Adoption of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) in China During the Past 10 Years: Consecutive Survey Data Analysis and Comparison of Sino-American Challenges and Experiences

Jun Liang, Ying Li, Zhongan Zhang, Dongxia Shen, Jie Xu, Xu Zheng, Tong Wang, Buzhou Tang, Jianbo Lei, Jiajie ZhangJournal of Medical Internet Research 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

Background: The adoption rate of electronic health records (EHRs) in hospitals has become a main index to measure digitalization in medicine in each country. Objective: This study summarizes and shares the experiences with EHR adoption in China and in the United States. Methods: Using the 2007-2018 annual hospital survey data from the Chinese Health Information Management Association (CHIMA) and the 2008-2017 United States American Hospital Association Information Technology Supplement survey data, we compared the trends in EHR adoption rates in China and the United States. We then used the Bass model to fit these data and to analyze the modes of diffusion of EHRs in these 2 countries. Finally, using the 2007, 2010, and 2014 CHIMA and Healthcare Information and Management Systems Services survey data, we analyzed the major challenges faced by hospitals in China and the United States in developing health information technology. Results: From 2007 to 2018, the average adoption rates of the sampled hospitals in China increased from 18.6% to 85.3%, compared to the increase from 9.4% to 96% in US hospitals from 2008 to 2017. The annual average adoption rates in Chinese and US hospitals were 6.1% and 9.6%, respectively. However, the annual average number of hospitals adopting EHRs was 1500 in China and 534 in the US, indicating that the former might require more effort. Both countries faced similar major challenges for hospital digitalization. Conclusions: The adoption rates of hospital EHRs in China and the United States have both increased significantly in the past 10 years. The number of hospitals that adopted EHRs in China exceeded 16,000, which was 3.3 times that of the 4814 nonfederal US hospitals. This faster adoption outcome may have been a benefit of top-level design and government-led policies, particularly the inclusion of EHR adoption as an important indicator for performance evaluation and the appointment of public hospitals.

Introduction

Digitalizing healthcare is a global priority, yet the trajectories of technology adoption vary significantly between nations. While the impact of the US Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act is well-documented, long-term comparative data on China’s digital health evolution has remained scarce. This study bridges this gap by comparing a decade of survey data from both countries to understand diffusion modes and identify whether challenges faced by China’s centralized, public-heavy system differ from those in the decentralized, private-heavy US system.

Methods and Data Sources

The researchers employed a longitudinal survey analysis combined with mathematical modeling. To ensure comparability, Chinese "EMR Stages" were mapped to US "Basic" and "Comprehensive" EHR definitions.

The study utilized high-authority datasets:

  • China: Annual surveys from the Chinese Health Information Management Association (CHIMA) covering 2007–2018.
  • United States: Information Technology Supplement survey data from the American Hospital Association (AHA) and ONC data briefs covering 2008–2017.
Number of surveyed and responded hospitals in China and the US (2007-2018).

The core methodological tool was the Bass Diffusion Model, which distinguishes between adoption driven by external factors (Coefficient $p$ - Innovation, e.g., government policy) and internal factors (Coefficient $q$ - Imitation, e.g., peer influence).

Results

From 2007 to 2018, EHR adoption rates in sampled Chinese hospitals jumped from 18.6% to 85.3%. In the US, rates rose from 9.4% (2008) to 96% (2017). While the US followed a classic "S-curve" (high $q$ value) driven by peer influence and financial incentives, China’s adoption was more linear (higher $p$ value), reflecting a top-down, government-led approach.

The Scale of Implementation

The absolute scale of China's digitalization is significant. By 2018, approximately 16,772 Chinese hospitals had adopted EHRs—3.3 times the number of nonfederal US hospitals (4,814). China added an average of 1,500 EHR-adopting hospitals annually, compared to 534 in the US.

Shared Challenges

Despite systemic differences, both nations faced identical primary barriers:

  1. Insufficient financial support.
  2. Shortage of IT staff.

By 2014, "vendor inability to deliver" also emerged as a top-three challenge in both countries, suggesting that hospital requirements are beginning to outpace market capabilities.

Discussion and Conclusion

The rapid adoption of EHRs in China can be attributed to top-level design and government mandates, where adoption was tied to hospital grading and executive performance evaluations. However, several limitations exist, including potential self-reporting bias and the distinction between adoption and "meaningful use."

In conclusion, both countries have achieved significant milestones in hospital digitalization over the last decade. Future efforts should shift focus from binary adoption metrics to interoperability and the actual impact of these systems on patient outcomes and global health data sharing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: The adoption rate of electronic health records (EHRs) in hospitals has become a main index to measure digitalization in medicine in each country.Objective: This study summarizes and shares the experiences with EHR adoption in China and in the United States.Methods: Using the 2007-2018 annual hospital survey data from the Chinese Health Information Management Association (CHIMA) and the 2008-2017 United States American Hospital Association Information Technology Supplement survey data, we compared the trends in EHR adoption rates in China and the United States. We then used the Bass model to fit these data and to analyze the modes of diffusion of EHRs in these 2 countries. Finally, using the 2007, 2010, and 2014 CHIMA and Healthcare Information and Management Systems Services survey data, we analyzed the major challenges faced by hospitals in China and the United States in developing health information technology.Results: From 2007 to 2018, the average adoption rates of the sampled hospitals in China increased from 18.6% to 85.3%, compared to the increase from 9.4% to 96% in US hospitals from 2008 to 2017. The annual average adoption rates in Chinese and US hospitals were 6.1% and 9.6%, respectively. However, the annual average number of hospitals adopting EHRs was 1500 in China and 534 in the US, indicating that the former might require more effort. Both countries faced similar major challenges for hospital digitalization.Conclusions: The adoption rates of hospital EHRs in China and the United States have both increased significantly in the past 10 years. The number of hospitals that adopted EHRs in China exceeded 16,000, which was 3.3 times that of the 4814 nonfederal US hospitals. This faster adoption outcome may have been a benefit of top-level design and government-led policies, particularly the inclusion of EHR adoption as an important indicator for performance evaluation and the appointment of public hospitals.J Med Internet Res 2021;23(2):e24813doi:10.2196/24813
BibTeX
@article{liang2021adoption,
  author = {Jun Liang and Ying Li and Zhongan Zhang and Dongxia Shen and Jie Xu and Xu Zheng and Tong Wang and Buzhou Tang and Jianbo Lei and Jiajie Zhang},
  title = {{Adoption of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) in China During the Past 10 Years: Consecutive Survey Data Analysis and Comparison of Sino-American Challenges and Experiences}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=jBT69TuVNu},
}

Loading related content...

Figure