circular economy faces a potential bottleneck: a disconnect between the scholars proposing business models and the engineers building the underlying technology. While the field is successfully attracting diverse talent, the current structure favors business-centric "attention" over engineering-centric "implementation."

To bridge this gap, future efforts must move beyond siloed research. Fostering targeted collaborations between management and technical disciplines is essential to ensure that academic innovation translates into scalable, real-world industry applications. The data is clear: the most impactful path forward for the Circular Economy is through the deliberate crossing of disciplinary boundaries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the European Union introduced its Circular Economy (CE) Action Plan in 2015, CE research has expanded rapidly. However, the structure of this emerging field - both in terms of its constituent disciplines and researcher dynamics - remains poorly understood. To address this gap, we analyze over 25,000 CE-related publications from Scopus by combining conventional bibliometric approaches with advanced machine learning techniques, including text embeddings and clustering. This hybrid method enables both a macro-level mapping of research domains and a micro-level investigation of individual researchers' disciplinary backgrounds and collaborations. We classify CE research into 16 distinct clusters, identifying the original disciplines of researchers and visualizing patterns of interdisciplinary collaboration. Building on this foundation, we ask: Which CE-related research domains receive the most attention in academic and policy contexts? And how are different types of interdisciplinary collaboration associated with research impact? Our findings show that research in business and management attracts substantial academic and policy attention, while engineering research - though less visible - tends to achieve higher funding success. This suggests a positive dynamic in which the former draws attention to CE issues and the latter secures the economic resources necessary to realize them. We further demonstrate that CE papers co-authored by researchers from different disciplines tend to show higher research impact than intradisciplinary work. Qualitative case analyses also highlight this tendency. Centered particularly on collaborations between business-oriented and engineering-oriented disciplines, our findings underscore the importance of interdisciplinary efforts in CE research and offer insights for guiding future cross-disciplinary engagement in the field.
BibTeX
@misc{nishimoto2025advancement,
  author = {Keita Nishimoto and Koji Kimita and Shinsuke Murakami and Yin Long and Kimitaka Asatani and Ichiro Sakata},
  title = {{Advancement of Circular Economy Through Interdisciplinary Collaboration: A Bibliometric Approach}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2507.04923},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.04923},
}
Figure