Advanced modeling of reactive sputtering process with non-linear discharge current density

Tereza Schmidtová, Petr Vašina, Marek EliášChemické 2008

Abstract

Advanced modeling of reactive sputtering process with non-linear discharge current density, paper, interdisciplinary study of plasma physics, magnetron discharges.

Introduction

Reactive magnetron sputtering is a cornerstone technique for the deposition of high-quality thin films, such as oxides and nitrides. A significant challenge in this process is the phenomenon of hysteresis. As the flow of reactive gas increases, the system often undergoes a sudden transition from a high-rate metallic sputtering mode to a low-rate "poisoned" compound mode.

Historically, the Berg model has been the industry standard for predicting these transitions. However, a major limitation of the original Berg model is its assumption of uniform discharge current density across the target surface. In actual magnetron systems, magnetic fields confine the plasma, creating a non-uniform "racetrack" erosion pattern. This study addresses this discrepancy by incorporating non-linear current density profiles into the modeling framework.

Methods

To better approximate real-world conditions, the researchers modified the Berg model by discretizing the sputtering target into $N$ small concentric annuli. Each annulus is treated as a local system with its own discharge current density ($J$), while all regions interact with a shared reactive gas environment.

The study compared several current density distributions:

  1. Uniform profile: The baseline Berg case.
  2. Triangular profile.
  3. Gaussian profiles: Four variations with different Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) values (0.01 m to 0.04 m).

To ensure comparability, all profiles were normalized to a total discharge current of 0.5 A, with the peak intensity positioned at the target's half-radius.

Comparison of the various discharge current density profiles used in the model, including the uniform Berg case, triangular, and Gaussian distributions.

Key Results and Discussion

The modeling results indicate that the high-current "racetrack" region exerts a dominant influence on the overall sputtering process. Even when the peripheral areas of the target become poisoned, the intense local current in the racetrack can maintain a clean, metallic surface, thereby sustaining efficient sputtering.

Enhanced Erosion and Deposition Rates

A significant finding is that non-uniformity in current density actually enhances performance. Steeper current profiles—those with higher local concentrations—result in higher overall erosion and deposition rates. For instance, at a partial pressure of 20 mPa, the sharpest Gaussian profile (FWHM 0.01 m) exhibited an erosion rate approximately 25% higher than the uniform Berg model. This is attributed to the high local current density's ability to "clean" the target surface faster than the reactive gas can form a compound layer.

Hysteresis and Stability

The non-linear models also predicted shifts in the critical hysteresis points. The transition from metallic to compound (M-C transition) occurred at higher pressures in models with concentrated current. For example, the jump was observed at 42 mPa for the sharp Gaussian profile, compared to 35 mPa for the uniform case. Furthermore, the steepest Gaussian profiles resulted in a hysteresis loop approximately 15% narrower than the uniform model, suggesting that real-world systems may be inherently more stable than previously predicted by simplified models.

The relationship between reactive gas pressure and total gas supply, illustrating the narrowing and shifting of the hysteresis loop for different current density profiles.

Conclusion

By replacing uniform current assumptions with more realistic non-linear profiles, this research provides a more accurate representation of the reactive magnetron sputtering process. The findings highlight the critical role of the racetrack effect in determining deposition efficiency and system stability.

While Gaussian profiles offer a substantial improvement over uniform models, they remain mathematical approximations. Future research should focus on integrating these non-linear profiles into comprehensive 3D simulations that account for complex gas flow dynamics and specific chamber geometries to further bridge the gap between theoretical models and industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Advanced modeling of reactive sputtering process with non-linear discharge current density, paper, interdisciplinary study of plasma physics, magnetron discharges
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmidtova2008advanced,
  author = {Tereza Schmidtová and Petr Vašina and Marek Eliáš},
  title = {{Advanced modeling of reactive sputtering process with non-linear discharge current density}},
  booktitle = {Chemické},
  year = {2008},
}

Loading related content...

Figure