Adolescent sex differences in cortico-subcortical functional connectivity during response inhibition

Yu Sun Chung, Vince D. Calhoun, Michael C. StevensCognitive 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how the brain's functional connectivity differs between adolescent males and females during response inhibition tasks. They found significant sex differences in how brain regions communicate, particularly in subcortical areas, and that these patterns change with age differently for boys and girls, suggesting distinct developmental trajectories for cognitive control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the brain controls impulses (response inhibition) is crucial for self-regulation and is linked to various behavioral disorders. While previous research has explored sex differences in resting-state brain connectivity, there's a significant gap in understanding how these differences manifest when the brain is actively engaged in tasks requiring inhibition. This is particularly important during adolescence, a period of significant brain development and a time when sex differences in impulsivity-related disorders become more apparent. The study aims to bridge this gap by examining task-based functional connectivity during a Go/No-Go task, specifically looking at how sex and age interact to shape these neural networks.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated neuroimaging analysis technique called Group Independent Component Analysis (ICA). This method allows them to identify distinct brain networks that show synchronized activity patterns across participants. For this study, they used a high model-order ICA (80 components) to capture fine-grained network segregation.

Key steps in their analysis included:

  • Preprocessing: Standard fMRI preprocessing steps like realignment and spatial normalization.
  • Group ICA: Estimating functional networks across the entire group of participants.
  • Feature Identification: Selecting components that were reliably associated with the Go/No-Go task conditions (correct rejects and false alarms) using statistical thresholds and criteria like fractional amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation (fALFF).
  • Multivariate Analysis: Using a MANCOVA (Multivariate Analysis of Covariance) model to examine the effects of sex, age, and their interaction on the identified functional networks. They specifically looked at both spatial maps (representing the strength of connectivity within a component) and Functional Network Connectivity (FNC) (examining the correlation between the time courses of different components).
  • Univariate Analysis: Following up on significant MANCOVA findings with univariate tests to pinpoint specific regions and interactions.

This approach allowed them to investigate both within-network connectivity (spatial maps) and between-network connectivity (FNC) in a comprehensive manner.

Datasets

The study utilized functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data from 130 healthy, right-handed adolescents and young adults, aged 12-25 years. The sample was balanced for sex (66 boys, 64 girls).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Subcortical Sex Differences Emerge During Active Tasks: Contrary to some resting-state findings, this study revealed significant sex differences in functional connectivity within subcortical regions (like the amygdala, thalamus, and caudate) when participants were actively engaged in response inhibition. This suggests that while resting-state connectivity might show some differences, the demands of a cognitive task can amplify or reveal more pronounced sex-specific neural communication patterns.
  • Distinct Developmental Trajectories: Adolescent boys and girls show different patterns of age-related changes in functional connectivity within certain brain networks. This implies that the maturation of cognitive control systems is not uniform across sexes during adolescence, potentially contributing to observed differences in behavior and vulnerability to certain disorders.
  • Functional Connectivity, Not Just Behavior, Differs: The study found these sex differences in brain connectivity even when behavioral performance on the Go/No-Go task did not significantly differ between males and females. This highlights the concept of compensatory mechanisms, where different neural strategies might be employed by each sex to achieve similar behavioral outcomes.
  • Default Mode Network (DMN) Involvement: The findings suggest that sex differences in functional connectivity extend to the DMN, a network typically associated with self-referential thought and internal attention. This could imply that girls might be reallocating attentional resources differently during response inhibition compared to boys.

Key Results

  • Sex Differences in Regional Connectivity: Significant sex differences were observed in several cortical and subcortical components. Girls showed greater functional connectivity than boys in regions like the isthmus cingulate cortex, right inferior frontal gyrus, thalamus, and amygdala during response inhibition and/or error processing.
  • Age-Related Changes Differ by Sex: Univariate analyses revealed age effects in specific components (e.g., right middle frontal gyrus, superior parietal lobule). Crucially, age × sex interactions were found in the left pars triangularis and bilateral superior parietal lobule, indicating that girls showed weaker functional connectivity with increasing age in these regions, while boys did not show significant associations.
  • Functional Network Connectivity (FNC) Sex Effects: FNC analysis revealed medium-to-large sex effects, particularly among default mode network regions and the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). Girls generally showed greater cross-network integration compared to boys, especially during error processing and successful response inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality and Significance: The authors acknowledge that their experimental design prevents them from directly determining the functional significance of these observed sex differences. Further experimentation is needed to manipulate cognitive processes and test these possibilities directly.
  • Pubertal Status: The study did not include information on pubertal status, which is a critical period for hormonal changes that can influence brain development and connectivity. Future studies should incorporate this to better understand its role.
  • Age Range: The study's age range (up to 25 years) might not fully capture later developmental stages. Longitudinal studies or studies with broader age ranges could reveal more about age-related functional network changes.
  • Task Specificity: The observed sex differences in functional connectivity were found during a specific Go/No-Go task. Future work should investigate whether these differences are conserved across other cognitive tasks.
  • Intrinsic vs. Task-Based Connectivity: While the study focused on task-based connectivity, comparing these findings with resting-state connectivity would provide a more complete picture of how sex influences brain networks.

The authors emphasize the importance of continuing to study sex differences, not just to understand neurocognitive variations, but also to gain crucial insights into the mechanisms underlying psychopathology.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chung2019adolescent,
  author = {Yu Sun Chung and Vince D. Calhoun and Michael C. Stevens},
  title = {{Adolescent sex differences in cortico-subcortical functional connectivity during response inhibition}},
  booktitle = {Cognitive},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3758/s13415-019-00718-y},
}
Figure