Adolescents' responses to online peer conflict: How self‐evaluation and ethnicity matter

Sheida Novin, Marieke Bos, Claire E. Stevenson, Carolien RieffeInfant 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how adolescents respond to online peer conflict by developing an ecologically valid computer game that simulates peer provocation. The findings reveal that while a sense of coherence generally leads to fewer expressions of displeasure, self-esteem's impact is moderated by ethnicity, with higher self-esteem being linked to more displeasure in Moroccan-Dutch adolescents. This highlights the complex interplay of individual psychological factors and cultural background in navigating online social interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The digital age has created new arenas for adolescent social interaction, with online platforms offering both opportunities and risks. While these platforms are valuable for communication, their anonymity can increase the likelihood of adolescents being targeted, provoked, or harassed. Existing research on adolescent responses to peer provocation often relies on hypothetical scenarios or self-reports, which may not accurately reflect real-time behavior. This study addresses the gap in understanding how adolescents actually respond to online peer conflict in a more ecologically valid setting, and how individual characteristics like self-evaluation (sense of coherence and self-esteem) and demographic factors (ethnicity and gender) influence these responses. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for addressing issues like cyberbullying and potential psychological distress.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel, ecologically valid computerized game designed to simulate online peer provocation. Participants were randomly assigned to play a "cooperation" game with a computer-generated peer teammate. This teammate was programmed to deliver increasingly aggravating chat messages and deliberately obstruct gameplay, simulating a provocative online interaction. Participants' chat responses were coded for expressions of displeasure. To assess the impact of the provocation, participants also completed mood ratings (anger and happiness) before and after the game. The study employed a mixed-methods approach, combining the experimental game with self-report measures for sense of coherence and self-esteem, and analyzed chat responses using multiple regression to identify predictors of displeasure.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 167 adolescents, comprising 92 Moroccan-Dutch and 75 Dutch participants, aged approximately 15.6-15.7 years. Participants were recruited from schools in the Netherlands. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study introduced its own experimental paradigm and collected data directly from participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ecological Validity Matters: The study successfully demonstrates that a simulated online peer provocation can elicit genuine frustration and expressions of displeasure, suggesting that this experimental approach is a more accurate reflection of real-world online conflict than hypothetical scenarios or self-reports alone.
  • Sense of Coherence as a Buffer: Higher levels of sense of coherence (the belief in one's ability to manage difficult situations) were consistently associated with fewer expressions of displeasure, indicating its protective role in online conflict.
  • Ethnicity Moderates Self-Esteem's Impact: The relationship between self-esteem and expressions of displeasure was not uniform. While higher self-esteem was linked to fewer expressions of displeasure in Dutch adolescents, it was associated with more expressions of displeasure in Moroccan-Dutch adolescents. This suggests that cultural background plays a significant role in how self-esteem translates into behavior during online conflict.
  • No Gender Differences Found: Interestingly, gender did not appear to be a significant moderator of responses to online peer provocation in this study.

Key Results

  • The peer-provoking game successfully elicited frustration, evidenced by a decrease in self-reported happiness and an increase in self-reported anger.
  • Expressions of displeasure in chat responses were significantly more common during and after the peer provocation compared to the baseline.
  • A main effect of sense of coherence (SOC) was found: higher SOC was associated with fewer expressions of displeasure.
  • A significant interaction effect between self-esteem and ethnic group was observed. Higher self-esteem was associated with more expressions of displeasure in Moroccan-Dutch adolescents (B = 0.22, 95% CI [.09, .36]), but not in Dutch adolescents (B = -0.07, 95% CI [−.22, .08]).
  • No significant main or interaction effects of gender and ethnic group were found for the proportion of displeasure expressed.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Generalizability: The findings are based on a specific age group (15-year-olds) and ethnic composition (Dutch and Moroccan-Dutch). Future research should explore whether these findings generalize to other age groups, ethnicities, and cultural contexts.
  • Provocation Type: The study focused on mild provocation within a game context. Future work could investigate responses to more severe forms of online provocation, such as cyberbullying.
  • Social Context: The current study involved interaction with an unknown peer. Future research could explore how the presence of virtual onlookers (friends or strangers) influences adolescents' moral judgments and responses during online conflict.
  • Physiological Measures: While the game elicited self-reported emotions, future studies could incorporate physiological measures (e.g., heart rate, skin conductance) to further validate the instrument and provide a more comprehensive understanding of emotional responses.
  • Broader Individual Differences: The study focused on self-evaluation. Future research could examine other factors that might influence responses, such as perceived social support, coping skills, and empathy.
  • Understanding the Moroccan-Dutch Self-Esteem Effect: The authors speculate that the unique finding for Moroccan-Dutch adolescents might be related to social identity theory and the salience of ethnic identity formation. Further research is needed to explore these explanations and the potential role of perceived discrimination.

Summary updated

Abstract

We studied Dutch and Moroccan-Dutch adolescents' responses during online peer provocation and how self-evaluation and demographic variables matter.Provocation by the (computer-generated) peer teammate increased expressions of displeasure.More sense of coherence but less self-esteem was associated with fewer expressions of displeasure, but ethnicity moderated the effect with self-esteem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{novin2017adolescents,
  author = {Sheida Novin and Marieke Bos and Claire E. Stevenson and Carolien Rieffe},
  title = {{Adolescents' responses to online peer conflict: How self‐evaluation and ethnicity matter}},
  booktitle = {Infant},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1002/icd.2067},
}
Figure