Admissibility region for rarefaction shock waves in dense gases

Calin Zamfirescu, Alberto Guardone, Piero ColonnaJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new "rarefaction shocks region" (RSR) that defines the thermodynamic conditions under which non-classical rarefaction shock waves can exist in dense gases. This region is larger than previously defined areas and is crucial for understanding and exploiting these phenomena in advanced applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical gasdynamics dictates that shock waves must be compressive, meaning they increase pressure and density. However, for certain fluids, particularly dense gases near their liquid-vapor saturation curve, non-classical phenomena like rarefaction shock waves (RSWs) – where pressure and density decrease across the shock – are theoretically possible. These RSWs are physically admissible if they obey thermodynamic laws and stability conditions.

Previous work identified a region where the "fundamental derivative of gasdynamics" ($\Gamma$) is negative, suggesting RSWs might occur there. However, it was also observed that RSWs could exist even when $\Gamma$ is positive, leading to confusion and a lack of a clear definition for the conditions under which RSWs are truly admissible. This paper aims to precisely define this "admissibility region" for rarefaction shocks, going beyond the simple $\Gamma < 0$ criterion.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical analysis and thermodynamic modeling. They start by recalling the fundamental Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions that govern the states across a shock wave. A key aspect of their method is the use of the "admissibility criterion" (equation 2.6), which involves comparing the slopes of the Rankine-Hugoniot curve and the Rayleigh line at pre- and post-shock states.

They introduce the concept of a "double sonic locus" (DSL), which represents states where both the pre- and post-shock conditions are sonic (Mach number = 1). This DSL is shown to be a critical boundary for the admissibility of RSWs.

To investigate the influence of fluid properties, they first use the simplified polytropic van der Waals model. Subsequently, they employ more sophisticated multi-parameter thermodynamic models, specifically the Span-Wagner model, applied to siloxane fluids, to validate their findings and assess the impact of molecular complexity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical models and equations of state for fluids, rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond $\Gamma < 0$: The paper demonstrates that the region where rarefaction shocks are admissible is significantly larger than the region where the fundamental derivative of gasdynamics ($\Gamma$) is negative. This new region, termed the "rarefaction shocks region" (RSR), is crucial for a complete understanding.
  • The Double Sonic Locus (DSL): The locus of states where both the pre- and post-shock conditions are sonic (the double sonic locus) acts as a critical boundary for the RSR. It separates regions where different types of RSWs (sonic, non-sonic) are possible.
  • Uniqueness of Double Sonic Shocks: For a given isentrope in dense gases, there is a unique double sonic shock. This uniqueness is tied to the well-posedness of the Riemann problem for these fluids.
  • Molecular Complexity Matters: The size and shape of the RSR are strongly influenced by the molecular complexity of the fluid. More complex fluids tend to have larger RSRs, suggesting a greater potential for non-classical phenomena.
  • Practical Importance: Defining the RSR is vital for designing experiments to detect non-classical phenomena and for developing industrial applications that leverage these effects.

Key Results

  • The paper defines a new thermodynamic region, the rarefaction shocks region (RSR), which encompasses all states from which a rarefaction shock wave can originate.
  • The RSR is bounded by the liquid-vapor saturation curve and the double sonic locus (DSL).
  • The study shows that for dense gases, there is a unique double sonic shock along any given isentrope.
  • Using the van der Waals model and more accurate Span-Wagner models for siloxanes, the authors illustrate how molecular complexity (quantified by $\delta = R/c_v$) affects the size and shape of the RSR. Generally, increasing complexity leads to a larger RSR.
  • The RSR is found to be significantly larger than the $\Gamma < 0$ region, indicating that RSWs can occur under a wider range of conditions than previously thought.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependence: The authors acknowledge that the size and shape of the RSR are dependent on the thermodynamic model used to describe fluid properties. They emphasize the need for experimental validation of these models.
  • Extreme Conditions: The paper notes that some enlarged RSRs derived from the van der Waals model might represent extreme situations not likely to be observed in real substances, particularly when the Rankine-Hugoniot curves cross the liquid-vapor equilibrium region.
  • Experimental Verification: While the paper's results are intended to guide experimental efforts, the authors mention that generally accepted experimental evidence of non-classical phenomena in the vapor phase is still lacking. Future work will likely involve experimental verification of these predicted regions and phenomena.
  • Industrial Applications: The paper highlights the practical importance of the RSR for industrial applications, suggesting that further research will focus on translating these findings into real-world technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the vapour phase and close to the liquid–vapour saturation curve, fluids made of complex molecules are expected to exhibit a thermodynamic region in which the fundamental derivative of gasdynamic Γ is negative. In this region, non-classical gasdynamic phenomena such as rarefaction shock waves are physically admissible, namely they obey the second law of thermodynamics and fulfil the speed-orienting condition for mechanical stability. Previous studies have demonstrated that the thermodynamic states for which rarefaction shock waves are admissible are however not limited to the Γ&lt;0 region. In this paper, the conditions for admissibility of rarefaction shocks are investigated. This results in the definition of a new thermodynamic region – the rarefaction shocks region – which embeds the Γ&lt;0 region. The rarefaction shocks region is bounded by the saturation curve and by the locus of the states connecting double-sonic rarefaction shocks, i.e. shock waves in which both the pre-shock and post-shock states are sonic. Only one double-sonic shock is shown to be admissible along a given isentrope, therefore the double-sonic states can be connected by a single curve in the volume–pressure plane. This curve is named the double sonic locus. The influence of molecular complexity on the shape and size of the rarefaction shocks region is also illustrated by using the van der Waals model; these results are confirmed by very accurate multi-parameter thermodynamic models applied to siloxane fluids and are therefore of practical importance in experiments aimed at proving the existence of rarefaction shock waves in the single-phase vapour region as well as in future industrial applications operating in the non-classical regime.
BibTeX
@article{zamfirescu2008admissibility,
  author = {Calin Zamfirescu and Alberto Guardone and Piero Colonna},
  title = {{Admissibility region for rarefaction shock waves in dense gases}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1017/s0022112008000207},
}
Figure